|
Boundary Waters Quetico Forum Fishing Forum Tiger Bay Surpise |
Author
Text
10/16/2021 02:53PM
The fishing was pretty slow for the weekend of October 1st and I wasn't pulling in anything really sizeable. On literally my last cast of the night I thought, "I wonder if something is hiding behind that boulder that is set away from the rest of them..." BOOOM! Water explodes and this hog comes fully out of the water and then gives me a fight I will never forget. I included the picture on the paddle for some scale. I am guessing 22 inches and about 6-6.5 pounds.
Who I am precedes what I do, not the other way around.
10/18/2021 10:16AM
Sounds like a fun story and a welcome jolt of excitement for you. Very nice Smallmouth. Fall fishing can be hit or miss for sure.
Hard to tell from a picture how big fish are but I'd guess more like 19-20" and 4.5 pounds. No way that fish is anywhere close to 6lbs, it'd have to have a lot more girth to weigh that much. Its hard to say from 2 pictures though, just throwing my guess out there.
Hard to tell from a picture how big fish are but I'd guess more like 19-20" and 4.5 pounds. No way that fish is anywhere close to 6lbs, it'd have to have a lot more girth to weigh that much. Its hard to say from 2 pictures though, just throwing my guess out there.
10/19/2021 11:33AM
For comparison, here's a measured 19" bass. Note my elbow is behind my head to draw the bass as close as possible to my body and I'm nearly 6' tall. I'm guessing it weighed four pounds. Maybe 4.5 pounds.
Now, here's another 19" bass, but slimmer. However, this time my arm is mostly extended, making the fish look longer. I don't think it weighed four pounds. Too skinny.
I will paddle eternal, Kevlar and carbon.
10/20/2021 07:16AM
bobbernumber3: "missmolly: "Here's yet another 19" bass and a brute. You can see the weight in its buffalo back.
"
20 - 2 = 18. But in your boat it's your measurement."
That fish looks like it should go 20 if it had a tail/backend. Maybe it is the photo angle but the backend doesn’t look right.
T
10/20/2021 07:17AM
timatkn: "bobbernumber3: "missmolly: "Here's yet another 19" bass and a brute. You can see the weight in its buffalo back.
"
20 - 2 = 18. But in your boat it's your measurement."
That fish looks like it should go 20 if it had a tail/backend. Maybe it is the photo angle but the backend doesn’t look right.
T"
It does have a full tail, T. It's lying in water and the water is bending the light. The bulk of the tail is underwater. Look carefully and you'll see it. It's a 19" fish. I was just joshing bn3 because he likes subtraction.
I will paddle eternal, Kevlar and carbon.
10/20/2021 07:52PM
missmolly: "timatkn: "bobbernumber3: "missmolly: "Here's yet another 19" bass and a brute. You can see the weight in its buffalo back.
"
20 - 2 = 18. But in your boat it's your measurement."
That fish looks like it should go 20 if it had a tail/backend. Maybe it is the photo angle but the backend doesn’t look right.
T"
It does have a full tail, T. It's lying in water and the water is bending the light. The bulk of the tail is underwater. Look carefully and you'll see it. It's a 19" fish. I was just joshing bn3 because he likes subtraction. "
Okay I see it now. Ya know officially you are supposed to pinch the tail. I think if you did that it would be between 19 1/4 and 19 1/2. Might make 20 with a fish stretcher or if you have the MN DNR do the measuring :)
T
10/21/2021 07:50AM
timatkn: "bobbernumber3: "missmolly: "Here's yet another 19" bass and a brute. You can see the weight in its buffalo back.
"
20 - 2 = 18. But in your boat it's your measurement."
That fish looks like it should go 20 if it had a tail/backend. Maybe it is the photo angle but the backend doesn’t look right.
T"
I missed seeing the tail as well. Never second guess another fisherman's measurement...
10/22/2021 07:19AM
bobbernumber3: "timatkn: "bobbernumber3: "missmolly: "Here's yet another 19" bass and a brute. You can see the weight in its buffalo back.
"
20 - 2 = 18. But in your boat it's your measurement."
That fish looks like it should go 20 if it had a tail/backend. Maybe it is the photo angle but the backend doesn’t look right.
T"
I missed seeing the tail as well. Never second guess another fisherman's measurement..."
It's a horrible photo. I was so proud of my plan to measure all fish on that trip on the tape, but a third of them moved as I took the photo and all the photos look horrible because of the water and canoe clutter.
I will paddle eternal, Kevlar and carbon.
10/24/2021 08:26PM
bobbernumber3: "bumabu: ",,,,Gonna measure my paddle tonight. "
Well. What did it measure? Or just stick with the 22"?"
I know such an amateur move…just say 22…don’t mention you haven’t measured the paddle…certainly don’t give a timeline for measurement :)
T
10/24/2021 09:26PM
ericinely: "missmolly: "T, I don't do those fractional measurements. For me, a 19 and 3/4 inch fish is a 19 inch fish. "
You should. There's generally a huge difference between a 20" and a 20 7/8" smallmouth..."
Did you see the "Length and Weight" thread with the link to the biggest Texas smallmouth? A shorter fish can outweigh a longer fish, which is why I give more weight to backs and bellies than length.
I will paddle eternal, Kevlar and carbon.
10/26/2021 01:50PM
missmolly: "T, I don't do those fractional measurements. For me, a 19 and 3/4 inch fish is a 19 inch fish. "Remember your grade school math!
19.5 you round up always. 19.4 and you round down!
You're going to HELL and you're going to drag me with ya!! -Gunsmoke
11/17/2021 10:04AM
Finally measured my paddle and the fish taped out to 20" on the nose. My brother who is an avid angler said that he would guess the weight at 5.5 pounds considering how thick it was. So that's what I am recording it as. No matter what, it was by far the funnest smallmouth I have ever boated and was the largest by a little bit. Seeing that fish explode completely out of the water and tail dance has to be my greatest fishing memory to date.
Who I am precedes what I do, not the other way around.
Subscribe to Thread
Become a member of the bwca.com community to subscribe to thread and get email updates when new posts are added. Sign up Here