BWCA BWCA Solo Canoe Comparisons Boundary Waters Gear Forum
Chat Rooms (0 Chatting)  |  Search  |   Login/Join
* BWCA is supported by its audience. When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.
Boundary Waters Quetico Forum
   Gear Forum
      BWCA Solo Canoe Comparisons     

Author

Text

03/20/2020 11:34AM  
 
      Print Top Bottom Previous Next
gymcoachdon
distinguished member(599)distinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished member
  
03/20/2020 12:12PM  
Not sure if you want comments, but here I go!
I have paddled 2 of the canoes you have listed. The Prism, and the Magic. The Prism belongs to a friend, and the Magic is an older Bell that I own.
Both are very easy to paddle with nice glide. I wouldn't think there is much difference in efficiency. The Magic is a prettier canoe to my eye, but that is just aesthetics. Seating in the Wenonah is normally a tractor seat, and normally they have a footbrace. I prefer the bench seat, it seems to give me more options sliding around and relieving pressure points. I loved the Wenonah foot brace so much, that I bought one and installed it in my Magic. There are a few differences: first, the Magic is tough to turn, but the Prism is even harder! Great for long open water paddling, but more work when things get twisty. Second, I have found the Prism to have more initial stability. I have read otherwise, but when standing up in both, my Magic is really squirrelly, and I had a much easier time in the Prism. Both have proven seaworthy when conditions get tough.
 
DanCooke
distinguished member(1271)distinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished member
  
03/20/2020 12:29PM  
Lot more hulls than the ones listed on your chart.
 
andym
distinguished member(5350)distinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished memberpower member
  
03/20/2020 01:08PM  
It is interesting seeing the hulls from different builders on a single image. Two suggestions:

1) add the Souris River boats. They are pretty popular.

2) reorder them by either length or ratio of width/length. Then you could see similar hulls by different builders right next to each other.

But very cool!
 
03/20/2020 03:48PM  
Missing the Wenonah Advantage and the Savage River solos.
 
03/20/2020 06:41PM  
Actually, there was an Advantage, but it's so far out ahead of the others that it wasn't in the picture ;-)

 
03/20/2020 06:46PM  
Ole496: "Actually, there was an Advantage, but it's so far out ahead of the others that it wasn't in the picture ;-) "

Yes !! and they can be reasonably turned with a nice lean and the proper stroke.
 
whitecedar
distinguished member (350)distinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished member
  
03/21/2020 07:21AM  
As Andy and Dan mentioned, many more available hulls, Wenonah Voyageur, Swift Cruiser 16.8, Keewaydin Series, etc., then group them according to their use/specifications. Looking forward to seeing this evolve!
 
jdmccurry
member (45)member
  
03/25/2020 11:40AM  
I have a Prism in carbon with wood trim. I use it for touring (5-7 days) and fitness day paddling, sometimes with fidgety 60 lb. Goldendoodle. I just love the boat and find it easy to paddle in all conditions; with or without loads. I have used it with all kinds of paddles, wood otter tails, carbon bent shaft, and double blade. Works well with them all. I have paddled it in small twisty streams and did not find it difficult to turn. However I am an experienced whitewater solo paddler. The sliding tractor seat lets me trim on the fly to adjust to tail or head winds. If I were to purchase a complimentary 2nd boat I would go for the Northstar Phoenix in IXP for mixed flat/moving water tours and day paddles.
 
      Print Top Bottom Previous Next