BWCA Lund To Bigshell Boundary Waters Group Forum: Woodland Caribou Provincial Park
Chat Rooms (0 Chatting)  |  Search  |   Login/Join
* For the benefit of the community, commercial posting is not allowed.

Author

Text

mastertangler
distinguished member(4432)distinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished memberpower member
  
10/18/2016 07:14AM   (Thread Older Than 3 Years)
I know, I know........its way to early to start talking and planning but I can't help it. The UPS man has been a regular visitor to my house as I revamp my fishing approach and I spend at least 5 minutes a day looking at the map.

So thats the plan for next august Lord willing. Hopefully the Bog Trot will be a bit drier than it was last time we met. But what about knox creek to Linge? And how about the Sabourin river from Olive into Bigshell? Any big trees across the river? And how about the lake north of Bigshell............Burntwood.......... a long portage in......... easy or hard? Any decent campsites on Burntwood?

Looking at spending a week on Bigshell, a week on Olive and a week on Linge. I see Bigshell has a 5 star site. Olive and Linge look to have several options as well.......any site recommendations?
 
      Print Top Bottom Previous Next
KerryG
distinguished member (367)distinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished member
  
10/18/2016 08:42AM  
It's never too early. I just talked with Harlan yesterday and nailed down next years trip already. We're going to do the Bloodvein from Larus down to rivers end at Lake Winnipeg. Something to dream on as winter approaches. Oh, I forgot, you don't have winter :>)
 
mastertangler
distinguished member(4432)distinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished memberpower member
  
10/18/2016 10:41AM  
quote KerryG: "It's never too early. I just talked with Harlan yesterday and nailed down next years trip already. We're going to do the Bloodvein from Larus down to rivers end at Lake Winnipeg. Something to dream on as winter approaches. Oh, I forgot, you don't have winter :>)"


Kerry your omitting some very fine portaging by starting at Laurus. Perhaps you should reevaluate? Um, where are the night pics?
 
Mondo63
member (13)member
  
10/18/2016 12:24PM  
M-A,
I went from Lund to Young lake with my boy last summer. Knox Creek was a bit of a challenge for us on the way up. There was some blowdown in sections that posed some problems for us. We had to get out and portage across some oxbows in spots as well as dig out the saw to cut through some spots. I think it took us a little over a couple of hours to get from Knox to the lake just to the south of Young where we spent the night. We did encounter a moose going up the river when we were creating all sorts of racket trying to get off of a submerged log. The moose must have been napping in the tall grass. I think we startled him and he got up and started running, thankfully, away from us.
We were tired by the time we got off of the creek so we camped at the bailout lake to the south of Young. The site is nice enough but no real place to set up your tent. Nice sloping rock to the water and decent kitchen/fire pit set up. We had spent some time on Knox slaying walleyes and we hadn't anticipated how long the creek was going to take us. We were happy we bailed on getting to Young that evening as the next morning we had a bit of a challenge getting into Young. As you leave the lake to the south of Young, the weeds/grasses become really thick. The channel disappears and finding a way through is a bit of a challenge. Eventually we made it to the portage. Paddling across the wet lawn to get to it would have been too tough the evening before.
We spent a few nights on Young and absolutely loved it. We saw moose and bears. We caught a ton of walleyes too. As you look at the map, there is an island campsite near the east end of the lake. It is awesome with a great boat landing, fantastic swimming, great fishing right off the shore, a flat place for the tent, a blueberry patch and lots of wood scattered about.
Our plan was to go up to Linge but we kind of don't like moving up and or down creeks and the fishing and solitude on Young was so great that we just decided to stay put. I think your trip sounds awesome. I know Olive has an outpost on it so maybe more time on Young would be better than sharing it with a bunch of boats. Linked are some of our videos. Hopefully got them linked correctly. Let me know if you want to know the fishing spots on Young that we found.

Be forewarned, a lot of zany stuff in the vids that keep us entertained. See links below.

We are in serious negotiations regarding our route next year. The boy is highly interested in heading up to Musclow. Looks like a lot of fantastic walleye lakes up that way and your report has piqued our interest.

Mondo

Day 2 Video

Day 4

Day 5
 
mastertangler
distinguished member(4432)distinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished memberpower member
  
10/18/2016 03:11PM  
Yo Mondo Man........I would like to see your Utube vids. You can't just copy and paste on this forum but must use "add a link" option > Just scroll down to access. If you give the titles I can just search at Utube as well.

Hey knox creek sounds challenging and fun. Thanks for weighing in. Maybe they will have cleaned up that route by the time I get rolling. If not I have plenty of time. The Outpost on Olive is Harlans if I;m not mistaken. Not so sure there is any motor boats......maybe some one can chime in on that.

Bigshell, Olive and Linge supposedly have "marginal or unconfirmed" populations of walleye. I have to get away from all those pesky 20" walleyes and focus on some closer to 30".

Yes paddle or fly into Musclow and stay where I did. Very nice, fish galore with lots of options if the wind comes up. Send me a paper map of Musclow and Barclay and I will mark it up for you. Ask Santa for a Mega Bass deep six in sexy shad color.......whack-em lure.
 
Mondo63
member (13)member
  
10/18/2016 05:56PM  
quote mastertangler: "Yo Mondo Man........I would like to see your Utube vids. You can't just copy and paste on this forum but must use "add a link" option > Just scroll down to access. If you give the titles I can just search at Utube as well.


Hey knox creek sounds challenging and fun. Thanks for weighing in. Maybe they will have cleaned up that route by the time I get rolling. If not I have plenty of time. The Outpost on Olive is Harlans if I;m not mistaken. Not so sure there is any motor boats......maybe some one can chime in on that.


Okay, I think I've got the vids linked correctly. And I'm pretty sure I talked to Harlan about his outpost and it did sound like he has motors there. Maybe I'm off base on that.
 
Marten
distinguished member(514)distinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished member
  
10/18/2016 06:01PM  
The river travel from Olive to Bigshell varies with the water levels. We had no trouble in May just after ice out but Hoop came by later and had log jams when the water dropped. Check out his wintertrekker youtube channel for some video of the river.
 
KerryG
distinguished member (367)distinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished member
  
10/18/2016 07:43PM  
My wife and I did the Olive to Douglas run 3 years ago. It was a great trip. The fishing is great all through there. Olive, in particular has a sparse walleye population but the ones that are in there are noted to be big. I caught one that was certainly in the 6 lb range. I attached it to a stringer over the side of the canoe and managed to have it escape before I got it home to measure. Young is a very nice lake with lots of walleye. We stayed at a beautiful site there. In fact my back went out and we stayed at that site for 5 nights while I recuperated. The run between Linge and Knox is tough. In fact, I'd say that our day between Young and Knox was one of the roughest we've ever done. That was because the water was low (mid August) and there was an enormous amount of deadfall blocking the creek all the way down. In the spring Harlan and co. had been able to paddle over all that so it wasn't cleared but by late summer it was a bloody mess. We were unloading and loading our canoe every 100 yards in some cases. Brutal. Your plan is to exit at Lund and I actually have 't gone that way. As I said, from Knox we went down through Indian House (a pike only lake) and then through Crystal (East), Page, Hatchet and Douglas (another great Walleye lake.) That section from Indian House we did twice, the second time it was the tail end of a trip starting at Broken Arrow at the western edge of the park and doing the minjim route. Anyway if there's anything you want to know about campsites, we stayed at a few beauties along the route you're planning.
 
mastertangler
distinguished member(4432)distinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished memberpower member
  
10/19/2016 06:17AM  
Whoa.......sounding more and more like it might be a hard trip. I will have to bring a chain saw..............Um, On second thought scratch that. Last time I brought a saw I got into some difficulty.
 
mastertangler
distinguished member(4432)distinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished memberpower member
  
10/19/2016 09:47AM  
Did I say thanks for the info? Well let me say it emphatically......Thanks!

So what I have gotten so far is Knox creek is no picnic and neither is the Souborin river into Bigshell (at least during low water).

Covering new ground, even if its tough, is usually fun the first time but usually not so much the second. I had originally intended on doing a "route" i.e. returning by the same way but now am strongly considering a loop.

So heres the question........should I take the Sabourin out of Bigshell to Thicketwood or should I portage into Burntwood and take the Dutch river to Thicketwood?
 
mastertangler
distinguished member(4432)distinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished memberpower member
  
10/21/2016 07:09AM  
Mondo......I took an extended coffee break yesterday and watched all your vids but day 1. Good stuff, you guys make me smile. Looks like Young lake is a winner.......might have to work that in.

Marten, I checked out several of winter trekker vids and like them almost as much as I like yours. The Sabourin out of Bigshell looks potentially time consuming but has Thicketwood as a reward. I could not find video of Olive into Bigshell.......are you certain he has this?

I had originally thought of busting tail and getting to Bigshell or Burntwood and then meandering back and staying at Olive, Linge and now Young as well. Now I'm probably leaning towards that again after watching wintertekkers videos........The creek travel is probably all going to be much the same I suspect.

 
Marten
distinguished member(514)distinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished member
  
10/21/2016 03:33PM  
I was not sure of what his exact content was for the river but knew you would see the river at lower levels with the log jams. I know we only spent one night camped on the river between Olive and Bigshell. It was a long day but we made from Bigshell to Thicketwood for a late supper. Found a nice place to camp about a half mile from the Larus portage the day after the long paddle.
 
10/21/2016 06:41PM  
Just to jump into this discussion quickly, a group I was with a couple of years ago looked into that Olive-southward to Knox route with Harlan. He didn't outrighthly wave us off of it but I do remember him asking us if "we really wanted to portage that much?". We ended up flying into Donald and doing the Gammon out via Douglas. There are a lot of walleye on Douglas as well as some other lakes on that route such as Glen and the one due south, the Hat. I haven't been to the far north of the park beyond Knox and Murdoch but Olive looks like a lovely lake from the pictures :). Some day I'll get into that area, I'm sure. Good luck with your planning MT --- if it's August of next year, we might cross paths in that park.
 
mastertangler
distinguished member(4432)distinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished memberpower member
  
10/21/2016 08:25PM  
Geez, all this might take more time than I thought. I had figured one day from Knox to Linge, one day from Linge to Olive, and one day from Olive to Bigshell. I will just have to get up early and eat my Wheaties.

The plan is to be in a shape other than round and cut back on some gear (although you would never know it by the shelf full of fishing stuff carefully arranged in my shop as I revamp my piscatorial strategy for this trip).........tripling instead of 4 carries across like last trip might also expedite matters. Maybe I will bring less food ;-)

But I say bring it on.....I will just ease along from daylight to dark and see where I get.........I am hopefully going to be able to carve out a good chunk of time to play with. Not getting any younger.......best have some adventure while I can. Is it just me or does the time seem to be flying by?

HighnDry I will eventually post my basecamp plans / dates and will encourage whomsoever to come and visit. It would be great to meet you. I figure most of my time will be spent on Bigshell, Olive and Linge.
 
solotrip
distinguished member (170)distinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished member
  
10/22/2016 10:17AM  
Yes, I have boats / motors on Olive Lake. You may not want to be base camping on the lake as groups will be around most of the summer. All trails from Bigshell to Olive and Olive to Linge are clear sailing. Simple grunt work and a bunch of in and our but both are easily done in less than a day. Linge is an incredible Walleye Lake!

Harlan
 
mastertangler
distinguished member(4432)distinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished memberpower member
  
10/23/2016 07:17AM  
quote solotrip: "Yes, I have boats / motors on Olive Lake. You may not want to be base camping on the lake as groups will be around most of the summer. All trails from Bigshell to Olive and Olive to Linge are clear sailing. Simple grunt work and a bunch of in and our but both are easily done in less than a day. Linge is an incredible Walleye Lake!


Harlan "


I hope you are booked solid this summer Harlan! I am one small boat, hopefully your guests will not object if I poke around for a few days (I stay sort of quiet ;-)

Good news about the routes. Hopefully they will stay open.

I had hoped to connect with you after this summers trip. Rumor has it you were Salmon fishing in British Columbia if I remember correctly. How did it go? Feel free to throw up a few pics ;-)
 
solotrip
distinguished member (170)distinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished member
  
10/23/2016 10:39AM  
Master,

no objections lol. Just know that you may encounter some boats. On the flip side, they may invite you in for a Sauna!

Keep in mind that the fire from last summer on Olive took out a lot of nice campsites, still a few on the north end, and some in the east though. I'll be revisiting those trails again in the spring to ensure no blowdown.

Personally, i would spend some time on Bigshell and fish "Banana Lake", located up the hill by way of 100 meter portage from the south end of Bigshell. Trophy Lake Trout and Pike in there. 1 campsite awaits you, overlooking this crystal clear lake. Well worth the efforts to get in there. Also note, FN members from Pikangikum FN built a cabin this fall on the beach on southeast end of Bigshell....the big beach. Was an excellent campsite but i would look elsewhere for next year.

Yup, tried my hand at some saltwater Salmon...epic trip with Mooching reels....tired arms. Boy those fish can run and run and run! Had Salmon last night for dinner!

 
mastertangler
distinguished member(4432)distinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished memberpower member
  
10/24/2016 07:10AM  
Bravo Harlan! I understand BC is a very pretty place. Good for you!

Sort of bad news about the cabin. I suspect it is in the location I had been looking forward to camping at.......a 5 star site on a point? SE side of the lake? Even if it is just used in the fall who wants to camp near a structure? Blah!

So I had considered ending up in Burntwood. Shame to go all that way and not check it out. But you say "Banana lake"? Why is it called that ;-)

OK......you talked me into it. Skip the almost 2000 meters of portaging into Burntwood and instead travel into a pretty little hidey hole via a 150 meter portage...... complete with whoppers. That was easy. If I catch a big one in there I will put a plug in for you as the all-knowing guru ;-)

Crap.......I want to go now!! (patience grasshopper)
 
Marten
distinguished member(514)distinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished member
  
10/24/2016 08:02AM  
A note on accessing Banana: There is fast water as you exit Bigshell to Little Bigshell and the park map does not show a portage. There is a portage on river right and it ends where the 90 meter to Banana Lake begins. Camping on Banana sounds like a great idea and short portages will give you access to the other waters when your arms give out after fighting the monsters.
 
mastertangler
distinguished member(4432)distinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished memberpower member
  
10/24/2016 01:09PM  
That is so awesome......thanks guys! Banana lake it is then. Portage river right so I don't dump the contents of my wee little vessel into the drink, and then up the hill.

Forums? Who knew? I was completely computer illiterate until my eccentric recluse genius buddy (stereotypes often exist for a reason ;-) suggested I check out Quiet Journey. On more than a whim than anything else I checked it out. At that point I didn't even know what "copy and paste" meant. Fast forward and I now have a "digital scrapbook" in which to record my trips, built a website to promote my business and learned of the Quetico and Woodland Caribou all due to being involved with forums. Places I never would of heard about on my own.

Now, thanks to the kindness of people I have never met before, I have an excellent adventure awaiting me.

 
dentondoc
distinguished member(1097)distinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished member
  
10/24/2016 04:33PM  
You might also find "Banana" Lake being referred to as "Perched" Lake. According to conversations I've had with Claire, the lake sits higher than surrounding lakes and as a consequence, the only direction the water flows from here is out. Apparently, as a result of its position, it is among the clearest lakes in all of WCPP.

dd
 
mastertangler
distinguished member(4432)distinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished memberpower member
  
10/25/2016 06:57AM  
quote dentondoc: "You might also find "Banana" Lake being referred to as "Perched" Lake. According to conversations I've had with Claire, the lake sits higher than surrounding lakes and as a consequence, the only direction the water flows from here is out. Apparently, as a result of its position, it is among the clearest lakes in all of WCPP.


dd"


I'm with you DD.......we simply must find a better name than "Banana Lake" for what is obviously a gem. I find it difficult to get excited about "Yup, I can't wait, I'm going to Banana lake".

How about "Crescent lake"? Sounds a bit more intriguing. Or perhaps "Crown Lake".......we could pronounce it in a foreign language to make it sound more exotic ;-)

Still pulling my gear together. I had an epiphany of sorts regarding the fishing approach and decided to act upon it promptly rather than let the enthusiasm fade and the "water become murky" with the passage of time as it were. Then the long waiting game........but that will give me time to get in shape to climb that hill.......will I need rope? Crampons?

I will save Burntwood for a later time............Perhaps do a Thicketwood to Burntwood trip in 2018. That water between those two lakes looks mighty interesting. Lord willing of course.......who knows what a day may bring!

 
dentondoc
distinguished member(1097)distinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished member
  
10/25/2016 08:55AM  
quote mastertangler: "but that will give me time to get in shape to climb that hill.......will I need rope? Crampons?"


I don't want to deter your preparation, but topographic data suggest that the climb is probably not much more than 20 meters (but that's over a 100 meter portage). So, its definitely up hill and one would assume that the (20%) grade is not uniform over that distance, but I doubt technical climbing gear would be necessary. However, if you string a rope between a couple of trees as you go in, you might have a hellava zip-line coming out!

BTW: If you want to confirm what I mentioned above about water clarity, you can easily see the difference between "Banana" and surrounding lakes via a zoomed up view of the current satellite image rendering from Google Earth.

dd
 
mastertangler
distinguished member(4432)distinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished memberpower member
  
10/26/2016 06:29AM  
Super clear water........can sometimes spell tough fishing. But oh so beautiful. I love looking in the water while I'm paddling along. Sounds nice.

Looks like I will have 24 days again. I had thought I might swing 30 but no dice. Now I just have to make the tough decisions on "stuff". Last time was 4 carries but that was only for a few days and then it was mostly paddling........this is a portage trip. Hopefully I can do 3 carries this time.
 
mastertangler
distinguished member(4432)distinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished memberpower member
  
10/27/2016 06:00AM  
Little Bigshell.........with the swifts separating little from Big they are, for all intents and purposes, like 2 separate lakes. Deep down I know I gravitate towards the bigger waters because they usually have a more diverse forage base for the fish I pursue. Bigger waters usually mean bigger fish.......but it also means wind and waves.

Perhaps I should consider spending time on Little Bigshell. Anybody got the skinny on that body of water? Any decent places to pitch a tent? Hows the fishing? Gravitating towards spending some time there as well as Banana.
 
Marten
distinguished member(514)distinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished member
  
10/27/2016 07:30AM  
I can't address the fish but feel you should enjoy being able to walk down the Banana portage and fish the base of the rapids. You will see in my video that it is quite a run of fast water.
 
solotrip
distinguished member (170)distinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished member
  
10/27/2016 10:04AM  
The portage into Banana is shown on the new Chrismar map of the park. As Marten noted, it's on river right as you exit Bigshell proper. At times, it is a torrent of water in there, at others it's just a trickle. When Claire and i flagged it 4 years ago (after nobody had likely accessed the lake in a decade), we just got out in knee deep water and walked the canoe to shore. This past year was different with much higher water levels....it all depends on water.

Fishing for lakers and pike is amazing. Water is crystal clear. Lots of Moose in that area as well.
 
mastertangler
distinguished member(4432)distinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished memberpower member
  
10/27/2016 11:00AM  
quote solotrip:


Fishing for lakers and pike is amazing. Water is crystal clear.
"


OK, pipe down a little. Do you want the whole world to know? ;-)
 
McVacek
distinguished member (273)distinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished member
  
12/03/2016 09:27AM  
My husband Chris and I spent one night on banana lake a couple years ago. It was a stunning lake. We bushwhacked over to the campsite which was covered in lady slippers. We never had enough time to fish the lake due to a thunderstorm, which was disappointing but just more reason to return someday. I also do recall having many mosquito friends at that campsite! :)
 
mastertangler
distinguished member(4432)distinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished memberpower member
  
12/03/2016 10:39AM  
Well I'm defintely focused on getting to Bannana lake.

Very pleased with my overall fishing strategy which I have been pulling together slowly and with an abundance of monetary expenditure (ouch! ....I asked myself just yesterday > "your not really going to feed that to a pike are you"? ) Some of these large plastic swim baits are a bit expensive to be feeding to a slimy toothy torpedo just to get torn, ripped and destroyed. Oh well.....

Whenever I hit the reading room I pull out the map and give it a quick glance. Sure a bucketload of portages between Lund and banana. Probably 4 or 5 days tripling is what I figure even running late in the day.

Monday I start training. Whoppeee!
 
01/24/2017 08:42PM  
Been Olive down to Knox and out to Lund.

Getting to Linge not difficult at all the creek going down to Knox is/can be plugged up. it was when I did it, purdy tough going, with the dog

SunCatcher
 
mastertangler
distinguished member(4432)distinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished memberpower member
  
01/27/2017 01:36PM  
quote SunCatcher: "Been Olive down to Knox and out to Lund.


Getting to Linge not difficult at all the creek going down to Knox is/can be plugged up. it was when I did it, purdy tough going, with the dog


SunCatcher"


So Knox to Linge "plugged up"? Low water? Rock gardens? Blowdown? Choked with weeds?
 
01/28/2017 07:04AM  
quote mastertangler: "
quote SunCatcher: "Been Olive down to Knox and out to Lund.



Getting to Linge not difficult at all the creek going down to Knox is/can be plugged up. it was when I did it, purdy tough going, with the dog



SunCatcher"



So Knox to Linge "plugged up"? Low water? Rock gardens? Blowdown? Choked with weeds? "
no

It is a decent paddle,. I was there late August,. Over labor day,. There is a fair amount
Of wild rice and lower water at ends of lakes, in the calmer water, but more than enough H2O to paddle through. Do-able stuff.
 
mastertangler
distinguished member(4432)distinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished memberpower member
  
01/29/2017 08:07AM  
Geez I'm so confused........which is it (not that it really matters mind you......nothing some determination can't handle)........"purdy tough going" or a "decent paddle"?

Low water is a concern as I should be there in Late August as well (Lord willing ;-)
 
KerryG
distinguished member (367)distinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished member
  
01/29/2017 05:46PM  
Linge to Knox was one of the toughest paddles we've ever done. Mid August. Coming out of the first portage out of Young going in the direction of Knox we hit an area of swamp grass so dense that we almost turned back. I was doing the African Queen thing thigh deep in muck. Fortunately I finally found something similar to shore (almost held my weight - ankle deep) and were able to finally make it through. And that was the 1st portage. They got worse from there - seriously.
 
01/30/2017 11:10AM  
quote KerryG: "Linge to Knox was one of the toughest paddles we've ever done. Mid August. Coming out of the first portage out of Young going in the direction of Knox we hit an area of swamp grass so dense that we almost turned back. I was doing the African Queen thing thigh deep in muck. Fortunately I finally found something similar to shore (almost held my weight - ankle deep) and were able to finally make it through. And that was the 1st portage. They got worse from there - seriously."


Yikes!
 
mastertangler
distinguished member(4432)distinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished memberpower member
  
01/31/2017 01:52PM  
quote KerryG: "Linge to Knox was one of the toughest paddles we've ever done. Mid August. Coming out of the first portage out of Young going in the direction of Knox we hit an area of swamp grass so dense that we almost turned back. I was doing the African Queen thing thigh deep in muck. Fortunately I finally found something similar to shore (almost held my weight - ankle deep) and were able to finally make it through. And that was the 1st portage. They got worse from there - seriously."


Ahem.......uh well, have you ever wanted to be an actor? You could play tough guy Bogart pulling the boat through the impassable and, yes, I will play the distinguished Katherine Hepburn looking quite concerned about our forward progress from the bow seat. I can help pick the leeches off when you get back in the boat. Your pics are absolutely amazing BTW.
 
02/19/2017 07:23PM  

Just wondering if you will clear out a new campsite and cut trails to your fishing hole like you did on Musclow and elsewhere. What a total dick
 
02/20/2017 07:34AM  
quote AndySG: "
Just wondering if you will clear out a new campsite and cut trails to your fishing hole like you did on Musclow and elsewhere. What a total dick "




Andy, he's been run through the ringer enough. He's been talked to by the park. I'm sure if he does it'll be his last trip in WCPP and maybe Canada. We can let it rest I think.
 
Marten
distinguished member(514)distinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished member
  
02/20/2017 08:16AM  
quote nctry: "
quote AndySG: "
Just wondering if you will clear out a new campsite and cut trails to your fishing hole like you did on Musclow and elsewhere. What a total dick "




Andy, he's been run through the ringer enough. He's been talked to by the park. I'm sure if he does it'll be his last trip in WCPP and maybe Canada. We can let it rest I think."


+1
I think more than MT learned a few things through this.
 
mastertangler
distinguished member(4432)distinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished memberpower member
  
02/21/2017 08:59AM  
People like Andy don't really bother me as certain people feel a need to be hateful to others, I get it. They get little more than pity from me. The only thing that really bothers me is his tag line of "WWJD" as his representation of what Christ is like is 180 degrees opposite of what I know to be true.

The bottom line at Musclow is there is a 4 star site at an ideal strategic location where only 1 stars existed previously (f you could even find something). I would challenge any experienced paddler to arrive at the Musclow site and state that it is a net negative for the park. My advice is to go to Musclow, enjoy an excellent campsite at a prime location in total seclusion and catch walleye after walleye until you get tired.

And yes, despite my defense of the Musclow site it is my first and last site I will build. I am a team player and had I known it was against the rules I would not have engaged in the activity in the first place.

Here Andy, this is for you
WWJD
 
Bogwalker
Moderator
  
02/21/2017 11:35AM  
MT FYI-WWJD on BWCA.com is not the same as your definition.

WWJD for many of us means "What Would Jan Do"
 
mastertangler
distinguished member(4432)distinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished memberpower member
  
02/21/2017 01:12PM  
quote Bogwalker: "MT FYI-WWJD on BWCA.com is not the same as your definition.


WWJD for many of us means "What Would Jan Do""


Well that explains a great deal now doesn't it! Thank you very much Bogwalker...... I appreciate that enlightenment. I would venture a guess that I am not the only one on the board who is a trifle confused (even though clearly it is obvious that Jan was much known and much loved).

Again I thank you for providing clarity.
 
mastertangler
distinguished member(4432)distinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished memberpower member
  
03/10/2017 01:52PM  
Today I had an epiphany of sorts.......I'm tired, as in whooped and wore down. My body is showing it as well. In spite of spending many hours peering at maps and spending lots of $$ on a new and improved fishing strategy I'm going to bail on my WCPP trip this year. I also would rather have a bit more time than 24 days to do what I want to do. Two and a half day drive and then 3 or 4 hard days to get where I want to fish.

I want to thank those who have weighed in.......the advice given is appreciated and the trip will be rescheduled.

Instead I am eyeing using my 24 days at Isle Royale and using the Superior Expedition decked canoe which has only one trip under its belt. One day drive, no portaging and lakeside screened shelters complete with a picnic table........water taxis for use if I lack the stones to brave the north shoreline. (Better a cowardly dog than a dead lion ;-)

Fishing opportunities are potentially excellent especially for fish of trophy size.
 
03/15/2017 02:10PM  
That sounds like a pretty good trip.
I guess there are some big fish in Gichigami.
Remember, pics or it didn't happen. ;)
 
03/15/2017 02:47PM  
Isle Royale would be a great trip!
 
mastertangler
distinguished member(4432)distinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished memberpower member
  
11/22/2017 08:01AM  
Well I am back on for my previously planned WCPP trip this summer. The Isle Royale excursion got my health pointed back in the right direction. This winter looks to be the "workout winter".

Harlan has suggested fishing "Banana lake" just below Bigshell. I have noticed however as per having received Harlans Maps, that there appears to be no campsites on Banana or the unnamed lake from which the portage into Banana originates. Is that true?

And if so, am I clear in understanding that there is a swift or a chute from Bigshell to the unnamed lake? Is the swift easy to traverse if I were to camp at Bigshell and make the round trip to Banana on day trips?
 
mastertangler
distinguished member(4432)distinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished memberpower member
  
11/23/2017 08:15AM  
I have reread the thread and Martin notes a portage on river right to bypass the swift out of Bigshell. Thats good. Still curious as to wether anyone has camped on Banana or the unnamed lake directly below it. I may have to make day trips from Bigshell if no site exists.
 
KerryG
distinguished member (367)distinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished member
  
11/23/2017 05:10PM  
quote mastertangler: "I have reread the thread and Martin notes a portage on river right to bypass the swift out of Bigshell. Thats good. Still curious as to wether anyone has camped on Banana or the unnamed lake directly below it. I may have to make day trips from Bigshell if no site exists. "

I'm not sure what you mean when you ask whether or not their are campsites on Banana Lake. As I'm sure you are well aware, there are no designated campsites in WCPP so you can effectively camp anywhere that you can pitch a tent. That being said, if you ask Harlan I'm sure he knows of at least one or two existing sites, especially since he is recommending that lake to you.
 
mastertangler
distinguished member(4432)distinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished memberpower member
  
11/23/2017 07:59PM  
Ahem........that was my belief Kerry when I established a campsite on Musclow Lake. But au contraire one must camp at already established campsites. That is the rules and I was informed by several sources including WCPP. What I thought was a valuable enhancement to the park turned out to be a violation. So be aware.
 
KerryG
distinguished member (367)distinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished member
  
11/24/2017 09:01AM  
quote mastertangler: "Ahem........that was my belief Kerry when I established a campsite on Musclow Lake. But au contraire one must camp at already established campsites. That is the rules and I was informed by several sources including WCPP. What I thought was a valuable enhancement to the park turned out to be a violation. So be aware. "

Now that is odd because Harlan has assured me over the years that the mandate of the park is that there are no official camp sites. Maybe that has changed recently or maybe the MNR is interpreting their mandate differently, who knows. For myself, the devastation to the park by uncontrolled fires over the past number of years has me looking to Atikaki Provincial Park over on the Manitoba side for future tripping. Last summer as we made our way down the Bloodvein River I finally ran into Martin Kehoe in the flesh going the other way on a portage. I have been communicating with him for years but we'd never actually met. He was incredibly excited about Atikaki and told me that if I thought the Bloodvein was beautiful, I ought to see the rest of the park. And by the way, the fishing was ridiculous - I have never pulled out so many 26 - 28" Walleye in my life. I caught my first Pike over 46" and enormous catfish to boot (and all, by the way, with a 4' rod after snapping the damn thing after the first week out.)
 
11/24/2017 10:19AM  
In the BWCA it is specifically prohibited to camp anywhere other than an officially established campsite.
I think similar regulations exist in some of the more popular Ontario parks, e.g. Algonquin.
I believe that, like in the Q, technically it is allowed to camp anywhere in WCPP.
But establishing a campsite by cutting trees, building a fire pit, etc. is prohibited.
Throwing up a tent and sleeping for a night is OK, but park management wants us to adhere to full LNT in that instance.
They strongly encourage using established campsites.
There are a lot of established campsites in the park. And most of them are where we would expect them to be. The criteria for a good campsite haven't changed over the millennia so look for rocky points, nice beaches, etc. and you are likely to find an established campsite.
MT made the mistake of establishing a site where one did not already exist.
Park management reserves such activity to itself.
MT isn't the kind of guy who will ignore what Claire told him.
Now that he knows what MNR wants he will act accordingly.
Best practice is to just use the established sites.
That will minimize the overall impact on the resource and preserve it for generations to come.
 
mastertangler
distinguished member(4432)distinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished memberpower member
  
11/24/2017 05:00PM  
Kerry you trouble maker...........Now you have me interested in Atakaki..........as if WCPP wasn't far enough!! Visions of 26 to 28" walleye dancing in my head........and a 46" pike! Wow, nice fish. Heck with pics of the stars we want to see that big pike and catfish ;-)

Did you ever catch anything with the Savage gear swimbait?

Yes Jcavenaugh I would not want to do anything which would cause me difficulty and remove myself from the pleasure which is Ontario Parks in spite of the best of intentions. I do wish to return to the camp at Musclow however and now consider it an "established" campsite. It is a desirable situation and can be considered a destination lake IMO.
 
Marten
distinguished member(514)distinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished member
  
11/28/2017 10:53AM  
On the downstream end of the portage River Right from Bigshell you will intersect the portage to Banana. Note that some maps show a 50 meter portage RL but it a tough scramble when a easy carry is RR from Bigshell.
 
      Print Top Bottom Previous Next