Click to View the Full Thread

Boundary Waters Quetico Forum :: Gear Forum :: News for you Thule and Yakima snobs
 
Author Message Text
Kendis
05/23/2023 05:20PM
 
Bro just flexed in a way no one else cares about. Must be canoeing season.
 
OCDave
05/24/2023 12:42PM
 
jillpine: "This discussion reminds me of the Red Green show.
Growing up with parents who were teenagers in the depression, they imparted all their frugality to us kids. We made do with anything we could, like a lot of people and like life before plastics. So, watching that beloved show as a kid, I never understood the humor. I thought it was more like a 1970’s version of life hacks. "



I am described as "handy" far more often than "handsome".
 
JD
05/24/2023 03:17PM
 
Roof racks ain't cheap, so it's good to hear you found a solution that let you adapt your existing setup. I think I paid around $600 for my Thule bars (the more aerodynamic ones) and I'm not really sure what I plan to do when I get another car. I was honestly probably just going to sell the car with the rack and buy a whole new setup.
 
gravelroad
05/24/2023 08:37PM
 
OCDave: "You are such a roof-rack snob. Cut to length 2x4's and a few feet of bailing wire would have served your purpose; a set of Zip-ties to replace the bailing wire if you're "fancy". Then again, some feel the need show-off a little and end up going way too fancy. The roof-rack snobs always opt for a manufactured and branded solution.



Maybe next time, if you really, really needs to justify a trip to town... consider a set of U-bolts and new, rather than salvaged, 2x4s. "



FWIW, I fabricated feet for my Honda Element from metal stock and U-bolts back in the day, rather than buy the pricey Thule version. But I would never expose others on the road to the risk of zip tie failure from weathering.
 
OtherBob
05/30/2023 03:30PM
 
3/4 galvanized pipe works as good as pricey Yakima round bars. I have different lengths to accommodate solo, tandem, and side by side tandems.


Pipe has that honest working class cachet, unlike the black bourgeois tubes. Red thread protectors for end caps are cool.
 
Jackfish
05/24/2023 08:50AM
 
To quote a quote that gets quoted here from time to time: "Your mileage may vary".
 
Frenchy19
05/24/2023 10:29AM
 
gravelroad: "Frenchy19: "Seems there is some anger in this post..."
Read it again. ;-)
hy·per·bo·le
noun
noun: hyperbole; plural noun: hyperboles
exaggerated statements or claims not meant to be taken literally.
"he vowed revenge with oaths and hyperboles" "

Thank you for that. After teaching English for 28 years, I was unaware of hyperbole;-)
 
jwartman59
05/24/2023 10:26AM
 




Actual 2x4 attached to Thule rack with you bolts. A couple of old wood canoes to complete the look
 
jillpine
05/24/2023 11:06AM
 
This discussion reminds me of the Red Green show.
Growing up with parents who were teenagers in the depression, they imparted all their frugality to us kids. We made do with anything we could, like a lot of people and like life before plastics. So, watching that beloved show as a kid, I never understood the humor. I thought it was more like a 1970’s version of life hacks.
 
justpaddlin
05/25/2023 08:31AM
 
Malone snob eh? Do the bar ends have razor sharp burrs that make you bleed and destroy the end caps when you first put them on like a real Thule?
 
justpaddlin
05/25/2023 08:33AM
 
technically_rugged: "Roof racks ain't cheap, so it's good to hear you found a solution that let you adapt your existing setup. I think I paid around $600 for my Thule bars (the more aerodynamic ones) and I'm not really sure what I plan to do when I get another car. I was honestly probably just going to sell the car with the rack and buy a whole new setup."


Used roof racks are easy to find on Craigslist or Facebook marketplace because once people buy a new car they're pretty much ready to give away their old rack (I have 3 used racks I'd give away). I'm tempted to replace my Thule rectangular bars with a Thule aero rack which would cost me $225-250 on Craigslist but I decide the better way to reduce noise from the rack is to make sure I always carry a canoe. ;)
 
Kendis
05/25/2023 10:00AM
 
gravelroad: "Kendis: "Bro just flexed in a way no one else cares about. Must be canoeing season."
And yet you found the time to comment …"

You're right, as a Yakima snob I should have stayed silent. Touche.
 
gravelroad
05/23/2023 11:44AM
 
I worked in an outdoor equipment store for five years and was a thorough Thule snob. Yakima was okay as an alternative, but Malone was clearly beyond the pale. Two experiences now have me eating crow and singing Malone’s praises simultaneously.

Malone had the clear best choice when I needed a kayak carrier suitable for my Folbot:


Malone SeaWing Kayak Carrier

Then l bought an elderly, low-mileage Sequoia last week to replace a slightly less elderly Tahoe that started showing its age in a bad, bad way. To my horror I discovered that the Thule roof rack feet from the Tahoe can’t be attached to the larger diameter raised rails on the Sequoia.

A new system from Thule would cost over $400 and leave me with trendy cross bars only 60 inches long. HOWEVER, Malone’s SteelTop feet fit the Sequoia AND I can continue to use my 78-inch Thule square bars and Thule canoe carrier. I found a set of SteelTop feet on eBay for cheap money. If I didn't have the cross bars, I'd use Malone's 65-inch version for a total system cost of about $160:

65" Malone SteelTop Cross Rail System

Suck on it, Swedes. (FWIW, my paternal grandfather and namesake was the son of Swedish immigrants.)

 
jwartman59
05/26/2023 09:37AM
 

RIP little rear wheel drive, manual transmission Ford ranger. This little guy could handle most everything except snow, especially the Duluth hills after a half inch of snow. I take great pride in not spending money on gear. I’m kind of an anti-snob snob.
 
YaMarVa
05/30/2023 03:21PM
 
justpaddlin: "Malone snob eh? Do the bar ends have razor sharp burrs that make you bleed and destroy the end caps when you first put them on like a real Thule?"


No Thule rack is complete without a set of tennis balls over the bar ends.
 
gravelroad
05/25/2023 03:29PM
 
justpaddlin: "Malone snob eh? Do the bar ends have razor sharp burrs that make you bleed and destroy the end caps when you first put them on like a real Thule?"


You forgot the tetanus risk, as I did. :-). Thanks for the reminder, as I just knocked off the Thule end caps today.


Haven’t seen any Malone bars so I can’t comment on their finish quality.
 
1JimD
05/25/2023 09:09PM
 

This homemade rack has outlasted three trucks. Two S-10s and a Dodge half ton. It not only hauled canoes, but turned my little S-10s into lumber haulers that put full sized trucks to shame!

Just something about making your own !

Jim
 
gravelroad
05/23/2023 05:33PM
 
Kendis: "Bro just flexed in a way no one else cares about. Must be canoeing season."


And yet you found the time to comment …
 
Frenchy19
05/23/2023 05:11PM
 
Seems there is some anger in this post...
 
gravelroad
05/23/2023 05:32PM
 
Frenchy19: "Seems there is some anger in this post..."


Read it again. ;-)


hy·per·bo·le
noun
noun: hyperbole; plural noun: hyperboles
exaggerated statements or claims not meant to be taken literally.
"he vowed revenge with oaths and hyperboles"



 
OCDave
05/23/2023 08:05PM
 
You are such a roof-rack snob. Cut to length 2x4's and a few feet of bailing wire would have served your purpose; a set of Zip-ties to replace the bailing wire if you're "fancy". Then again, some feel the need show-off a little and end up going way too fancy. The roof-rack snobs always opt for a manufactured and branded solution.


Maybe next time, if you really, really needs to justify a trip to town... consider a set of U-bolts and new, rather than salvaged, 2x4s.
 
foxfireniner
05/24/2023 10:25AM
 
My Yakima round bars howl like the wolves.


I love them.