|
Boundary Waters Quetico Forum Listening Point - General Discussion Contingency Permits - Necessary Practice or Bad Etiquette
|
Author
Text
10/03/2025 12:13PM
So, under the thread on the 2026 fee increases we got into a discussion on contingency permits which I pejoratively called "permit squatting." By "contingency permitting" I mean the practice of reserving several permits in advance with the likelihood that one or more of the permits will be cancelled or left unused without cancelling.
While strictly within the rules, I believe that this is bad etiquette. My arguments are:
1. It is clearly now the predominant trend - something like 60% of all issued permits go unused and half of those are no-shows, permits that are not cancelled so cannot be claimed by another party. With some searching this data is available somewhere within the USFS website. I may be somewhat off quoting these from memory, but only marginally;
2. There are many people who would otherwise reserve an "intentional permit," one they have a great deal of confidence they will use, well after the January opening but cannot react on short notice to cancelled dates that open up, even with a month's notice. Folks need to negotiate vacation time at work, coordinate with their party, and otherwise plan. For most working people, that precludes a January commitment. I am especially concerned with folks from greater than one day's drive who need to arrange for their travel to and from the BWCA in addition to their time inside, because I am in that cohort, as are most of my friends and family;
3. In addition to BWCA losing revenue under the current cancellation policy, outfitters and other businesses who depend on BWCA lose significant revenue and therefore the ability to provide better employment opportunities. Employment issues are the primary argument for opening up the area to further minimg and logging;
4. The most effective means for USFS to prevent contingency permits would be to blacklist or otherwise throttle repeat offenders, but life happens and people who cancel permits for other than contingency reasons might be accidentally included in that group.
I'll leave it for the pro-contingency folks to argue their cause. I understand what has been said and empathize with their reasoning, but I feel it does not rise above the objections above.
Your thoughts ....
While strictly within the rules, I believe that this is bad etiquette. My arguments are:
1. It is clearly now the predominant trend - something like 60% of all issued permits go unused and half of those are no-shows, permits that are not cancelled so cannot be claimed by another party. With some searching this data is available somewhere within the USFS website. I may be somewhat off quoting these from memory, but only marginally;
2. There are many people who would otherwise reserve an "intentional permit," one they have a great deal of confidence they will use, well after the January opening but cannot react on short notice to cancelled dates that open up, even with a month's notice. Folks need to negotiate vacation time at work, coordinate with their party, and otherwise plan. For most working people, that precludes a January commitment. I am especially concerned with folks from greater than one day's drive who need to arrange for their travel to and from the BWCA in addition to their time inside, because I am in that cohort, as are most of my friends and family;
3. In addition to BWCA losing revenue under the current cancellation policy, outfitters and other businesses who depend on BWCA lose significant revenue and therefore the ability to provide better employment opportunities. Employment issues are the primary argument for opening up the area to further minimg and logging;
4. The most effective means for USFS to prevent contingency permits would be to blacklist or otherwise throttle repeat offenders, but life happens and people who cancel permits for other than contingency reasons might be accidentally included in that group.
I'll leave it for the pro-contingency folks to argue their cause. I understand what has been said and empathize with their reasoning, but I feel it does not rise above the objections above.
Your thoughts ....
10/03/2025 12:52PM
You have too much faith in humans. Personally I think a fair amount of this activity is intentional blocking of other parties with ZERO intention of ever using more than one of the permits obtained for the desired EP and entry date.
Pick four or more putative leaders and list the other party members on all the permits they will not be ”leading.” If you think the feds might pick up on this, use initials, full first names and shortened first names alternately to avoid detection. Cancel all but one at the last minute and enjoy your own ”private” EP and/or route.
The penalties are FAR too miniscule to deter this nefarious activity, especially when spread among multiple party members.
Pick four or more putative leaders and list the other party members on all the permits they will not be ”leading.” If you think the feds might pick up on this, use initials, full first names and shortened first names alternately to avoid detection. Cancel all but one at the last minute and enjoy your own ”private” EP and/or route.
The penalties are FAR too miniscule to deter this nefarious activity, especially when spread among multiple party members.
10/03/2025 02:36PM
Maybe call me lucky, but I've never had to cancel a permit. I've also never booked a permit I did not intend to use on that exact date, nor have I considered booking a permit I did not have an already planned trip for. When I trip with other adults/groups we have the trip planned out first, then book the permit. If that means we don't get our first-choice entry point... so be it, it's still the Boundary Waters. I personally feel this should be the norm and as gravelroad mentioned, I might just have too much faith in humanity. Just because the electronic system allows for the behavior to occur doesn't make it an appropriate excuse to engage in the behavior. Don’t get me wrong, there’s perfectly good reasons to cancel a permit, but for the purpose of having a contingency permit is not one of them.
I mentioned this in another thread, but it was par for the course at other locations I camped at this summer in the Superior region as well. Twelve Mile beach in MI for example. Every campsite, every day, was booked all summer, but while we spent a long weekend there over half the campground remained empty despite being fully reserved. We may not be able to change other’s behaviors but it’s my opinion that we should be setting the example as members of this group, not contributing to the issue.
I mentioned this in another thread, but it was par for the course at other locations I camped at this summer in the Superior region as well. Twelve Mile beach in MI for example. Every campsite, every day, was booked all summer, but while we spent a long weekend there over half the campground remained empty despite being fully reserved. We may not be able to change other’s behaviors but it’s my opinion that we should be setting the example as members of this group, not contributing to the issue.
10/03/2025 03:41PM
I wanted to get the data right. Below is the link to the USFS report on BWCA permits. In that report USFS states:
"Reservations made on the last Wednesday in January have more than doubled in five years. In 2024, 57% of cancellations and 59% of No-Shows were from reservations made during the on sale, suggesting visitors continue to reserve more permits than they can use. When visitors reserve only the permit they can use, entry points have more quota available, groups have more time to plan trips that fit their skill level and others have the opportunity to experience the wilderness."
How many no-shows and cancellations? For Quota Overnight Paddle:
Permits: 20,948
No-Shows: 2,110
Cancellations: 9,374
Cancel<30 days: 6,655*
* - projecting overall rates onto QOP numbers. USFS' cancellation notification time data lumps all quota overnight permits including hiking and motor boats, I think we can assume there is only slight variation, at best, between the sensibilities of paddlers and the others. Only 29% of these cancellations were made with more than 30 days notice, with 41% of cancellations made within 4 or fewer days until the entry date. Of all the cancellations, only 11%, those cancelling 0-1 days prior to the entry date, were penalized. the rest received a full refund of their fees.
So, almost 9,000 QOP permits were "squatted," meaning they were reserved without being returned in a manner that they could be "fairly" accessed by the full public. Of course, 30 days is not a magic number to judge fairness, just the limit of USFS categorization and a generally expressed measure of low-guilt cancellation, Some have argued 60 or even 90 days lead-time is needed to organize a trip, in which case over 11,000 permits were squatted in 2024.
"Reservations made on the last Wednesday in January have more than doubled in five years. In 2024, 57% of cancellations and 59% of No-Shows were from reservations made during the on sale, suggesting visitors continue to reserve more permits than they can use. When visitors reserve only the permit they can use, entry points have more quota available, groups have more time to plan trips that fit their skill level and others have the opportunity to experience the wilderness."
How many no-shows and cancellations? For Quota Overnight Paddle:
Permits: 20,948
No-Shows: 2,110
Cancellations: 9,374
Cancel<30 days: 6,655*
* - projecting overall rates onto QOP numbers. USFS' cancellation notification time data lumps all quota overnight permits including hiking and motor boats, I think we can assume there is only slight variation, at best, between the sensibilities of paddlers and the others. Only 29% of these cancellations were made with more than 30 days notice, with 41% of cancellations made within 4 or fewer days until the entry date. Of all the cancellations, only 11%, those cancelling 0-1 days prior to the entry date, were penalized. the rest received a full refund of their fees.
So, almost 9,000 QOP permits were "squatted," meaning they were reserved without being returned in a manner that they could be "fairly" accessed by the full public. Of course, 30 days is not a magic number to judge fairness, just the limit of USFS categorization and a generally expressed measure of low-guilt cancellation, Some have argued 60 or even 90 days lead-time is needed to organize a trip, in which case over 11,000 permits were squatted in 2024.
10/03/2025 09:07PM
I am with Gravelroad…
There are WAY too many no shows and WAY too many cancels with 30 days or less to be “unintentional”.
Of course they all aren’t intentional…we can all recognize that…but the stats are staggering.
This isn’t new…it’s just gotten worse over time. I can remember issues in 2002 going to Insula in the fall. All Lake one permits taken…then magically over half available on my day of entry. That’s obviously intentional and that was 20 years ago.
I know I’ve said this before but Quetico had this issue in the ‘90’s so they went to a higher initial reservation fee ($111) and a rolling cancellation charge. There is a formula the further out you scheduled and the closer to the entry date the higher the fee to cancel. Vs. canceling early or scheduling later and canceling later cost you minimal. They also do a rolling reservation of 5 months in advance at most which I think is better but statistically didn’t stop the over booking.
The only thing that will stop this is the pocket book…wait and see who replies that is a bad idea…those will be your abusers :) … pretty obvious!
T
There are WAY too many no shows and WAY too many cancels with 30 days or less to be “unintentional”.
Of course they all aren’t intentional…we can all recognize that…but the stats are staggering.
This isn’t new…it’s just gotten worse over time. I can remember issues in 2002 going to Insula in the fall. All Lake one permits taken…then magically over half available on my day of entry. That’s obviously intentional and that was 20 years ago.
I know I’ve said this before but Quetico had this issue in the ‘90’s so they went to a higher initial reservation fee ($111) and a rolling cancellation charge. There is a formula the further out you scheduled and the closer to the entry date the higher the fee to cancel. Vs. canceling early or scheduling later and canceling later cost you minimal. They also do a rolling reservation of 5 months in advance at most which I think is better but statistically didn’t stop the over booking.
The only thing that will stop this is the pocket book…wait and see who replies that is a bad idea…those will be your abusers :) … pretty obvious!
T
“Many go fishing all their lives without knowing that it is not fish they are after.” Henry David Thoreau
10/04/2025 12:21PM
I do think there should be a less lenient refund policy. And there is no excuse for not canceling a permit as soon as you realize you are unable to use it unless you are unconscious or dead. I do like that the policy is now that someone can have their permit canceled if they take out more than 1 for the same time period, but it would be interesting to know how well it is being enforced due to the decreased budgets. I have canceled a permit once, but only because I was watching for one to open up at a preferred entry point.
It would also be interesting to know how many cancellations are because someone switched to a different date or a different EP. I'm sure the percentage is pretty high.
It would also be interesting to know how many cancellations are because someone switched to a different date or a different EP. I'm sure the percentage is pretty high.
10/04/2025 12:34PM
straighthairedcurly: "I do think there should be a less lenient refund policy. And there is no excuse for not canceling a permit as soon as you realize you are unable to use it unless you are unconscious or dead. I do like that the policy is now that someone can have their permit canceled if they take out more than 1 for the same time period, but it would be interesting to know how well it is being enforced due to the decreased budgets. I have canceled a permit once, but only because I was watching for one to open up at a preferred entry point.
It would also be interesting to know how many cancellations are because someone switched to a different date or a different EP. I'm sure the percentage is pretty high."
I'm curious if that overlap policy is being enforced in the database code, manually, or not at all. I can't imagine there is enough manpower to do it manually, so it must either be automatically, and thus uniformly applied, or not at all.
Hmmm. That's an interesting twist to my query. I don't feel swapping EPs is particularly bad form - someone else cancelled that permit you swapped for, so any bad juju goes to that person, in my humble opinion. The only exception would be if you had then swapped outfitters or lodging that then left those businesses with vacancies they might have otherwise filled. Cancellations hurt them deeply. That is why when I had to cancel this year, I took a new permit that could be served by the same lodge & outfitter even though they said my deposit would be good through 2026.
10/04/2025 02:35PM
Raise the fees and make them non-refundable.
I'm all for it. I would love for it to go back to the days (early 2000's) when we could decide on doing a trip this next weekend and go find many viable permits still available or decide on doing a trip in two or three weeks and get the exact permit you want.
Today to try and plan all my trips in January...life's busy, work commitments happen, kids sport activities happen, life happens and every year for the last handful of years i've had to cancel and/or re-book permits.
I book 5 or 6 permits a year with every intention of using every one of them. This year due to Camphouse fire, and a work commitment I had to cancel two of those permits. I cancel them as soon as I know. I was able to make my other three trips and take two other day trips (self issue) into the BW.
Is there hoarding - for sure! Are people playing games with the system and blocking others - for sure! Raise the fees significantly and make them non-refundable.
I'm all for it. I would love for it to go back to the days (early 2000's) when we could decide on doing a trip this next weekend and go find many viable permits still available or decide on doing a trip in two or three weeks and get the exact permit you want.
Today to try and plan all my trips in January...life's busy, work commitments happen, kids sport activities happen, life happens and every year for the last handful of years i've had to cancel and/or re-book permits.
I book 5 or 6 permits a year with every intention of using every one of them. This year due to Camphouse fire, and a work commitment I had to cancel two of those permits. I cancel them as soon as I know. I was able to make my other three trips and take two other day trips (self issue) into the BW.
Is there hoarding - for sure! Are people playing games with the system and blocking others - for sure! Raise the fees significantly and make them non-refundable.
"When used separately, women and alcohol can be a lot of fun. But if you mix them, they can turn you into a dumbass." - Red Foreman
10/04/2025 07:10PM
straighthairedcurly: "I do like that the policy is now that someone can have their permit canceled if they take out more than 1 for the same time period, but it would be interesting to know how well it is being enforced due to the decreased budgets."
It’s automated in the system. The only people that can do permits on the same day are not for profits. Usually a designated group leader can do 2-3 permits? Which makes sense.
There are many ways to get around it and people have posted on these threads and on the BWCA FB page how to do it. I do hesitate on posting that as to not encourage others.
T
“Many go fishing all their lives without knowing that it is not fish they are after.” Henry David Thoreau
10/05/2025 11:43AM
I swap or cancel a permit about every year. Availability is always way better on the drive up then it is at 10am on permit day in January anyway! Where I draw the line, etiquette wise, is when a group reserves extra permits for the purpose of keeping them out of other people's hands.
Let's tax the hoarders! If they want to make the BWCA less accessible to others they can at least pay more for the privilege. They talked about upping the per-person fee, why not up the non-refundable reservation fee? It's currently $6. Add any number to that and multiple it by 9,374 and the answer is a bigger budget for our local USFS, most of which would be paid by those that are actively gaming the system.
Let's tax the hoarders! If they want to make the BWCA less accessible to others they can at least pay more for the privilege. They talked about upping the per-person fee, why not up the non-refundable reservation fee? It's currently $6. Add any number to that and multiple it by 9,374 and the answer is a bigger budget for our local USFS, most of which would be paid by those that are actively gaming the system.
10/05/2025 01:06PM
I’d be interested in something along the lines of attaching a personal identifier for every adult member of the party (driver’s license or SSN etc) on the permit. If the permit goes unused or is not cancelled in a timely manner every member is flagged in the rec.gov system and automatically goes to the back of the line for all rec.gov permits nationwide for a year. Something like you’re ineligible for the first week when permits become available. I think this places the onus on everyone to make sure their group is acting with good intentions. It would also keep the focus on permits rather than monetary penalties.
I really dislike when everyone gets punished for the actions of a few. I’m all for increasing fees for BWCA permits in general but if you’re trying use fees high enough to serve as a deterrent you’re unfairly punishing poorer people and families and potentially not at all impacting those with money to spare.
Anyway, just a thought. Curious to hear what others think.
I really dislike when everyone gets punished for the actions of a few. I’m all for increasing fees for BWCA permits in general but if you’re trying use fees high enough to serve as a deterrent you’re unfairly punishing poorer people and families and potentially not at all impacting those with money to spare.
Anyway, just a thought. Curious to hear what others think.
10/05/2025 01:37PM
timatkn: "straighthairedcurly: "I do like that the policy is now that someone can have their permit canceled if they take out more than 1 for the same time period, but it would be interesting to know how well it is being enforced due to the decreased budgets."
It’s automated in the system. The only people that can do permits on the same day are not for profits. Usually a designated group leader can do 2-3 permits? Which makes sense.
There are many ways to get around it and people have posted on these threads and on the BWCA FB page how to do it. I do hesitate on posting that as to not encourage others.
T"
It’s already self-evident and so rampant that I have no concerns about alerting the non-abusers to what is happening. Change will only occur when enough people raise the alarm, and they need to know just how weak the system is at finding and punishing abuse.
10/05/2025 09:11PM
I would change the system to model Queticos . I would like to see canceled permits reassigned at a much lower cost to increase the chance of being used and to offer some benefit to the local people. My first experiences in the BWCA were one or two night trip on days off working for an Outfitter. Had permit fees been expensive we would not have done these trips.
10/06/2025 08:55AM
907Tundra: "I’d be interested in something along the lines of attaching a personal identifier for every adult member of the party (driver’s license or SSN etc) on the permit. If the permit goes unused or is not cancelled in a timely manner every member is flagged in the rec.gov system and automatically goes to the back of the line for all rec.gov permits nationwide for a year. Something like you’re ineligible for the first week when permits become available. I think this places the onus on everyone to make sure their group is acting with good intentions. It would also keep the focus on permits rather than monetary penalties.
I really dislike when everyone gets punished for the actions of a few. I’m all for increasing fees for BWCA permits in general but if you’re trying use fees high enough to serve as a deterrent you’re unfairly punishing poorer people and families and potentially not at all impacting those with money to spare.
Anyway, just a thought. Curious to hear what others think."
I like that...but it would need to go further. It would need to track those that drop their permit or no show and get added to one of their friends permits during the same time period. That's one of the work arounds. I'd like to see a permanent ban for any that do this. Sounds harsh...but word would get out quick and change behaviors. You always need examples!
T
“Many go fishing all their lives without knowing that it is not fish they are after.” Henry David Thoreau
10/06/2025 09:27AM
There are a couple different issues here that contribute to the same problem.
1. People booking permits to make the entry point more private.
2. Contingency Permits where you book 2 or 3 permits so you have options in case something comes up.
3. Swapping permits closer to the date of entry because something opened up or other conditions.
I don't know how common number 1 really is. There is the potential for it, but I would want to see some data backing it up.
Number 2 is the one that I think really happens and is the main cause of the problem. People don't mean to abuse the system but either forget to cancel their back-up permits or cancel them late. That sounds a lot more likely to me than people intentionally trying to keep others out to enrich their own experience. My personal opinion is that a contingency permit is bad etiquette and the practice needs to be discouraged.
Number 3, I am fine with. I wish there was a way to swap permits instead of canceling and reserving a different one. If they do make changes to address number 2, I hope they would take steps to not hinder number 3. For example, if the reservation fee that is non-refundable was raised, they should waive it for trades.
1. People booking permits to make the entry point more private.
2. Contingency Permits where you book 2 or 3 permits so you have options in case something comes up.
3. Swapping permits closer to the date of entry because something opened up or other conditions.
I don't know how common number 1 really is. There is the potential for it, but I would want to see some data backing it up.
Number 2 is the one that I think really happens and is the main cause of the problem. People don't mean to abuse the system but either forget to cancel their back-up permits or cancel them late. That sounds a lot more likely to me than people intentionally trying to keep others out to enrich their own experience. My personal opinion is that a contingency permit is bad etiquette and the practice needs to be discouraged.
Number 3, I am fine with. I wish there was a way to swap permits instead of canceling and reserving a different one. If they do make changes to address number 2, I hope they would take steps to not hinder number 3. For example, if the reservation fee that is non-refundable was raised, they should waive it for trades.
10/06/2025 10:33AM
timatkn: "907Tundra: "I’d be interested in something along the lines of attaching a personal identifier for every adult member of the party (driver’s license or SSN etc) on the permit. If the permit goes unused or is not cancelled in a timely manner every member is flagged in the rec.gov system and automatically goes to the back of the line for all rec.gov permits nationwide for a year. Something like you’re ineligible for the first week when permits become available. I think this places the onus on everyone to make sure their group is acting with good intentions. It would also keep the focus on permits rather than monetary penalties.
I really dislike when everyone gets punished for the actions of a few. I’m all for increasing fees for BWCA permits in general but if you’re trying use fees high enough to serve as a deterrent you’re unfairly punishing poorer people and families and potentially not at all impacting those with money to spare.
Anyway, just a thought. Curious to hear what others think."
I like that...but it would need to go further. It would need to track those that drop their permit or no show and get added to one of their friends permits during the same time period. That's one of the work arounds. I'd like to see a permanent ban for any that do this. Sounds harsh...but word would get out quick and change behaviors. You always need examples!
T "
With how cheap permits are - nothing would prevent them from all picking up thier own permit. A group of 4 - reserves four permits, picks them all up. Permits are way too cheap.
"When used separately, women and alcohol can be a lot of fun. But if you mix them, they can turn you into a dumbass." - Red Foreman
10/06/2025 01:49PM
With how cheap permits are - nothing would prevent them from all picking up thier own permit. A group of 4 - reserves four permits, picks them all up. Permits are way too cheap."
I've spoken with two separate people who have admitted doing this just to hoard an EP. I think someone even posted about doing this in the other thread "because it's within the rules" or something like that.
Raise the prices. Make permits non refundable once the date is under 30 days out of entry date.
10/06/2025 01:56PM
LiquorPugs: "With how cheap permits are - nothing would prevent them from all picking up thier own permit. A group of 4 - reserves four permits, picks them all up. Permits are way too cheap."
I've spoken with two separate people who have admitted doing this just to hoard an EP. I think someone even posted about doing this in the other thread "because it's within the rules" or something like that.
Raise the prices. Make permits non refundable once the date is under 30 days out of entry date. "
Very good points the last 2 posts. Thanks
T
“Many go fishing all their lives without knowing that it is not fish they are after.” Henry David Thoreau
10/06/2025 02:06PM
LiquorPugs: "With how cheap permits are - nothing would prevent them from all picking up thier own permit. A group of 4 - reserves four permits, picks them all up. Permits are way too cheap."
I've spoken with two separate people who have admitted doing this just to hoard an EP. I think someone even posted about doing this in the other thread "because it's within the rules" or something like that.
Raise the prices. Make permits non refundable once the date is under 30 days out of entry date. "
This ploy is technically against the rules if they then form up at a single campsite, which is supposed to be occupied only by a party under a single permit. To enforce this would require inspection of the permit by USFS at the campsite. I have heard of more occurrences of people bending this rule by sharing their campsite for a night with weary strangers than I have of permit inspections by USFS staff. With more funding will we get more staff to enforce the rules? I agree that any party caught "EP squatting" should be banned for an extended period. That goes beyond etiquette.
10/06/2025 03:41PM
I'm not in favor of having more staff to enforce the rules. Only once did I run into a Ranger out there and the guy was a complete jack wagon. We (myself, wife and three yr old son) did nothing wrong and he was just dead set on trying to find something. I don't know if he was trying to impress the younger ranger gal with him or what, but it took some effort to stay composed.
Additionally - i go to the BW to be left alone. I wouldn't want rangers swinging by daily to check on stuff.
I am in favor of developing a permitting system that as a result of fees or structure, minimizes the issues discussed above.
Additionally - i go to the BW to be left alone. I wouldn't want rangers swinging by daily to check on stuff.
I am in favor of developing a permitting system that as a result of fees or structure, minimizes the issues discussed above.
"When used separately, women and alcohol can be a lot of fun. But if you mix them, they can turn you into a dumbass." - Red Foreman
10/07/2025 12:06AM
LiquorPugs: "With how cheap permits are - nothing would prevent them from all picking up thier own permit. A group of 4 - reserves four permits, picks them all up. Permits are way too cheap."
I've spoken with two separate people who have admitted doing this just to hoard an EP. I think someone even posted about doing this in the other thread "because it's within the rules" or something like that.
Raise the prices. Make permits non refundable once the date is under 30 days out of entry date. "
If you make the permits non refundable within 30 days of entry date it removes any incentive to actually cancel their permit. If they aren’t officially cancelled they can’t be reposted and be made available for those who can take advantage and plan a “last minute” trip.
Something needs to be done but this might have unintended consequences.
10/07/2025 05:59AM
Upon reading the last few threads on this topic, I’ve come to the conclusion that some people don’t know the meaning of the word “intend.” In most of these cases they should instead be using a word similar to “maybe.”
"Miller owns that field, Locke that, and the Mannings the woodland beyond. But none of them owns the landscape." - R.W.Emmerson.
10/07/2025 07:06AM
inspector13: "Speckled: "Make them non-refundable."
Absolutely. Who doesn't do that?
"
Non- refundable only works if there is enough loss (initial cost) to limit booking in the first place. Otherwise it would just encourage more no shows. Which are already an issue.
They could say each trip needs to pay for a minimum 4 people (right now it is two), then what you get for a refund is dependent on when you cancel. 3 months out, full refund, a couple days non-refundable. Would encourage people to not overbook and to cancel ASAP. The initial investment would be $166… I’d start there. Once again I am suspicious of people that are against this as to their “intentions” The loss of money is simple to get around…don’t book trips you aren’t 100% certain you can take.
Currently you need to book two people then when you actually check in they refund the second person. I don’t remember the actual percent but suspiciously…a very high percent of no shows per the FS were solo permits. Makes sense if people are scamming the system. I don’t remember when the FS implemented this…but that was the reason. I want to say the no shows per solo percent was in the upper 80’s? But it was in a round table discussionso it could be higher or slightly lower?
T
“Many go fishing all their lives without knowing that it is not fish they are after.” Henry David Thoreau
10/07/2025 07:48AM
timatkn: "inspector13: "Speckled: "Make them non-refundable."
Absolutely. Who doesn't do that?
"
Non- refundable only works if there is enough loss (initial cost) to limit booking in the first place. Otherwise it would just encourage more no shows. Which are already an issue.
T"
Ya - I would raise the price significantly, not just like 5 bucks or even double. But more like a minimum of $50 per adult and $25 per youth. At that point - it likely wouldn't eliminate permit hoarding, but it would sure put a dent in it.
"When used separately, women and alcohol can be a lot of fun. But if you mix them, they can turn you into a dumbass." - Red Foreman
10/07/2025 10:19AM
Are you saying a group of four gets four different permits for the same EP & day to somehow ‘hoard’ a lake. How is that supposed to work, that seems a tad far fetched. How is that going to keep other parties off their cherished spot via portage. What lakes can you pull this off on and the EP has to have 4 permits a day.
If so, I would rate that as bad etiquette and frankly stupid, why waste the money and I don’t see that scheme working out how they planned..
If so, I would rate that as bad etiquette and frankly stupid, why waste the money and I don’t see that scheme working out how they planned..
10/07/2025 11:17AM
The "Sky is falling" crisis mentality with respect to cancellation numbers is tired. This argument fails to appreciate the decision making process of the US Forest Service. The most relevant number is NOT the number of permits issued nor the number of cancellations. The relevant number is; how many visitor/ days is the BWCA utilized during the permit season.
The actual number of BWCA permits available was reduced by 13% in 2022 to reduce the actual number of visitors and reduce resource damage caused by those visitors. Certainly, that reduction decision was not made without appropriate analysis of the rate of permit use, cancellation and non-use.
If the US Forest service felt that the number of visitors was in reality 10% less than ideal, they have the power to and the data to make an informed modification.
Is reserving "Contingency Permits" a novel problem? I doubt it, but if the use/cancellation/non-use patterns change over time I trust that the USFS will eventually change the number of available permits to reflect those changes.
The actual number of BWCA permits available was reduced by 13% in 2022 to reduce the actual number of visitors and reduce resource damage caused by those visitors. Certainly, that reduction decision was not made without appropriate analysis of the rate of permit use, cancellation and non-use.
If the US Forest service felt that the number of visitors was in reality 10% less than ideal, they have the power to and the data to make an informed modification.
Is reserving "Contingency Permits" a novel problem? I doubt it, but if the use/cancellation/non-use patterns change over time I trust that the USFS will eventually change the number of available permits to reflect those changes.
10/07/2025 01:58PM
OCDave: "The "Sky is falling" crisis mentality with respect to cancellation numbers is tired. This argument fails to appreciate the decision making process of the US Forest Service. The most relevant number is NOT the number of permits issued nor the number of cancellations. The relevant number is; how many visitor/ days is the BWCA utilized during the permit season.
The actual number of BWCA permits available was reduced by 13% in 2022 to reduce the actual number of visitors and reduce resource damage caused by those visitors. Certainly, that reduction decision was not made without appropriate analysis of the rate of permit use, cancellation and non-use.
If the US Forest service felt that the number of visitors was in reality 10% less than ideal, they have the power to and the data to make an informed modification.
Is reserving "Contingency Permits" a novel problem? I doubt it, but if the use/cancellation/non-use patterns change over time I trust that the USFS will eventually change the number of available permits to reflect those changes."
The graph in the report of BWCA visitors supports your point: visitation dropped from roughly 166K in 2021 to 150K in 2022. But the trend in total permits was already dropping by 2021 so I would suspect one cause of this drop was the reduction in permits made available and another was transient COVID behavior. Indeed, USFS lists this among the factors in visitation variability from year to year.
These threads seem to always transition into discussions of what USFS should or should not do to address problems. Don't get me wrong, I appreciate the time and thoughtfulness that goes into these perspectives and ideas. My intent was to have a discussion of what we could or should do as the users of the resource because that is something we can effect, and particularly to address contingency permitting.
I did business with the Federal government for nearly two decades, and without casting any judgement, hoping for their internal systems to improve precisely to meet problems in a timely manner is a mental exercise only. Towards whatever ends, I see only two mechanisms USFS have which they can utilize with some agility: (1) throttle the resource directly (change permit quotas like OCDave discussed above; and close or open campsites); and (2) raise or lower fees. When I read that the reservation system was developed by one of the major "Beltway bandits" I concluded that changes to cancellation and refund policies would be difficult for USFS because that would likely constitute a "contract mod" which Federal contractors love and for which USFS likely doesn't have the money to fund. That is the primary reason I was for the 2.5x fee increase alone - changing one thing is more likely to get over the finish line than a complex strategy that will draw lots of detailed complaints.
I do think USFS wants to reduce contingency permits because they say so in the quote I included above. I won't repeat all of it, but they do end that paragraph with "(so) others have the opportunity to experience the wilderness."
I've been up front about my selfishness - I live in Texas and all of my friends and family who could make a trip to BWCA live outside of Minnesota. The closest live in Madison (always our last stop when we drive up) and the furthest live in San Diego. For us, "Black Wednesday" in January is very much a hinderance to planning trips as a party that includes anyone other than my wife and me. We'd love to take folks up there to see why we are so passionate about it, and in the process, add in a small way to the advocacy for its protection. But the process turns us into dictators because we must get the permit before our prospects can commit, "if you go with us it will be on the 25th and you must do this and that." Life doesn't work that way, and when you add the travel arrangements (frankly, something our Minnesota brethren may not fully appreciate) it is nearly impossible to make happen.
The "crisis" is that the BWCA could soon change fundamentally unless it has increased revenue AND advocacy. I'm pretty sure the Minnesota marketplace is fully exposed but most of the rest of the country has never even heard of BWCA. I'm trying to illustrate how, from my selfish viewpoint, there is a nexus between this crisis and contingency permits. "Black Wednesday" is here to stay for the foreseeable future. Only our behavior as users of the resource can be expected to change. If y'all agree, we can act accordingly, and if not, I'll stand corrected.
10/07/2025 08:22PM
scat: "Are you saying a group of four gets four different permits for the same EP & day to somehow ‘hoard’ a lake. How is that supposed to work, that seems a tad far fetched. How is that going to keep other parties off their cherished spot via portage. What lakes can you pull this off on and the EP has to have 4 permits a day.
If so, I would rate that as bad etiquette and frankly stupid, why waste the money and I don’t see that scheme working out how they planned.."
That is exactly what I am saying. I described the method with sufficient detail that I feel no need to repeat myself on the point. The number four was for illustration purposes only. You could do it on Clearwater or Moose or Seagull or any other EP that you wanted to deter others from using. Even an incomplete blocking can reduce the people who can use the EP and/or route in question and improve the blockers’ experience.
10/07/2025 08:45PM
gravelroad: "scat: "Are you saying a group of four gets four different permits for the same EP & day to somehow ‘hoard’ a lake. How is that supposed to work, that seems a tad far fetched. How is that going to keep other parties off their cherished spot via portage. What lakes can you pull this off on and the EP has to have 4 permits a day.
If so, I would rate that as bad etiquette and frankly stupid, why waste the money and I don’t see that scheme working out how they planned.."
That is exactly what I am saying. I described the method with sufficient detail that I feel no need to repeat myself on the point. The number four was for illustration purposes only. You could do it on Clearwater or Moose or Seagull or any other EP that you wanted to deter others from using. Even an incomplete blocking can reduce the people who can use the EP and/or route in question and improve the blockers’ experience."
Yea, what’s so hard to understand? A group of 9 could all get separate permits…the cost is only 6 bucks more per person…Peanuts! Waste of money? Give me a break! I don’t think we can spell it out any more…it’s not far fetched…it’s documented. You are probably too good of a person to think this way…I wish everyone was that innocent.
T
“Many go fishing all their lives without knowing that it is not fish they are after.” Henry David Thoreau
10/07/2025 10:03PM
I should have known, it’s a conspiracy…
Not sure I really buy that theory but it’s not something I’m going to get excited about either way.
If 4 guys each get a permit doesn’t it cost each of them $38, whereas if they put all 4 on one permit it is $38 for the group. Not a fortune but a waste of money. How is it only $6 more for each to get their own permit.
If 9 guys get separate permits for Moose Lake, what good does that do, Moose Lake has 27 permits a day, every day. It’s a stupid scheme, a group isn’t going to have a lake to themselves for very long, if that is the intention.
Not sure I really buy that theory but it’s not something I’m going to get excited about either way.
If 4 guys each get a permit doesn’t it cost each of them $38, whereas if they put all 4 on one permit it is $38 for the group. Not a fortune but a waste of money. How is it only $6 more for each to get their own permit.
If 9 guys get separate permits for Moose Lake, what good does that do, Moose Lake has 27 permits a day, every day. It’s a stupid scheme, a group isn’t going to have a lake to themselves for very long, if that is the intention.
10/08/2025 08:24AM
scat: "I should have known, it’s a conspiracy…
If 4 guys each get a permit doesn’t it cost each of them $38, whereas if they put all 4 on one permit it is $38 for the group. Not a fortune but a waste of money. How is it only $6 more for each to get their own permit.
If 9 guys get separate permits for Moose Lake, what good does that do, Moose Lake has 27 permits a day, every day. It’s a stupid scheme, a group isn’t going to have a lake to themselves for very long, if that is the intention."
Your math doesn’t check out Scat. Remember a solo permit isn’t really a Solo permit. As I’ve explained several times when you reserve a solo permit you actually pay for TWO people. After you check in you get refunded the second person. This was put in place several years ago because the FS has publicly stated this is a problem with people reserving fake solo permits and no showing. So they made the no show more expensive. It was their first effort to stop it, but this is away around it. We aren’t making this up…this is straight from the FS. You know…the people who actually track it :)
So each permit you are paying the $6 reservation fee and the fee for one camper. So getting all solos is just $6 more/person. It’s just one of about 6 ways to circumvent the system Scat. I personally don’t think it is the most often one used. People are just brainstorming how to stop it. It’s complicated and multi-faceted.
Once again I appreciate you aren’t thinking that way so it probably doesn’t resonate. The only thing I can reiterate to you is that the FS is on record that permit hoarding is an issue. We aren’t making it up we are just echoing the information. Saying it isn’t a problem goes against all the evidence, the group in charge tracking it, and those seeing the economic effects on businesses and communities.
T
“Many go fishing all their lives without knowing that it is not fish they are after.” Henry David Thoreau
10/08/2025 08:47AM
scat: "If 4 guys each get a permit doesn’t it cost each of them $38, whereas if they put all 4 on one permit it is $38 for the group. Not a fortune but a waste of money. How is it only $6 more for each to get their own permit.
If 9 guys get separate permits for Moose Lake, what good does that do, Moose Lake has 27 permits a day, every day. It’s a stupid scheme, a group isn’t going to have a lake to themselves for very long, if that is the intention."
Permit cost is per person (was $16 but is increasing) plus $6 for the group booking fee. The $38 minimum is only for solos and the extra $16 gets refunded. A group of 4 would be $70 (16*4=64 plus the permit cost = $70), but 4 people booking their own permit each is $22 a piece $88 total. That's $18 difference for the whole group, once they get the $16 refunded.
Honestly, I wasn't sure how much I believed that people would take advantage of the permit process like this, but looking at it this way, I can see people thinking that having everyone getting their own permit is just more convenient than having to settle costs later on. They could even think that they are doing the forest service a favor by giving them the extra $6 per person if they don't even consider how this limits others.
Also, not every entry point has 27 permits a day. This would be much more effective for entry points with less than 10 permits available each day if they were actively trying to book the entry point only for themselves.
10/08/2025 09:20AM
But what good does booking permits for the same entry point do. They have to portage to a lake which might be full already. And new people are moving around every day and can be on the same lake. You can reserve permits but not a lake or campsite.
I’ll leave it there, I never have a problem getting a permit so what do I care what other people do.
I’ll leave it there, I never have a problem getting a permit so what do I care what other people do.
10/08/2025 10:00AM
Thanks for breaking it down with more detail than I was going to. I just came back on to say it’s $70 for 1 permit of 4 and $88 for 4 solos. $18 divided by 4 isn’t much.
I think they do it to have a higher chance of finding a site vs having a lake to themselves. It’s not the biggest/most common problem in this discussion, but it a part of it.
I’ve been told by multiple outfitters they’ve had groups do this. One example , Rockwood has had groups of under 9 people show up together and take all 3 permits for the day for Lizz with plans to camp together stating they did it so they’d be the only group entering that day.
There is a rule that all people on a permit must camp together , but there isn’t anything in the rules prohibiting multiple groups camping at 1 site as long as they are under the 9 person/4 watercraft rule.
I think they do it to have a higher chance of finding a site vs having a lake to themselves. It’s not the biggest/most common problem in this discussion, but it a part of it.
I’ve been told by multiple outfitters they’ve had groups do this. One example , Rockwood has had groups of under 9 people show up together and take all 3 permits for the day for Lizz with plans to camp together stating they did it so they’d be the only group entering that day.
There is a rule that all people on a permit must camp together , but there isn’t anything in the rules prohibiting multiple groups camping at 1 site as long as they are under the 9 person/4 watercraft rule.
Ride EZ
10/08/2025 11:04AM
scat: "But what good does booking permits for the same entry point do. They have to portage to a lake which might be full already. And new people are moving around every day and can be on the same lake. You can reserve permits but not a lake or campsite.
I’ll leave it there, I never have a problem getting a permit so what do I care what other people do."
The idea is that you don't have to race to the entry point then race another group that launched from the same entry point to get a good campsite.
I think that for Ely side this is less effective, but for entry points that are not completely full all week and spread out like on the Grand Marais side, it would probably be very effective.
10/08/2025 02:15PM
If you make the permits non refundable within 30 days of entry date it removes any incentive to actually cancel their permit. If they aren’t officially cancelled they can’t be reposted and be made available for those who can take advantage and plan a “last minute” trip.
Unfortunate for the permit holder. Bonus for USFS.
OR
Make some sort of permit exchange option. Allow the unfortunate traveler to resell their unusable permits (at a price equal to, or lower than, the original price to prevent scalping)
10/08/2025 02:22PM
SIDE NOTE: This is clearly a sensitive topic on this message board which makes me think that we all (mostly) fall into one of two buckets: we're either in support of fixing/improving the permit system or we want to see it unchanged and do nothing about deterring bad etiquette.
okay, carry on with all the good ideas and reasons why those good ideas are bad ideas. :)
okay, carry on with all the good ideas and reasons why those good ideas are bad ideas. :)
10/08/2025 03:16PM
LiquorPugs: "SIDE NOTE: This is clearly a sensitive topic on this message board which makes me think that we all (mostly) fall into one of two buckets: we're either in support of fixing/improving the permit system or we want to see it unchanged and do nothing about deterring bad etiquette.
okay, carry on with all the good ideas and reasons why those good ideas are bad ideas. :)"
Not quite. I want to minimize bad behavior by pointing out what is collectively considered bad etiquette, because hoping to change the permitting system to eliminate bad behavior is not a practical strategy. Etiquette is, I think, a common understanding of expected behavior WITHIN the rules. That is something very much ours to control as resource users. Raising fees will reduce some bad behavior and is a relatively easy change for USFS to make technologically, but there was significant pushback on this forum a few months ago when it was discussed. Changing the regulations to explicitly forbid the outrageous behavior described above is also within their capabilities, but the reality is that field enforcement is their weak link. That is why folks here look at changing the permitting system, because it is automatic and therefore putatively offers to eliminate bad behavior without the need for field enforcement. But expecting USFS to pay Booz Allen Hamilton even more money (easily a six-figure contract mod) to develop and thoroughly test before public release a handful of new, experimental features in the software is impractical. That's my humble opinion based on my personal experiences with US government contracting. I don't think they are bad ideas, just not practical.
Can we agree:
(1) reserving multiple permits on the same date and EP by one party to thin out the crowd is REALLY BAD behavior; and
(2) reserving contingency permits isn't great behavior?
10/08/2025 05:43PM
This is not an issue and it won’t change. In 40 years I’ve canceled one permit and got a new one for the next day with 15 permits left for that lake. I don’t reserve on the first issue date. I do it in may there are plenty of options.
Chief Lone Watie
10/08/2025 06:33PM
Oh yeah, I forgot on a solo you get a refund of $16 so it’s $22 each not $38. Gotcha
Ok - I guess I can see the theory at least behind that one. They want all the permits so they are the only group entering that EP that day in hopes of getting the best campsite.
Am I the only one who hopes they didn’t get it…
Ok - I guess I can see the theory at least behind that one. They want all the permits so they are the only group entering that EP that day in hopes of getting the best campsite.
Am I the only one who hopes they didn’t get it…
10/09/2025 08:18AM
LiquorPugs: "If you make the permits non refundable within 30 days of entry date it removes any incentive to actually cancel their permit. If they aren’t officially cancelled they can’t be reposted and be made available for those who can take advantage and plan a “last minute” trip.
Unfortunate for the permit holder. Bonus for USFS.
OR
Make some sort of permit exchange option. Allow the unfortunate traveler to resell their unusable permits (at a price equal to, or lower than, the original price to prevent scalping) "
I also wish there was a permit exchange of some sort. Rather than a ticket master type of exchange, I would prefer a tool that allows you to cancel 1 permit and book a different one at the same time and possibly save on some of the permit booking fees. Something that encouraged you to cancel when grabbing a new permit. Trading permits with someone else is just taking that one step further and I think that would be a great option, as long as it is feasible and doesn't lead to a different sort of permit hoarding.
10/09/2025 03:45PM
There are other plausible explanations for the epidemic of cancelled/no show permits. Are there a few among the BWCA faithful who might use some the methods described above. Yup. To the extent that almost 60% of reserved permits are cancelled/no show. IMHO - Not likely.
Solution - Shut down the public online reservation system. The online system shows only open reservations. This allows you to know which cooperator to try calling. All reservations must be made with a cooperator by phone. Require a valid Id number. DL, State ID, passport, military, etc. Cooperators can charge a convenience fee and get 50% of the cancellation/no show fees. (Much like a non-refundable airline reservation.) FS gets the other 50%. No refunds. Rebooked are not cancelled if done at the time of cancellation of first permit. Repeat offenders are banned for X years (X=pick a number) from making a reservation.
To make the reservation system manageable for the cooperators, a rolling system of opening reservations can be instituted. Three months before each month of reservations. e.g. May reservations open Feb 1 etc.
Harsh, maybe, but the damage done to the economy of the area by whomever is hoarding permits is a form of fraud. Nefarious or not, cooperators/outfitters (and it is not just those outfitting businesses that are harmed!) should have the expectation that the full availability of permits allow the market to dictate their success or failure. Not a system that can be gamed and rigged to prevent those who would have liked to (i.e. the full market) from arriving at their doorstep.
Solution - Shut down the public online reservation system. The online system shows only open reservations. This allows you to know which cooperator to try calling. All reservations must be made with a cooperator by phone. Require a valid Id number. DL, State ID, passport, military, etc. Cooperators can charge a convenience fee and get 50% of the cancellation/no show fees. (Much like a non-refundable airline reservation.) FS gets the other 50%. No refunds. Rebooked are not cancelled if done at the time of cancellation of first permit. Repeat offenders are banned for X years (X=pick a number) from making a reservation.
To make the reservation system manageable for the cooperators, a rolling system of opening reservations can be instituted. Three months before each month of reservations. e.g. May reservations open Feb 1 etc.
Harsh, maybe, but the damage done to the economy of the area by whomever is hoarding permits is a form of fraud. Nefarious or not, cooperators/outfitters (and it is not just those outfitting businesses that are harmed!) should have the expectation that the full availability of permits allow the market to dictate their success or failure. Not a system that can be gamed and rigged to prevent those who would have liked to (i.e. the full market) from arriving at their doorstep.
10/11/2025 10:50AM
I have said before the only way to deal with the permit issue is to limit the number of permits a party can apply for. If someone applies for five permits and shuts out someone else, that is wrong. Places out west already limit the number of permits you can apply for. One example is the Enchantment Wilderness in Washington state that also has a lottery like the BWCA. It specifically states: "You may submit ONE application per person with up to 2 alternate choices." Grand Canyon specifies, "Each individual can submit one application per lottery (i.e., one per month)." Yosemite rules are, "Only one application is allowed per lottery, per group." Note in all of these the limit is one.
10/11/2025 11:05AM
GaryInTexas: " ...
Can we agree:
(1) reserving multiple permits on the same date and EP by one party to thin out the crowd is REALLY BAD behavior; and
(2) reserving contingency permits isn't great behavior?"
1) Yes, certainly monopolizing entry permits for a single EP on a single day is a prick move.
2) No, we are all of the type to head into the wilderness with the only certainty being uncertainty. This forum is composed of the exact type of blokes that make contingency plans. I'd contest that is not bad behavior but imperative planning. Personally, my January intentions are for one BWCA trip for the year but, I grab two permits. Once my plans solidify the unnecessary permit is cancelled; usually the second permit is cancelled before May 1 and from my observance, it never goes unclaimed.
A very old wise man once crooned, "You can't always get what you want, but if you try sometimes, well, you might find; You get what you need". Or, to rephrase, if you don't get your ideal permit in January, keep checking back and eventually you'll find one that works for you.
10/11/2025 01:25PM
I wasn't going to reply to this thread because it seems like this deceased horse has already been thoroughly beaten, but what the heck.
On permit day last January I knew I wanted to go to Wood Lake around the 4th of July, but also was aware that my sister was coming for a visit around that time of year. I only get to see her once a year for a few days, so didn't want to miss that. So I reserved permits for the week leading up to the 4th, and the week after. As soon as she finalized her travel plans, which was sometime in February to the best of my recollection, I cancelled the permit for the time period that would have overlapped her visit.
Does that make me a permit hoarder, and thus a bad person? Based on some of the opinions I've seen here, maybe. Luckily for me, I don't give a rat's derriere about anyone's opinion, so it doesn't matter to me. But I just thought I'd share the story in case it helped open someone's mind to the fact that people might reserve multiple permits for all sorts of different reasons.
On permit day last January I knew I wanted to go to Wood Lake around the 4th of July, but also was aware that my sister was coming for a visit around that time of year. I only get to see her once a year for a few days, so didn't want to miss that. So I reserved permits for the week leading up to the 4th, and the week after. As soon as she finalized her travel plans, which was sometime in February to the best of my recollection, I cancelled the permit for the time period that would have overlapped her visit.
Does that make me a permit hoarder, and thus a bad person? Based on some of the opinions I've seen here, maybe. Luckily for me, I don't give a rat's derriere about anyone's opinion, so it doesn't matter to me. But I just thought I'd share the story in case it helped open someone's mind to the fact that people might reserve multiple permits for all sorts of different reasons.
10/12/2025 10:57AM
NEIowapaddler: "I wasn't going to reply to this thread because it seems like this deceased horse has already been thoroughly beaten, but what the heck.
On permit day last January I knew I wanted to go to Wood Lake around the 4th of July, but also was aware that my sister was coming for a visit around that time of year. I only get to see her once a year for a few days, so didn't want to miss that. So I reserved permits for the week leading up to the 4th, and the week after. As soon as she finalized her travel plans, which was sometime in February to the best of my recollection, I cancelled the permit for the time period that would have overlapped her visit.
Does that make me a permit hoarder, and thus a bad person? Based on some of the opinions I've seen here, maybe. Luckily for me, I don't give a rat's derriere about anyone's opinion, so it doesn't matter to me. But I just thought I'd share the story in case it helped open someone's mind to the fact that people might reserve multiple permits for all sorts of different reasons. "
Ive done kind the same thing the last few years. I get a permit for an entry point so I have one and I'll check randomly and if I see one for a different area id rather go I cancel the original permit. I don't care if I'm cancelling a week before entry or a month before.
Another thought if I was to hoard permits to try and get the lake to myself I buy up the permits leading up to my entry date. Not the day of my entry
10/12/2025 12:42PM
Michwall2: "There are other plausible explanations for the epidemic of cancelled/no show permits. Are there a few among the BWCA faithful who might use some the methods described above. Yup. To the extent that almost 60% of reserved permits are cancelled/no show. IMHO - Not likely.
Solution - Shut down the public online reservation system. The online system shows only open reservations. This allows you to know which cooperator to try calling. All reservations must be made with a cooperator by phone. Require a valid Id number. DL, State ID, passport, military, etc. Cooperators can charge a convenience fee and get 50% of the cancellation/no show fees. (Much like a non-refundable airline reservation.) FS gets the other 50%. No refunds. Rebooked are not cancelled if done at the time of cancellation of first permit. Repeat offenders are banned for X years (X=pick a number) from making a reservation.
To make the reservation system manageable for the cooperators, a rolling system of opening reservations can be instituted. Three months before each month of reservations. e.g. May reservations open Feb 1 etc.
Harsh, maybe, but the damage done to the economy of the area by whomever is hoarding permits is a form of fraud. Nefarious or not, cooperators/outfitters (and it is not just those outfitting businesses that are harmed!) should have the expectation that the full availability of permits allow the market to dictate their success or failure. Not a system that can be gamed and rigged to prevent those who would have liked to (i.e. the full market) from arriving at their doorstep."
You’ve gotta realize how unrealistic this is though, right? USFS has heavily invested in the recreation.gov infrastructure and this would close that system to the public it was designed to serve. The way you’re splitting up the pie also doesn’t account for the fact that the website contracting firm gets a share as well.
Think we also need to acknowledge the fact that the demand rate for the permits that go cancelled and unused is nowhere near 100%. Would love to see a survey of rec. gov users who report not being able to take a bwca trip due to lack of permit availability. My guess is the number isn’t big. The optics aren’t perfect and some folks will never be able to look at the cancellation dynamics and accept it—- but I would reason the impact is much smaller than some of you are suggesting. My thought is that the vast majority of people who want to take a trip are able to do so, and that the overall usage numbers are generally in line with what the USFS desires.
Also, among the outfitters I’ve spoken with, I can’t think of any who are yearning to get into the business of operating a call center all year round to handle permit reservations for customers. Why would they want to pay people all year to sit on rec.gov when they have actual tangible work to focus on?
10/12/2025 09:24PM
OCDave: "GaryInTexas: " ...
Can we agree:
(1) reserving multiple permits on the same date and EP by one party to thin out the crowd is REALLY BAD behavior; and
(2) reserving contingency permits isn't great behavior?"
1) Yes, certainly monopolizing entry permits for a single EP on a single day is a prick move.
2) No, we are all of the type to head into the wilderness with the only certainty being uncertainty. This forum is composed of the exact type of blokes that make contingency plans. I'd contest that is not bad behavior but imperative planning. Personally, my January intentions are for one BWCA trip for the year but, I grab two permits. Once my plans solidify the unnecessary permit is cancelled; usually the second permit is cancelled before May 1 and from my observance, it never goes unclaimed.
A very old wise man once crooned, "You can't always get what you want, but if you try sometimes, well, you might find; You get what you need". Or, to rephrase, if you don't get your ideal permit in January, keep checking back and eventually you'll find one that works for you.
"
In these chats I haven't read anybody writing, "so I reserved Bog Lake for the last week in September, just in case." No, contingency permits are certainly of the prime EPs and dates, and that has a rippling effect on other people's plans. What we seem to be arguing is a corollary of the Golden Rule - if you don't want to live with the uncertainty why should you expect anybody else to? Abracadabra, we have Black Wednesday, 60% cancellations and no-shows, and all the ramifications thereof I won't repeat, because my horse ain't dead yet.
I think the more appropriate song is "All I Want is Everything," sung by a very sad, and unwise woman. "It's a big ol' world, big enough, Baby, for a greedy girl."
10/15/2025 01:33PM
NEIowapaddler: "On permit day last January I knew I wanted to go to Wood Lake around the 4th of July, but also was aware that my sister was coming for a visit around that time of year. I only get to see her once a year for a few days, so didn't want to miss that. So I reserved permits for the week leading up to the 4th, and the week after. As soon as she finalized her travel plans, which was sometime in February to the best of my recollection, I cancelled the permit for the time period that would have overlapped her visit.
Does that make me a permit hoarder, and thus a bad person? "
No, this would not be an example of the "bad etiquette" that people are concerned about. At least not myself, but it is admittedly a gray area issue and this is on the lighter side of gray. My issue is if you were to cancel the second permit in June. Canceling in February is plenty of time for someone that does plan ahead to use that permit, canceling a month or less before the date does not.
You could make the argument that any sort of contingency permit contributes to the artificial sense of permit scarcity on permit day, but I personally don't like the idea of there being a single permit day at all and favor a rolling permit release, so I don't feel the need to argue those semantics.
10/15/2025 02:04PM
gravelroad: "You have too much faith in humans. Personally I think a fair amount of this activity is intentional blocking of other parties with ZERO intention of ever using more than one of the permits obtained for the desired EP and entry date."
Eh. I think it's more about folks having multiple options and hedging their bets on weather or actually putting trips together.
“Growth for the sake of growth is the ideology of the cancer cell.” -Edward Abbey
10/15/2025 02:41PM
Reservations should not be allowed. All entry permits should be issued day-of, first come-first served. Problem solved.
"Miller owns that field, Locke that, and the Mannings the woodland beyond. But none of them owns the landscape." - R.W.Emmerson.
10/15/2025 06:04PM
YaMarVa: "Reservations should not be allowed. All entry permits should be issued day-of, first come-first served. Problem solved. "
IMO that would make planning for trips almost impossible. If you are never sure where you're going to be able to go, how do you plan? And don't tell me that you plan every trip the same way, because nobody does that.
10/15/2025 07:00PM
arctic: "gravelroad: "You have too much faith in humans. Personally I think a fair amount of this activity is intentional blocking of other parties with ZERO intention of ever using more than one of the permits obtained for the desired EP and entry date."
Eh. I think it's more about folks having multiple options and hedging their bets on weather or actually putting trips together."
I do too. I've known some. And it is from people only 250 miles away too.
10/16/2025 06:15AM
NEIowapaddler: "YaMarVa: "Reservations should not be allowed. All entry permits should be issued day-of, first come-first served. Problem solved. "
IMO that would make planning for trips almost impossible. If you are never sure where you're going to be able to go, how do you plan? And don't tell me that you plan every trip the same way, because nobody does that. "
Ive made 10-12 trips by just showing up at the Tofte ranger station and getting whatever permit was available. There was no impact on my ability to plan my trip. I could be dropped off at any random EP and I can assure you I’ll be properly prepared. Besides the amount of food I bring and packing appropriately for the time of year (which you don’t need a reservation to prepare for), I pretty much pack the same for all my BWCA trips. So no, it’s not impossible at all, it’s rather easy actually. I think you can find a better counter-point to my argument.
"Miller owns that field, Locke that, and the Mannings the woodland beyond. But none of them owns the landscape." - R.W.Emmerson.
10/16/2025 07:47AM
YaMarVa: "NEIowapaddler: "YaMarVa: "Reservations should not be allowed. All entry permits should be issued day-of, first come-first served. Problem solved. "
IMO that would make planning for trips almost impossible. If you are never sure where you're going to be able to go, how do you plan? And don't tell me that you plan every trip the same way, because nobody does that. "
Ive made 10-12 trips by just showing up at the Tofte ranger station and getting whatever permit was available. There was no impact on my ability to plan my trip. I could be dropped off at any random EP and I can assure you I’ll be properly prepared. Besides the amount of food I bring and packing appropriately for the time of year (which you don’t need a reservation to prepare for), I pretty much pack the same for all my BWCA trips. So no, it’s not impossible at all, it’s rather easy actually. I think you can find a better counter-point to my argument. "
Congratulations! That would never work for my group. If there was no set plan people in my group would never agree to go on the trip. Just because it works for you, that doesn't mean it works for everyone.
This is a good example of why we are having the whole argument here. Some people can pick up and go at any time so they see no problem with people canceling permits a week from the permit date, but others that have to coordinate a group of people with jobs and families that don't allow for that level of uncertainty need to have a plan in place more than a month out to be able to commit. Those that have to plan are the types that are far more likely to bring money into the area, usually because they have to rent gear and/or are traveling a longer distance. From your post it doesn't seem like you rent or get outfitted, and most likely you don't have to travel far if you can just pick up and go, which means you aren't really bringing money into the area unless you go out of your way to do so.
Even if you personally do spend money in the area to support the local economy, it doesn't change the general trend of last minute trips bringing in less money to outfitters and the area in general on average.
10/16/2025 08:57AM
thegildedgopher: "Michwall2: "There are other plausible explanations for the epidemic of cancelled/no show permits. Are there a few among the BWCA faithful who might use some the methods described above. Yup. To the extent that almost 60% of reserved permits are cancelled/no show. IMHO - Not likely.
Solution - Shut down the public online reservation system. The online system shows only open reservations. This allows you to know which cooperator to try calling. All reservations must be made with a cooperator by phone. Require a valid Id number. DL, State ID, passport, military, etc. Cooperators can charge a convenience fee and get 50% of the cancellation/no show fees. (Much like a non-refundable airline reservation.) FS gets the other 50%. No refunds. Rebooked are not cancelled if done at the time of cancellation of first permit. Repeat offenders are banned for X years (X=pick a number) from making a reservation.
To make the reservation system manageable for the cooperators, a rolling system of opening reservations can be instituted. Three months before each month of reservations. e.g. May reservations open Feb 1 etc.
Harsh, maybe, but the damage done to the economy of the area by whomever is hoarding permits is a form of fraud. Nefarious or not, cooperators/outfitters (and it is not just those outfitting businesses that are harmed!) should have the expectation that the full availability of permits allow the market to dictate their success or failure. Not a system that can be gamed and rigged to prevent those who would have liked to (i.e. the full market) from arriving at their doorstep."
You’ve gotta realize how unrealistic this is though, right? USFS has heavily invested in the recreation.gov infrastructure and this would close that system to the public it was designed to serve. The way you’re splitting up the pie also doesn’t account for the fact that the website contracting firm gets a share as well.
Think we also need to acknowledge the fact that the demand rate for the permits that go cancelled and unused is nowhere near 100%. Would love to see a survey of rec. gov users who report not being able to take a bwca trip due to lack of permit availability. My guess is the number isn’t big. The optics aren’t perfect and some folks will never be able to look at the cancellation dynamics and accept it—- but I would reason the impact is much smaller than some of you are suggesting. My thought is that the vast majority of people who want to take a trip are able to do so, and that the overall usage numbers are generally in line with what the USFS desires.
Also, among the outfitters I’ve spoken with, I can’t think of any who are yearning to get into the business of operating a call center all year round to handle permit reservations for customers. Why would they want to pay people all year to sit on rec.gov when they have actual tangible work to focus on?"
The original question is to what extent are these practices of reserving "contingency permits or black out permits" in need of some type of response by the powers that run the permit system. I see the permit system as serving the wider economy, not just the wilderness traveler. To the extent that these practices negatively impact the economic viability of the region, they are a threat to the entire federal wilderness system and the ecological foundation that this system protects. Further, to the extent that these manipulator forces are allowed to marginalize the economy that has grown up to support the visitors to these places, the more likely those places are to be shrunk, eliminated, or allowed to be ecologically damaged in the name of greater economic forces (no matter how short term).
How would we "know" how many of the cancelled permits would actually get used? Scenario - Family of 4 (2 adults/2 children) has consulted their calendar in late December and they have identified one week in late July to make a trip to the BWCAW. This is their only time due to pressing activities and work schedules. Like many families, they have limited time/experience in canoes and would like to keep their entry choices to smaller lakes to avoid wind/weather complications. They identify 2-3 entries that might work, e.g. LIS North, Baker Lake, Lizz Lake. They have one date that works, They eagerly wait for "Black Wednesday" (someone else's term - not mine). They log in and refresh as necessary. They're in! Oh no! The system kicks them out. Log back in. We are now 5 min. into the permit session. Check LIzz Lake. Booked. Check LIS North - all gone. Check Baker Lake - Empty. They are done. Log out. Disappointed, this family now starts researching a different location for their family vacation. They come up with an entirely different plan. Do they ever go back to look for a BWCAW Permit? No! They have moved on. OR, they take a month and hope for a cancellation checking every other day until mid-February. Nothing. Now their second choice plan is in jeopardy because reservations at the inn for their second choice vacation are going fast. They jump and make that reservation and never go back to the BWCAW reservation system.
How many entry permit reservations are "lost" to just this type of scenario?
Even if someone is willing to go back during the next 4 months looking for a permit that is acceptable, an acceptable permit may never appear. Not willing to put themselves into a position where they will potentially have to travel over a 300-400 rd portage to find a campsite drives many to eliminate some entries. Not willing to drive all the way up the Gunflint. Not willing to encounter or listen to motorboat traffic. There are many reasons someone can rule out an open permit. To put in the time, money, and effort to just get to the BWCAW and have to accept a "less than" wilderness experience is a disqualifying factor.
I agree that the market probably would not include 100% of the cancelled/no show permits, but even add back in 20-40% and you would make a measurable difference in the bottom line for the Arrowhead region's economy.
As for the outfitters running call centers? They already do. They take requests for permits and attempt to fulfill those requests all the time. They are also at the mercy of the "Black Wednesday" phenomenon as well as the fraudulent manipulation of the supply of permits.
10/16/2025 09:17AM
ducks:
.........
I’ve been told by multiple outfitters they’ve had groups do this. One example , Rockwood has had groups of under 9 people show up together and take all 3 permits for the day for Lizz with plans to camp together stating they did it so they’d be the only group entering that day.
There is a rule that all people on a permit must camp together , but there isn’t anything in the rules prohibiting multiple groups camping at 1 site as long as they are under the 9 person/4 watercraft rule. "
That is extremely not cool, if doing it strictly to displace others.
I can see taking a couple permits if, say, half of the group goes one route, the other half another route, and they meet back up at certain points. I've always wanted to do such a trip. But hoarding to keep others from an EP on a certain day is a sh++y practice.
I think making permits nonrefundable within, say, 30 or even 21 days would at least incentivize some to release their permits back into the system, in time for others to use them. (combined with some type of $$ increase for permits....even doubled, it would still be very reasonable).
Making tickets nonrefundable greatly reduced no-shows in the airline industry, but then we're talking about a larger expense even for cheap plane tickets.
I wish they'd change the open permit day to a month later. In January, I'm not always ready for that day, it's like a race to buy concert tickets or something (Mudro is like getting Taylor Swift seats on the main floor), and friends don't usually know yet if they can get July 18-25th off.. I think making people hurry up & grab a permit in January makes for more speculative bookings.
"Enjoy every sandwich"
10/16/2025 10:18AM
@ A1t2o - I’m generally curious, what parts of the trip can’t you plan without knowing the exact EP you’re entering at? And is not knowing those parts worth not making a trip?
Given the known data, if reservations weren’t allowed, there would be no cancellations and thus lots of open permits on any given day. Add in the decreasing use of the BWCA over the last 30 years, there would always be many permits available.
Given the known data, if reservations weren’t allowed, there would be no cancellations and thus lots of open permits on any given day. Add in the decreasing use of the BWCA over the last 30 years, there would always be many permits available.
"Miller owns that field, Locke that, and the Mannings the woodland beyond. But none of them owns the landscape." - R.W.Emmerson.
10/16/2025 02:12PM
YaMarVa: "@ A1t2o - I’m generally curious, what parts of the trip can’t you plan without knowing the exact EP you’re entering at? And is not knowing those parts worth not making a trip?
Given the known data, if reservations weren’t allowed, there would be no cancellations and thus lots of open permits on any given day. Add in the decreasing use of the BWCA over the last 30 years, there would always be many permits available.
"
The ability to legitimately plan a trip, thanks to sites like this one, with information on lakes, portages, campsites, fishing, etc is all so beneficial. When I head into the BWCA, I thoroughly review the area and surrounding lakes. I have a contingency plan should certain lakes or sites not be available, or should weather become a factor, or this that and all the other things. There's such a benefit to knowing where you're going in advance.
I'm not saying you're wrong in pulling a card from deck and entering wherever that might be, it's just not the way a lot of us operate.
Subscribe to Thread
Become a member of the bwca.com community to subscribe to thread and get email updates when new posts are added. Sign up Here

Search BWCA.com
Donate