Click to View the Full Thread

Boundary Waters Quetico Forum :: Gear Forum :: Stuff sacks
 
Author Message Text
ParkerMag
03/13/2020 06:00AM
 
Everyone that trips with me uses two e-Vent bags - one for their personal/clothes, and one for their sleep system, which is typically hammock/suspension/tarp/quilts.
 
A1t2o
03/11/2020 10:51AM
 
What's a good store or site for stuff sacks? I'm looking at getting more to better sort my gear and food items. I don't need them to be that big but waterproof would be a big plus and probably help with reducing the scent of the food barrel. I know that they can be expensive when buying more than one or two at a time so I'm just looking for some deals.
 
sylvesterii
03/13/2020 09:13PM
 
I definitely prefer the Seal Line "Blocker Compression Dry Sack" Bags. The main reason is they compress down into a more rectangular shape, which definitely helps in packing. I do like the Sea To Summit eVent Dry Sacks (but NOT the Ultrasil Compression Dry Sacks), but they end up being more of a football shape and I think harder to pack. However, the eVent bags are really well made.


I don't reccomend the Sea to Summit Ultrasil material in any form. The material is lighter, but in my experience it isn't nearly as tough, and I've had several of the bags fail from both rubbing and from minor scratches. Granted you can patch/re-seal them, (but what good is that if you end up with water inside, and the weight savings just isn't worth it to me for canoe tripping. Maybe if I was doing a through-hike.


I for sure don't recommend the Outdoor Research Dry Compression sacks. They have some sort of coating on the inside that just sticks to any type of nylon or poly. It makes it SO hard to get anything in them. Super frustrating and not worth it. Surprisingly enough, I've also found that they tend to wear pretty easily as well.
 
bhouse46
03/11/2020 11:40AM
 
Another fan of the event bags. The ability to compress and be waterproof is hared to beat. I have three seasons with some of my bags, adding a couple each year, and they are holding up very well.
 
A1t2o
03/15/2020 11:54AM
 
I ended up buying an eVent compression sack. It'll replace my non-compression sleeping bag stuff sack. After trying it out, my sleeping went from 20L to 10L. For the food, I'll just use zip locks to sort.
 
unshavenman
03/11/2020 09:50PM
 
Sealline, Sea to Summit and Granite Gear all make good quality sil-nylon dry sacks. Amazon and REI are my go-to vendors.
 
Savage Voyageur
03/11/2020 01:53PM
 
jdoutdoors: "These are spendy, but I highly recommend them for your clothes. They let air out through a micro-pore fabric but they don't let it back in. These are great for cinching your clothes down to the smallest, densest ball possible. Again, spendy, but worth it for what tends to be one of the bulkiest items. You can get them at REI, Midwest Mountaineering, Amazon, etc. I have either the 14L (M) or 20L (L). I'd go with the L if you tend to bring a good amount of clothes, since you can always cinch it down and it doesn't weigh much more or cost much more.



https://seatosummitusa.com/products/event-compression-dry-sack "



I second these. They are great for your clothes and sleeping bag.
 
JD
03/11/2020 11:26AM
 
These are spendy, but I highly recommend them for your clothes. They let air out through a micro-pore fabric but they don't let it back in. These are great for cinching your clothes down to the smallest, densest ball possible. Again, spendy, but worth it for what tends to be one of the bulkiest items. You can get them at REI, Midwest Mountaineering, Amazon, etc. I have either the 14L (M) or 20L (L). I'd go with the L if you tend to bring a good amount of clothes, since you can always cinch it down and it doesn't weigh much more or cost much more.


https://seatosummitusa.com/products/event-compression-dry-sack
 
Blatz
03/11/2020 02:17PM
 
I've used Granite Gear compression sacks and Osprey waterproof sacks, both with good results
 
bhouse46
03/15/2020 12:25PM
 
I use the eVent for my tarp as well as other gear, it works to keep the dampness from spreading to the rest of the pack.
 
CampSR
03/11/2020 11:50AM
 
I have a few ALPS Mountaineering Compression Stuff Sacks, they are very well constructed and have held up well, compress down really well also. Only water resistant unfortunately, not water proof, but I line my pack with a contractor trash bag to overcome that.
 
TipsyPaddler
03/11/2020 11:05AM
 
CCS has very nice storage sacks. Dan has some round bags that I use in my food barrel. I use four—three for each meal and one for snacks. He offers sizes for both 30L and 60L barrels. I also use one or two of his zippered storage bags for organizing small gear that gets tossed in the portage back. Usually 1-2 per pack.
 
OCDave
03/13/2020 04:07PM
 
A1t2o: "What's a good store or site for stuff sacks? I'm looking at getting more to better sort my gear and food items. I don't need them to be that big but waterproof would be a big plus and probably help with reducing the scent of the food barrel. I know that they can be expensive when buying more than one or two at a time so I'm just looking for some deals."


With 10+ years of Boy Scouts behind us and a couple more years ahead of us we've tried a lot of stuff. Ziplock Freezer bags; 1 quart, 1gallon and, 2 gallon sizes have been among the items we have found most satisfying. We pack them so they stay flat after the air is purged. We also use trash compactor bags as pack liners so a water proofing has a bit of redundancy.


Investment is about $1 -$1.25 per camper and lasts several trips before items are lost or re-purposed for trash, food waste ect.


Good Luck
 
Savage Voyageur
03/14/2020 11:03AM
 
Frenchy19: "Another fan of the CCS stuff sacks. The rectangular ones fit perfectly into the Pioneer packs. Not waterproof, but I see no need for a stuff sack to be waterproof. "


I was thinking the same thing, no need to have waterproof stuff sacks. Then I thought If my stuff sacks were waterproof, I wouldn’t need a pack liner. Now I just fill my Duluth Packs with my Sea to Summit compression sacks.
 
Banksiana
03/13/2020 06:31PM
 
Another big fan of Sea to Summit e-vent compression sacks for clothing and sleeping bag/quilt. Water tight and space saving. I use Sil-nylon stuff sacks for gear that doesn't get compressed. I use the sea to summit ultra-sil dry sack for camera gear, journal and paper anything else I want to keep dry.
 
Blatz
03/14/2020 11:56AM
 
Savage Voyageur: "Frenchy19: "Another fan of the CCS stuff sacks. The rectangular ones fit perfectly into the Pioneer packs. Not waterproof, but I see no need for a stuff sack to be waterproof. "



I was thinking the same thing, no need to have waterproof stuff sacks. Then I thought If my stuff sacks were waterproof, I’m I wouldn’t need a pack liner. Now I just fill my Duluth Packs with my Sea to Summit compression sacks. "
I look at it as the Pack liner is the first line of defense. Water proof stuff sacks are my second line of defense for my down sleeping bag and my camp clothes.
 
GickFirk22
03/11/2020 12:25PM
 
I love my E-Vent dry sack as well. I think i have an 11 Liter one. I've also purchased several of these Outdoor Research Durable Dry Sack. They've stood up to a lot of abuse. I've got a few 30L and a few 20L and use them in lieu of a pack liner. OR Durable Dry Sack
 
Frenchy19
03/13/2020 04:14PM
 
Another fan of the CCS stuff sacks. The rectangular ones fit perfectly into the Pioneer packs. Not waterproof, but I see no need for a stuff sack to be waterproof.