Click to View the Full Thread

Boundary Waters Quetico Forum :: Fishing Forum :: Season Opener
 
Author Message Text
kanoes
12/08/2007 06:01PM
  
in the BW...walleye, bass, pike open on may 10th, 2008. (im trout challenged...sorry). keep this in mind also, on the MN/Ontario border waters bass and pike are open 365. check out the MN DNR website for more specifics (limits, sizes, etc.) Jan
 
overthehill
12/08/2007 05:55PM
  
Is there an opening day for walleye. Smallies and pike year-round ? No clue as to species specifics etc. Thanks, oth
 
The Great Outdoors
12/08/2007 09:36PM
  
Minnesota opener is always the 1st Saturday in May, that falls on or before the 15th.

The 15th being the latest the season will open, the earliest would be the 9th.

Bass opens the same time in the north,(everyplace north of Hwy 2 and east of Hwy 169????) 2 or 3 weeks later in the southern part of the state.
 
The Great Outdoors
12/09/2007 08:14AM
  
timatkn

Read the post again, carefully.

The FIRST SATURDAY IN MAY THAT FALLS ON, OR BEFORE, THE 15th.

I stand by the statement!!!

Kids!!! :)
 
timatkn
12/09/2007 11:26AM
  
Thanks marsonite for clearing it up. TGO, after your explanation--I see what you are saying now. Your statement is not clear as you think--please read it again carefully(the first one you wrote not the second post), pause at the comma, and you will see it can be interpreted two different ways. If you take the comma out of your original statement it would be harder to misinterpret.

Tim
 
The Great Outdoors
12/09/2007 02:07PM
  
Marsonite is correct.

It translates to the 1st Saturday on or before the 15th.

timatkn,

It reads the same in either post, as the date of the 15th isolates the Saturday whether or not the comma is/is not present.

This was a cloudy issue several years back, so I called the DNR for clarification.(In fact, I think the DNR had the wrong opening date in their regulation book one of those years)

The explanation I gave earlier was exactly the same as I received over the phone.

No dessert for you, go to your room! :)
 
kanoes
12/09/2007 02:36PM
  
depends on what the meaning of "is" is...

:)
 
timatkn
12/09/2007 04:14PM
  

Ya know TGO some sentences can have two different meanings depending on where you puctuate/pause or even just how it is read by the reader, an open minded person can recognize that, a close minded person can only see it one way.

Punctuation does matter and changes the emphasis/connection of the sentence. Because you know what you meant when you wrote your sentence you are unable or unwilling to see any other interpretations.

I can see how I misinterpreted your post, I was mistaken, where does that leave you?

Tim
 
snakecharmer
12/09/2007 08:19PM
  
There's only one way to settle this...DANCE OFF!
 
overthehill
12/08/2007 07:08PM
  
Thanks Jan. Pre-planning and trying to beat the bugs,crowds,catch a few fish too. Went in after full moon last year and got hammered by rain and wind, bite shut down a bit last 3 days there etc. Even got out the Almanac this time just to compare. Wish me luck. Don't know what dates to pick, but like 5-20 or else 6-3. But these variables are what makes it a fun challenge! Thanks, oth
 
timatkn
12/08/2007 10:49PM
  
TGO it looks like those leeches of yours took too much blood:),the walleye season is the second saturday of May, not the first. If you used cranks more often you might not of lost so much blood to the brain.-----sorry too easy couldn't resist. Your dates are correct though.

Tim
 
kanoes
12/10/2007 06:36AM
  
hahahahhahahaha
 
The Great Outdoors
12/10/2007 08:25AM
  
Hey, hey, hey local paddler,

Lighten up Bro, just two guys discussing points of view!

Quote from you: "Fishing opener is around the second weekend in May every year. Done."

I don't like to stir the pot, (yeah, right!) but fishing can open on the third Saturday in May if it falls on the 15th.

I wouldn't even have mentioned that, but didn't want to see you get arrested for fishing before season! :)
 
ditchpickle6996
12/10/2007 09:10AM
  
TGO,
I wasn't upset. Sorry to sound that way. I actually like the dance off idea.
 
ditchpickle6996
12/10/2007 09:28AM
  
Whoops,,, my bad. My previous post never went through.
 
canoeski
12/10/2007 10:58AM
  
TGO: "I don't like to stir the pot, (yeah, right!) but fishing can open on the third Saturday in May if it falls on the 15th."

This will happen in 2010.
 
timatkn
12/10/2007 01:10PM
  
"There's only one way to settle this...DANCE OFF!"

I don't think that would be fair to TGO---- I do a mean late 80's MC Hammer :)


Tim
 
kanoes
12/10/2007 04:02PM
  
way to head that one off at the pass!
 
timatkn
12/08/2007 09:11PM
  
Trout open the same as walleye/pike/smally seasons in the BW. In quetico walleye open the thrid sat. of May usually one week after the MN opener.
 
marsonite
12/09/2007 08:36AM
  
From the DNR website: "Minnesota's general fishing opener is always the Saturday two weeks before Memorial Day weekend (May 13 in 2000 and May 12 in 2001)"

They changed it a few years back to guarantee an extra weekend between Memorial day and the opener.
 
local paddler
12/09/2007 07:10PM
  
And you two are grown men? Fishing opener is around the second weekend in May every year. Done.
 
The Great Outdoors
12/10/2007 05:17PM
  
You got that right!

Gotta disarm the grenade before it blows up in your face:)
 
local paddler
12/10/2007 09:15AM
  
Sorry if I sounded crabby,,, my Lions lost again! By the way I said "around" the second weekend so I was right.
 
The Great Outdoors
12/10/2007 03:37PM
  
timatkn

Don't get over confident!!

I taught Michael Jackson how to Moonwalk:)

PS- And that IS THE ONLY THING I taught him for all you smart alecks on this site:)