|
Boundary Waters Quetico Forum Listening Point - General Discussion "Rowing" a canoe vs paddling |
Author
Text
04/12/2022 10:10AM
Some of you may be following Ellen Falterman as she trains for her rowing adventure across the Atlantic. CW Goetz (The Camping Show) did a recent interview with her and she took him out in what appears to be a 17' Grumman set up with a pretty cool rowing rig.
You can see moving crazy fast (Facebook link) here: Rowing A Canoe
You can see moving crazy fast (Facebook link) here: Rowing A Canoe
We all have to believe in something. I believe I'll go paddle.
04/12/2022 12:02PM
We have a Spring Creek rowing rig with 6-7 foot oars for a alumacraft canoe because my wife likes to row. It is basically impossible for me to keep up with her with a paddle. Throw in 9 foot competition oars, a sliding seat, and an elite rower and the thing will fly. Canoes are pretty good rowing craft! They aren’t going to be as fast as a true shell but those are lousy in rough water. Maybe they are close to an open water shell and faster than a rowing skiff.
But yeah, against the rules for the BW. And you want it that way because rowers would crush us all getting to campsites.
But yeah, against the rules for the BW. And you want it that way because rowers would crush us all getting to campsites.
04/12/2022 10:25PM
I row my 16 footer pretty regularly. Easily keep up with tandems and skinny kayaks. The seat hangs from the outriggers. the oars are 7', could probably use 7' 6". It also works as a tandem sitting facing the stern on the bow seat. Partner in the stern seat can paddle or just steer.
04/12/2022 10:40PM
I agree, though portaging the extra stuff would not be worth it for me. I would not hesitate to use oars on a lake that allows motors, legal or not. I am not sure what the rules are about oars and sails on motorized lakes. Anyone want to track that down?
04/12/2022 11:16PM
Oars are considered a machine because they are a lever on a fixed fulcrum. Hence being disallowed in the BW.
I can easily portage my wife’s canoe with the outriggers but would have a problem on narrow trails. Carbon fiber oars are quite light. A sliding seat would add some weight. But put two sliding seat setups in a tandem and that might be a real speedster. Would have to paint it red.
It would seem fair to use oars or sails on a motor lake but I don’t know the rules. Wonder how a small foiling catamaran compares to a motorboat with a 25 horse engine. Hmmm
I can easily portage my wife’s canoe with the outriggers but would have a problem on narrow trails. Carbon fiber oars are quite light. A sliding seat would add some weight. But put two sliding seat setups in a tandem and that might be a real speedster. Would have to paint it red.
It would seem fair to use oars or sails on a motor lake but I don’t know the rules. Wonder how a small foiling catamaran compares to a motorboat with a 25 horse engine. Hmmm
04/13/2022 06:23AM
The rules have not changed. And while I’m not tempted to use oars for camping, I could see us day tripping on Lakes 1 to 4 with our rowing rig. My wife would love the motor free rowing space.
Thinking about oars and sailboats on BWCA motor lakes: if they aren’t allowed then does it require a motor permit given that the FS considers them machines? If so, that would be one route to family camping with a rowboat. Although those permits are tough to get.
Otherwise, one could rowboat camp on FS lakes that are outside the BW.
Thinking about oars and sailboats on BWCA motor lakes: if they aren’t allowed then does it require a motor permit given that the FS considers them machines? If so, that would be one route to family camping with a rowboat. Although those permits are tough to get.
Otherwise, one could rowboat camp on FS lakes that are outside the BW.
04/13/2022 07:41AM
On a trip to lake 3 in 2000 we had a rowing canoe go by our camp. Seems to be a theme with this area. Must be a family or group that does this.
I think it is pretty rare to see. Most likely the logistics of carrying it, but now I see it is considered a mechanical advantage and technically illegal so that is probably why too.
T
I think it is pretty rare to see. Most likely the logistics of carrying it, but now I see it is considered a mechanical advantage and technically illegal so that is probably why too.
T
04/13/2022 09:10AM
People seem to spend a lot of time questioning the logic of the BWCA rules. In the end, the only people who need to justify the logic are the ones setting the rules. The rest of us just get to make the personal choice to follow them, or justify our reasons for breaking them to ourselves.
My understanding: the BWCA isn't a non-motorized wilderness area, it's a non-mechanized wilderness area. Specific exceptions have been for motorboat travel on a few select lakes. Rowing mechanism does not equal motorboat, therefore there is no exception that allows it. In my opinion those exceptions will never be expanded to include additional mechanized forms of travel. If anything, it will move in a more restrictive direction in the future.
My understanding: the BWCA isn't a non-motorized wilderness area, it's a non-mechanized wilderness area. Specific exceptions have been for motorboat travel on a few select lakes. Rowing mechanism does not equal motorboat, therefore there is no exception that allows it. In my opinion those exceptions will never be expanded to include additional mechanized forms of travel. If anything, it will move in a more restrictive direction in the future.
04/13/2022 11:43AM
The rules state that anything that gives you a fixed mechanical advantage to travel is not allowed. For example, you could use a hand held sail, but not a fixed sail or rudder. This also applies to rowing, paddle boats, bicycles on land, and any new or crazy idea that someone comes up with and wants to try out in the boundary waters.
The rule might seem a little dumb when you think about it from our perspective, but outsiders looking in might see the transportation issue a little differently and try different ideas. This rule just gives the FS the ability to reject different ideas that might be dumb, dangerous, or change the spirit of the boundary waters.
The rule might seem a little dumb when you think about it from our perspective, but outsiders looking in might see the transportation issue a little differently and try different ideas. This rule just gives the FS the ability to reject different ideas that might be dumb, dangerous, or change the spirit of the boundary waters.
04/13/2022 04:33PM
seems awfully silly that oars would be illegal in the bwca. I always thought it was funny that vexilars are allowed into the bwca in the winter because they technically have a [brushless] motor in them. So with that, you are allowed to bring a motor of sorts, but are not able to bring an oar. Makes a lot of sense.
04/14/2022 08:31AM
jwmiller39: "seems awfully silly that oars would be illegal in the bwca. I always thought it was funny that vexilars are allowed into the bwca in the winter because they technically have a [brushless] motor in them. So with that, you are allowed to bring a motor of sorts, but are not able to bring an oar. Makes a lot of sense. "
It’s hard to find the actual by laws/rules anymore, but if I remember correctly it’s about using a mechanical advantage to make work easier. Sails, oars, motors, chain saws, wheels, bikes, snowmobiles etc…It’s intentionally vague as new mechanical advantages can be developed. So the by-laws cover them all. I believe at one time when specific devices were mentioned instead of mechanical advantage devices there was a year or two there was an explosion of snowmobile use in the BWCAW as an example. Maybe you can make a case to outlaw a vexilar? I’ve never drug one out but it seems to fall more under electrical devices than mechanical advantage.
T
04/14/2022 12:28PM
I think I might disagree that oars are not allowed. Looking at the regulations, motorized is defined (293.6):
(a) Mechanical transport, as herein used, shall include any
contrivance which travels over ground, snow, or water on wheels,
tracks,skids, or by floatation and is propelled by a nonliving power source
contained or carried on or within the device.
(b) Motorized equipment, as herein used, shall include any machine
activated by a nonliving power source, except that small battery powered, hand-carried devices such as flashlights, shavers, and Geiger
counters are not classed as motorized equipment.
I think the key is that a mechanical advantage does not equal mechanized' Per Webster, the relevant definition of mechanize is:
- to equip with machinery especially to replace human or animal labor
The power source is still provided by a person, thus it is not mechanized.
I think part (b) also answers the vexilar question.
https://winapps.umt.edu/winapps/media2/wilderness/NWPS/documents/FS/FS_Wilderness_Regulations.pdf
(a) Mechanical transport, as herein used, shall include any
contrivance which travels over ground, snow, or water on wheels,
tracks,skids, or by floatation and is propelled by a nonliving power source
contained or carried on or within the device.
(b) Motorized equipment, as herein used, shall include any machine
activated by a nonliving power source, except that small battery powered, hand-carried devices such as flashlights, shavers, and Geiger
counters are not classed as motorized equipment.
I think the key is that a mechanical advantage does not equal mechanized' Per Webster, the relevant definition of mechanize is:
- to equip with machinery especially to replace human or animal labor
The power source is still provided by a person, thus it is not mechanized.
I think part (b) also answers the vexilar question.
https://winapps.umt.edu/winapps/media2/wilderness/NWPS/documents/FS/FS_Wilderness_Regulations.pdf
04/14/2022 01:03PM
One thing that I don't think has been mentioned is scenery and safety. I met a guy a long time ago who had a solo rowing set-up. Regardless of the technicality of the rules, he spoke enthusiastically about rowing LLC and Crooked and how much he loved the speed and efficiency. I asked him how he managaed to avoid water hazards...rocks, dead heads, etc. He said he just looked behind him often enough and felt as safe as he would be if he was paddling solo.
I'd miss the scenery. I know where I've been...I would want to see where I'm going. I supposed one could fashion a rear-view mirror set-up, or maybe use a cycling mirror that attaches to glasses. I just don't think I could get used to it.
Mike
I'd miss the scenery. I know where I've been...I would want to see where I'm going. I supposed one could fashion a rear-view mirror set-up, or maybe use a cycling mirror that attaches to glasses. I just don't think I could get used to it.
Mike
I did indeed rock down to Electric Avenue, but I did not take it higher. I regret that.
04/14/2022 01:48PM
Per Federal Code 43 CFR § 6301.5 Definitions - Management of Wilderness Areas
Mechanical transport means any vehicle, device, or contrivance for moving people or material in or over land, water, snow, or air that has moving parts. This includes, but is not limited to, sailboats, sailboards, hang gliders, parachutes, bicycles, game carriers, carts, and wagons. The term does not include wheelchairs, nor does it include horses or other pack stock, skis, snowshoes, non-motorized river craft including, but not limited to, drift boats, rafts, and canoes, or sleds, travois, or similar devices without moving parts.
Would think that drift boats & rafts (both having oars) would be saying that oars are not prohibited.
Cheers
Mechanical transport means any vehicle, device, or contrivance for moving people or material in or over land, water, snow, or air that has moving parts. This includes, but is not limited to, sailboats, sailboards, hang gliders, parachutes, bicycles, game carriers, carts, and wagons. The term does not include wheelchairs, nor does it include horses or other pack stock, skis, snowshoes, non-motorized river craft including, but not limited to, drift boats, rafts, and canoes, or sleds, travois, or similar devices without moving parts.
Would think that drift boats & rafts (both having oars) would be saying that oars are not prohibited.
Cheers
Jakthund: "I think I might disagree that oars are not allowed. Looking at the regulations, motorized is defined (293.6):
(a) Mechanical transport, as herein used, shall include any
contrivance which travels over ground, snow, or water on wheels,
tracks,skids, or by floatation and is propelled by a nonliving power source
contained or carried on or within the device.
(b) Motorized equipment, as herein used, shall include any machine
activated by a nonliving power source, except that small battery powered, hand-carried devices such as flashlights, shavers, and Geiger
counters are not classed as motorized equipment.
I think the key is that a mechanical advantage does not equal mechanized' Per Webster, the relevant definition of mechanize is:
- to equip with machinery especially to replace human or animal labor
The power source is still provided by a person, thus it is not mechanized.
I think part (b) also answers the vexilar question.
https://winapps.umt.edu/winapps/media2/wilderness/NWPS/documents/FS/FS_Wilderness_Regulations.pdf"
Subscribe to Thread
Become a member of the bwca.com community to subscribe to thread and get email updates when new posts are added. Sign up Here