| Author |
Message Text |
|
CanoeViking
|
NEIowapaddler: "It's almost like wearing life jackets increases your odds of surviving if you capsize..."
Exactly. I found for me that spending a little extra money to get a lifejacket that’s comfortable so that you hardly notice it is there. Then when wearing it it is not an annoyance and everybody’s safer.
|
|
Speckled
|
Curious as to what their options for self rescue were. Especially the second group that still had thier boats. Did they lose everything else? No paddles?
With the option of spot or other similar devices are folks much more likely to just hit the "save me" button?
|
|
Soledad
|
That is true- its is tough to get hypothermia without a life jacket while in the water.
I just bought a new NRS Ninja- they are half off right now. $75 and it will arrive before my next trip. My other jacket is 17-18 years old and their lifespan is around 10 years, some less than that.
|
|
straighthairedcurly
|
fun4dad2: "Frenchy19: "NEIowapaddler: ""
Perfect..."
Wearing a lifejacket/PDF causes hypothermia! it's true - look it up. Of course, not wearing it you drown before hypothermia sets in, but hey, you don't freeze to death!
"
Where on earth on you finding that gem? Hopefully you are joking.
|
|
LaVirginienne
|
I remember the day I emerged from the Snake river and immediately made for campsite 1726 looking north/west at whitecaps ahead on Bald Eagle. Grounded the next day as well.
|
|
fenrirrr
|
It’s possible they didn’t prepare for a scenario where they dump their canoe (in ideal conditions, you can get away with a lot—which I suspect is most folks BWCA experience). Or they did prepare, but still wound up in a bad position.
I think there’s a case to be made for contacting SAR even if you aren’t certain you need rescue. Hitting the SOS button doesn’t necessarily mean “come get me.” Most modern devices allow two-way coms so dispatch can triage the situation.
Immediately sending a few volunteers via canoe might well be the preferred response if there’s any risk of a more complicated rescue after dark or with other environmental or medical complications.
It would be interesting to look at detailed data on this. Higher rates of SOS calls may also mean fewer critical extractions or fatalities.
|
|
OgimaaBines
|
Soledad: "That is true- its is tough to get hypothermia without a life jacket while in the water.
I just bought a new NRS Ninja- they are half off right now. $75 and it will arrive before my next trip. My other jacket is 17-18 years old and their lifespan is around 10 years, some less than that."
Thanks for the tip, Soledad. What a deal!
|
|
NEIowapaddler
|
It's almost like wearing life jackets increases your odds of surviving if you capsize...
|
|
Coda1
|
straighthairedcurly: "fun4dad2: "Frenchy19: "NEIowapaddler: ""
Perfect..."
Wearing a lifejacket/PDF causes hypothermia! it's true - look it up. Of course, not wearing it you drown before hypothermia sets in, but hey, you don't freeze to death!
"
Where on earth on you finding that gem? Hopefully you are joking. "
Hypothermia takes a while to kill you. If you are not wearing a life jacket you will drown before hypothermia gets you.
|
|
Jaywalker
|
Well, it seems rescue stories are usually pretty boring when people wear their life jackets.....and that's a good thing.
|
|
Frenchy19
|
NEIowapaddler: "It's almost like wearing life jackets increases your odds of surviving if you capsize..."
perfect...
|
|
billconner
|
NEIowapaddler: "It's almost like wearing life jackets increases your odds of surviving if you capsize..."
:)
|
|
fun4dad2
|
Frenchy19: "NEIowapaddler: "It's almost like wearing life jackets increases your odds of surviving if you capsize..."
Perfect..."
Wearing a lifejacket/PDF causes hypothermia! it's true - look it up. Of course, not wearing it you drown before hypothermia sets in, but hey, you don't freeze to death!
|
|
timatkn
|
Two rescues on the same day on Bald Eagle Lake in the BWCAW. Luckily everyone was wearing life jackets and there were no fatalities.
Two Water Rescues BWCAW
|
|
Pinetree
|
Bald Eagle can get some terrific waves, once coming out of gull lake once it was so windy and a few hours of daylight left, I tried launching solo but got blown back in. Thus, I pitched my one-person tent just off the portage to Eagle and camped. Early the next morning, I paddled out, but had a heck of a time until I got behind the island.
When wilderness canoeing, you have to know when to move on or when to fold 'em and stay put.
|
|
iCallitMaize
|
I was grounded last year coming in and going out on Bald Eagle.
|