|
Boundary Waters Quetico Forum Fishing Forum Leeches or crawlers for walleye fishing in late may ? |
Author
Text
05/16/2021 09:16PM
thegildedgopher: "bobbernumber3: "Leeches on the Gunflint side, crawlers on the Ely side... seriously."
Ok, expand on that.
I’m supposed to fish ely next weekend and was thinking minnows made most sense."
After 20 years off the Gunflint Trail and only using leeches, I've made 6 trips to Ely. Walleyes just ignored the leeches around Ely, but are aggressive on crawlers. Just my experience. And I've never tried minnows.
05/17/2021 08:57AM
bobbernumber3: "thegildedgopher: "bobbernumber3: "Leeches on the Gunflint side, crawlers on the Ely side... seriously."
Ok, expand on that.
I’m supposed to fish ely next weekend and was thinking minnows made most sense."
After 20 years off the Gunflint Trail and only using leeches, I've made 6 trips to Ely. Walleyes just ignored the leeches around Ely, but are aggressive on crawlers. Just my experience. And I've never tried minnows."
Interesting. I ask because this year will be my first on the Ely side.
05/19/2021 02:49PM
Keep'em cool - obviously out of the sun - but not directly in contact with ice- or in my case - dry ice, which smoked them. Place the container in the shade , add some coolness via cold mulch or whatever debris the campsite offers,, only bring in the canoe what you think you will use as they will likely get smoked in daylight hours.
The two loudest sounds known to man: a gun that goes bang when it is supposed to go click and a gun that goes click when it is supposed to go bang.
05/20/2021 06:57AM
Leeches.
They are very easy to keep and hard to kill. Crawlers and especially minnows are very easy to kill (speaking from many heartbreaking experiences).
But... you can kill leeches too. I killed my first batch in 20 trips last week. I kept the leeches in a leech locker. I left the locker on shore for most of a very hot day. Nearly all the leeches died. The best approach is to buy a pound and keep them in a leech locker in the water. Then, just grab a handful to take fishing. Keep those in a leech tamer...
They are very easy to keep and hard to kill. Crawlers and especially minnows are very easy to kill (speaking from many heartbreaking experiences).
But... you can kill leeches too. I killed my first batch in 20 trips last week. I kept the leeches in a leech locker. I left the locker on shore for most of a very hot day. Nearly all the leeches died. The best approach is to buy a pound and keep them in a leech locker in the water. Then, just grab a handful to take fishing. Keep those in a leech tamer...
Fish where the fish are...
05/22/2021 10:21AM
I have done just fine with leeches on the Ely side in May. And I have taken crawlers in August with no issues. Like stated above keep 'em moist and cool and they will be fine. If you get them from VNO you get them in a Styrofoam container that they put a piece of peat moss on top. You just take that out occasionally and dunk it in the lake and squeeze out the excess. Worked great! Also I'm taking both. You just never know. And if they are short biting. Its hard to beat a cut crawler.
05/22/2021 12:50PM
Bring both and minnows if you want the hassle of keeping them alive...I think anyone who says leeches don't work on the Ely side is misguided at best. Every lake is different and provides different forage. At times I have noticed fish bite better on crawlers or leeches or minnows, but I have never heard of one type of bait not working at all for fish in a specific geographic area-it doesn't make sense.
One of the best days of fishing I have ever had was in July last year (in BWCA on Ely side) when I caught four pig walleyes over 20" in three hours (in addition to a bunch of fiesty 3-4lbs smallmouth) and my personal best at 29". I couldn't get the walleyes to bite dragging a crawler on a harness or trolling crankbaits, but they were absolutely crushing a medium leech and a small 1/8oz green jig head.
It really just depends on the mood of the fish and what is in season at their favorite buffet. General rule of thumb for me is minnows in May, switch to leeches as soon as they are available at the bait shop (usually June) and mix in crawlers as often as I can (generally most productive mid-june through mid-august.
One of the best days of fishing I have ever had was in July last year (in BWCA on Ely side) when I caught four pig walleyes over 20" in three hours (in addition to a bunch of fiesty 3-4lbs smallmouth) and my personal best at 29". I couldn't get the walleyes to bite dragging a crawler on a harness or trolling crankbaits, but they were absolutely crushing a medium leech and a small 1/8oz green jig head.
It really just depends on the mood of the fish and what is in season at their favorite buffet. General rule of thumb for me is minnows in May, switch to leeches as soon as they are available at the bait shop (usually June) and mix in crawlers as often as I can (generally most productive mid-june through mid-august.
Subscribe to Thread
Become a member of the bwca.com community to subscribe to thread and get email updates when new posts are added. Sign up Here