Click to View the Full Thread

Boundary Waters Quetico Forum :: Fishing Forum :: Best Single Day Fishing Story
 
Author Message Text
Moonpath
03/21/2025 08:23AM
 
YaMarVa: "July of 2007, Crooked Lake, Thursday Bay. Caught 100s of bass on Torpedoes, lots in the 18-22 inch range. "


Those are really fun lures to fish with. and they produce explosive results
 
Moonpath
03/21/2025 08:26AM
 
The Sylvania is one of my favorite places to fish. I have had some very good days fishing there. So I am not surprised to hear your stories connected to it And compared to the BW it is very accessible.
 
walter
03/21/2025 11:38AM
 
About 10 years ago. One other guy and me. First day, maybe three fish. Second day nothing until trolling across the middle of a large part of the lake. This was around 10 am and we snagged a laker.

Long story short, our count was 191 lakers…average probably between 17-27 inches. My buddy split his pants while bending over to grab the canoe while on shore for lunch. When we went back out to the spot, he put some of his pants on his jig head. First time to the bottom resulted in a fish. Insane day. We left when it got too dark to continue.
 
DTrain
03/21/2025 12:56PM
 
I can't say it's my best single day of fishing, but there's a lake near Ely outside of the BWCA which is absolutely infested with bass - largemouth and smallmouth. 100 fish days per person are regularly achievable. The size is smallish. You may catch a few 19" SMB in a day. I and others I know have fished this lake several times and there's never been anyone else there. It's a freak of nature. There aren't any other fish. I don't even know what these bass forage, probably themselves.
 
portagerunner
03/21/2025 10:42AM
 
End of July last summer I experienced the best week of fishing I’ve ever had in the park. We did well every day but the last evening of the trip we had two canoes out trolling and couldn’t go more than 30 seconds without getting a bite. We quickly realized we would not need to keep smaller northern and bass to have a meal due to how aggressive the crappie and walleye were. The average size was impressive, crappies 11-15 inches and walleye 16-27 inches all caught in 4 to 5 feet of water. After a half hour of fishing we met up and realized we had plenty to eat and had to quit fishing. We each kept a stringer of eater sized fish for dinner and lamented the fact that our fishing was over. The cherry on top was catching a perch in all the action to put me over the top on the “most species caught” bet that week.

 
timatkn
03/22/2025 02:26PM
 
Another favorite involves my Dad again. This time Walleyes.


We heard Mille Lacs was fished out of walleyes. There was a very narrow slot length 16-18” could keep one fish if I remember. My Dad just wanted to fish Mille Lacs and the weather looked good. Grew up in Minny and he had never fished the big pond.


We hit 3 Mile, 5 Mile and Banana and we caught so many big walleyes it was crazy. We couldn’t crack the 30 inch mark but we caught so many nice walleyes that occasionally we would catch a small one we’d both go “put a measure on it I think he is close to 18 inches” and every time the fish was 22-24inches. Those “small” 22-24inchers actually looked small now. Our whole view of walleyes was distorted.


Last fish of the trip I caught a 17 inch keeper. Thanked it for the trip and let it go for good Karma :)


T



 
Moonpath
03/22/2025 09:19AM
 
Those are some very nice crappies. I enjoy crappie fishing about as much as fishing for any other species. Plus, crappies are good eating. Getting average crappies between 11-15 inches is phenomenal. Way to go.
 
Moonpath
03/24/2025 08:20AM
 
walter: "About 10 years ago. One other guy and me. First day, maybe three fish. Second day nothing until trolling across the middle of a large part of the lake. This was around 10 am and we snagged a laker.


Long story short, our count was 191 lakers…average probably between 17-27 inches. My buddy split his pants while bending over to grab the canoe while on shore for lunch. When we went back out to the spot, he put some of his pants on his jig head. First time to the bottom resulted in a fish. Insane day. We left when it got too dark to continue. "



That is amazing. I have caught lakers but not like this. These magical fishing days stick in your memory and help explain why we go fishing even when they are not biting.

 
arctic
03/27/2025 10:49AM
 
Late September
Two people
2.5 hours
42 lake trout
 
TuscaroraBorealis
03/24/2025 07:18PM
 



The rest of the story...
 
Moonpath
03/20/2025 09:12AM
 
What has been your single best day fishing? This could involve catching a trophy fish, many fish, a certain kind or mix of fish (grand slam) or so on. Here is mine.

Once upon our return to Prairie Portage for our ride back to Moose Lake, we got back with about 2 hours to spare. My friend, Rambo and I decided to fish the rapids below the falls one last time for SM bass.

Our bait was a small white tube jig with a white curly tail. Casting out deep brought no bites. We switched to fishing in the shallow rapids themselves. Immediately, we both started getting bites. These were SM bass in the 12 to 14 inch range. Not big, but very aggressive. We decided to have a contest. Who could catch the most in one hour.

Every cast produced fish and many got off. Soon, our tube jigs looked mutilated but still produced. Neither of us wanted to stop and change baits for fear of falling behind.

After one hour, the tally was 100 for yours truly, and 96 for Rambo. So in one hour we caught 196 bass. I have never come close to matching that catch rate, it was truly amazing. I have caught many larger fish, muskie, pike, salmon, trout, but have never had so much fun.
 
Speckled
03/20/2025 11:55AM
 
Two stories that I like to tell.

Lac La Croix (Day 2) - First day was a travel day and we just chilled in camp. We had no plans for day two other than to probably wander over to Warrior Hill at some point.

I awoke later than the three other participants and found the breakfast fire dwindling. The other three individuals were all down on the shore spread out around our island casting for whatever was biting. I cut some wood and stoked the fire back up, heated some water and ate my oats. Had a cup of coffee and decided to wander down to the shore to cast as well. The others had been at it for over an hour - no bites.

My first cast produced about a 16 inch smallie. We decided fish lunch was in order so we threw it on the stringer with the hopes of picking up a couple more.

My second cast produced it's twin. On the stringer it went. I now have the attention of all my trip mates. "What are you using? What color?" One of the fellas actually had the exact same lure on.

Third cast - this one's heavier - a nice big fat northern, maybe six pounds. Released it. I'm now at three fish in three casts. Everyone else is still blank.

Fourth cast was a slightly smaller smallie. On the stringer it went and we figured that's enough for lunch. Four fish in four casts.

The fella with the same lure asks, "What are you doing with it? How are you fishing?" I try to describe the twitching method to him and he tries a couple times with no luck. I say, let me show you. He hands me his rod and I cast it out. One twitch - FISH ON! I hand it back to him. It was a nice 18+ inch smallie. Five fish - five casts.

The second was a trip to Crooked where four people, all in solos, went out one morning and all four came back with stories of a personal best fish. Four fisherman - four personal best fish in one morning - a 22 inch smallmouth, 38 inch northern, 27 inch walleye and 25 inch walleye.
 
santacruz
05/11/2025 07:56AM
 
So many to mention, on a small quetico lake full of smallmouth and eyes, we caught many, our top five Averaged 5 lbs.
My largest was 5.7, we then proceeded to catch walleyes for a shore lunch. Blue sky, sunny August day.
 
Moonpath
05/11/2025 08:32AM
 
QueticoMike: "We were at the end of the creek where it met the colder lake water on this late May trip. We both had ZMAN ShadZ tied onto the end of our lines and what was about to happen that morning is almost beyond belief. When we began casting towards the opposite shoreline it quickly became apparent this hole was stacked like cord wood with smallmouth bass. Every cast there was a fish. If we had to twitch the lure more than twice, we started to wonder why there wasn’t a smallmouth on the other end of the line. We tried to count doubles, but after 50 some doubles we started to lose count. We were somewhere in the 150 fish range at that period of the figurative slaughter. There were times when only one of us was hooked up with a fish during the outing, but it was a rare occasion. I had never encountered any fishing like this in my life. These weren’t little smallmouth either, they averaged in the 16 to 19-inch range for the most part with a handful of 20s thrown into the mix. All of these fish were caught in less than a 20-yard stretch of the lake. If I didn’t see this happen, I wouldn’t have believed it happened. I also witnessed my fishing partner reel in a smallmouth and when it was maybe 10 feet from him the lure pulled loose from the fish. The lure went about another 3 or 4 feet in the water towards him. In an instant the smallmouth bolted towards the lure and sucked it up again practically at his feet. This incredible fishing went on for hours until things began to slow. When I say “things”, I mean the fish biting and us being tired from all of the action. In the end, Mike speculated we must have caught 500 smallmouth. I told him to come back down to earth. I think somewhere in the neighborhood of 300 to 350 smallmouth bass during that outing would be a more realistic number. It was just unbelievable fishing." Wow, sensational., I have not had this kind of luck ever in terms of size, but have caught many smallmouth in one day. Way to go and great storry
 
AceAceAce
05/11/2025 10:23AM
 
One of my most memorable is a family trip on a lake off the Gunflint trail. We were supposed to go into the BW for a couple nights but a fire closure changed the trip into a campground based adventure. We had been fishing around the lake with mixed luck, a few fish but nothing crazy.


Early afternoon, we anchored over a rock reef ledge area and my wife and daughter started catching fish, mind you nothing large at all, mostly rock bass less than 5-6", but they were having fun. As a dad fishing with his family that is all that mattered. I was so busy helping them I hardly fished at all. My daughter said at one point "Dad I'm sorry you're not having any fun." I still can't explain to her how much fun it was. She'll get it someday.


Occasionally a larger smallmouth would follow their tiny fish in, and I'd toss out a ZMAN minnow and catch it - that was fun.


We ended the day at 99 fish, because we were out of the leeches we'd been using as bait. I'd even started cutting them into pieces to stretch them further. I had artificial bait but these tiny fish were not interested in that. My daughter refused to give up until we got 100, trying everything from raisins from the trail mix to a bare hook.


We finally called it a day and headed back to camp, only to hear that a five year old had hauled in an 18'' smallmouth from the dock - with a barbie fishing poll....


We still refer to that as the day of 99 fish!

 
Gunwhale
05/11/2025 06:50PM
 
All caught and released, all in Canada: best walleye day: 5 over 29" with the best at 31 1/2. Best lifetime walleye and best day of big fish. At this age, not likely to do better.


Best fly rod pike: 39" C&R Still trying for a 40 " fish.


Best number of walleyes: 3 hours of non stop bite for 16"-18" fish and two guys. I used plastic, other guy used minnow/jig. All C& R. Just one of those flukes, every bait and every presentation worked. Called time because of weather and distance back to camp.
 
QueticoMike
05/07/2025 07:03PM
 
We were at the end of the creek where it met the colder lake water on this late May trip. We both had ZMAN ShadZ tied onto the end of our lines and what was about to happen that morning is almost beyond belief. When we began casting towards the opposite shoreline it quickly became apparent this hole was stacked like cord wood with smallmouth bass. Every cast there was a fish. If we had to twitch the lure more than twice, we started to wonder why there wasn’t a smallmouth on the other end of the line. We tried to count doubles, but after 50 some doubles we started to lose count. We were somewhere in the 150 fish range at that period of the figurative slaughter. There were times when only one of us was hooked up with a fish during the outing, but it was a rare occasion. I had never encountered any fishing like this in my life. These weren’t little smallmouth either, they averaged in the 16 to 19-inch range for the most part with a handful of 20s thrown into the mix. All of these fish were caught in less than a 20-yard stretch of the lake. If I didn’t see this happen, I wouldn’t have believed it happened. I also witnessed my fishing partner reel in a smallmouth and when it was maybe 10 feet from him the lure pulled loose from the fish. The lure went about another 3 or 4 feet in the water towards him. In an instant the smallmouth bolted towards the lure and sucked it up again practically at his feet. This incredible fishing went on for hours until things began to slow. When I say “things”, I mean the fish biting and us being tired from all of the action. In the end, Mike speculated we must have caught 500 smallmouth. I told him to come back down to earth. I think somewhere in the neighborhood of 300 to 350 smallmouth bass during that outing would be a more realistic number. It was just unbelievable fishing.
 
mgraber
03/27/2025 03:29PM
 
There are many, a few 100+ fish days, huge fish, etc. but on a fairly recent canoe trip I got a grand slam in the first 20 minutes of throwing a line out, and a couple days later, after catching several hundred walleye,pike, smallmouth, lakers and rock bass, we portaged into a neighboring lake and caught over 50 largemouth 15"-18" in 1/2 day. This was all in July and hot weather. I love canoe country fishing... and people are talking about hauling in side imaging, down imaging, livescope, lol. How many fish do you need to catch?
 
timatkn
03/22/2025 01:56PM
 
I have been blessed. I’m can’t pick one. Here is my first one.


My favorite was Lake Trout: Took my Dad on his first trip he was nearly 60. My brother and I packed him in my Souris River Quetico 18.5 and 10 hours 16 portages and 25 miles later we reached our secret camp exhausted. Well we thought it was a secret… I met a fellow poster there in the camp we had targeted LOL.


Anyway we had a 4-6 hour window where we trolled for trout and it was just one after another all what I would call lunkers. Every fish was 34 inches or bigger and THICK. My Dad caught a 38 and 40 incher. All caught on silver black or blue DT 16. This was early May, right out in the middle of the lake fishing maybe 15-20 feet down. They were feeding on a HUGE school of Ciscoes near the surface. We just happened to find them by accident. We were fishing a point then moved across the lake to try to find a reef but kept our lines out and boom there they were in 80-100’ of water. We didn’t keep count, but wasn’t as many as you would think. We would all troll, one would hook up, everyone else reeled in, then we would net the fish in a rubberized net…repeat. The whole process took time. Later we thought if we jigged we could have done better but I can’t complain. Each catch we all felt a part of. Our net broke at some point the aluminum handle couldn’t handle the weight :)


Further it was a great trip, because it was my Dad’s first Wilderness trip. Up until that time my Dad was always in charge of trips/vacations that he went on previous to this, he couldn’t believe how efficient we were portaging, setting up camp, cooking etc… I remember after the first portage he asked how much longer and my brother and I thought “oh no” we had told him it was a rough trip, but he didn’t believe us LOL. He did great though!









Broke the net







An average trout
 
timatkn
03/22/2025 02:36PM
 
Final best day was crappie fishing on Truman Lake in Missouri. Once again with my Dad.


We were having a great trip, fishing was better than normal. Then the last day the weather warmed up perfectly and there was a thunder storm looming….in 4 hours my Dad and I caught our limit of 30 crappies. All we kept were 11-12 inchers. The majority of the fish were 13-14 inches but we let them go. It was a fish on every cast basically. You would have to cast as far as possible and they hit way out so you got your moneys worth on every fight. We were using swim baits, and the crappies would just hit them hard. Sometimes almost pull the pole out of your hand.


They were all staging for spawn we think all at once. Almost never happens, the weather is usually too sporadic. I don’t think I’ll ever see this again in my life. We had this bay/creek arm all to ourselves.


Came in to eat lunch, huge thunderstorm unleashed for 4 hours. We had another day of fishing planned, but we all just boated up and left. Anything else was going to be a disappointment after that :) and we had our fish. Didn’t keep a fish for the rest of the year after that.


T






 
goblu79
03/23/2025 01:56PM
 
I have only quit fishing due to exhaustion twice in my lifetime. The most recent, on Smirch Lake in the Turtle River/White Otter PP in 2021. I didn't count the fish, but my partner and I were catching SMB, Walleye and Pike on about 75 percent of casts for a solid hour. We had already had a very good day fishing before this. I finally quit when my back said "NO MORE!!!!" and we paddled in. I was afraid to throw a lure out on the way back to camp, for fear it would catch something I had to land. Our other camp mates reported very similar results, including a 48" Northern. Epic day.


Had a similar day on McIntyre in Quetico 2023. Mostly smallies around a small island close to the 5 star site at the north end. Darkness probably prevented this from being a bigger day, but I had to stop fishing in order to paddle back to camp in the dark. We tried to fish our way back, but kept having to stop to remove a fish.


In both cases, we had "doubles" so many times we stopped counting...I'd guess about 20 give or take.
 
Gadfly
03/20/2025 11:32AM
 
100 fish in an hour? I think you posted this story a week about 12 days too early.
 
YaMarVa
03/20/2025 12:23PM
 
July of 2007, Crooked Lake, Thursday Bay. Caught 100s of bass on Torpedoes, lots in the 18-22 inch range.
 
Savage Voyageur
03/20/2025 02:33PM
 
I have had two 100 fish days, both on Clearwater. The smallmouth bass were just crazy. I used a #2 Mepps inline spinner with the barbs pinched down. After a while I figured I better bend the barbs down because the action was so fast. the next day I figured I would try a Rapala shad rap. I casted it into a low hanging cedar branch. The lure was pulled free with a few tugs and hit the water. I caught two fish on one lure. The action was fast and furious until it started raining. Just a few drops of rain that hit the water and the fish light switched off.
 
lundojam
03/20/2025 08:42PM
 
Just outside the BWCA in SNF. The family is in two canoes. Mrs. Lundo says "let's bobber fish." I knew better than to doubt her intuition, so I rigged up slip-bobbers for all, paddled to a drop-off, tied the canoes together, and dropped the anchor. The kids proceeded to HAMMER nice keep walleyes in the 17" neighborhood. A moose walked by on shore. Fast, consistent action. Tons of fun.
 
papalambeau
03/20/2025 02:49PM
 
One of my fondest BW fishing memories was our first and only trip to Cherry Lake. We made it in to Cherry, set up camp, ate some chow and headed out fishing. We had six guys and three canoes so we headed out to cover new water.

I'm with my oldest son and he hooks into something big, down deep. We think it's a laker or a big northern, but as he's bringing it up, we see the white on the tail and it's a monster walleye! He plays it and we get it in the canoe and we can't believe it. We head to shore and the other two canoes join us to take measurements and pics. A 32" beauty with a nice wide girth (can't remember the girth measurement off hand). We have the release on video and a beauty of a replica mount on the wall.
 
Jefflynn06
03/20/2025 04:21PM
 
Two "best" days - both in Sylvania, one year apart.


One - Brother and his son, and I took our 81 year old stepdad to Sylvania. My nephew and stepdad were in a bay that was visible from the camp site. Brother and I watched them catch (or miss due to barbless requirement) fish on about 50-60 percents of their casts for about 30 minutes. They wound up keeping about 15-20 bluegills. Our stepdad, who fished a lot in both WI and AZ, said it was his best day fishing in his life. So his best day fishing became one of our best days fishing - just from being a part of it.


Two - Returned to Sylvania the next summer with three other guys. One of my buddies and I took the canoe in a small bay and started out catching a few (and missing an equal amount) for the first 20-30 minutes. Then we hit a spot where we were catching (some misses) fish on about 90 percent of our casts. I was in the stern and had the stringer. My buddy started catching keeper bluegills. He'd toss the fish to me or I'd grab the line and fish in the back and start to put it on the stringer. I'd get that done and I'd toss it back into the water while he resumed casting and he'd catch another one. He did this with about 5-6 straight casts and I had to tell him to stop so I could fish as all I was doing was putting his fish on the stringer. He just looked at me and laughed and said it was the best fishing day of his life! He did pause and let me cast and catch fish just about a often as he did. We probably caught about 80 fish in about 45 minutes. Non-stop action!

 
YaMarVa
04/01/2025 02:35PM
 
Moonpath: "YaMarVa: "July of 2007, Crooked Lake, Thursday Bay. Caught 100s of bass on Torpedoes, lots in the 18-22 inch range. "



Those are really fun lures to fish with. and they produce explosive results"



I've since switched to Whopper Ploppers and the results are even more explosive. I still keep a few Torpedoes in my tackle box because for about a decade they were my go-to summer SM lure.
 
lundojam
04/01/2025 09:09AM
 
Well done, sir.^^^ :)
 
gqualls
04/01/2025 06:09AM
 
The best single day fishing story for me was when my son and I were in the BWCA on this beautiful late June day that is etched, no, burned would be more like it, in our memories.
The day began with perfect weather, not only in the morning but throughout the day. There we just enough clouds and just enough breeze and I remember thinking "It's a great day to have a great day".
We have 5 trips together under our belts and our goal was simply to catch fish. We had decided the night before to fish the following day as long as there was enough light to see. We would only stop to eat. We targeted reefs, points, and cobble lined banks. Early morning we used topwater baits. Once the sun came up we started going below the surface with 3 and 4 inch plastics on 1/8 oz and 1/4 oz jig heads. Later in the evening we fished topwater exclusively. When we came across coves filled with grass or cabbage weed we threw Frogs and Flukes.
The surprise lure was an in-line spinner that I made and I tied the treble hook not only with a very specific color but also the hair extended beyond the treble hook 3-4 inches. Two of my PB fish came off that spinner bait. We made several videos and took a lot of pictures on our Go Pro.
Rather than dribble on and on about what we used and how we used certain lure I'll just share the final count:
Smallmouth : 347 ( largest was 8.2 lbs and 26.5 inches long ... a true hog)
Pike: 82 (largest was 45 inches estimating weight to be 22-24 lbs)
Lake Trout: 6 (largest was 22 inches; I know they were small but it was June and we had never caught LT before so we were happy)
Walleye: 116 (largest was 33 inches caught on my in line spinner)
Crappie: 6 ( largest was 23 inches and weight was right at 6 lbs. Fish of the trip. This fish was also caught on my inline spinner.)
I have never had a day like this and I attribute most of our fish to the inline spinner and the hair I used on the treble hook. It was actually a combination of 3 colors and I can't disclose anything else as I am in the process of getting some utility patents with Damon John and Laurie Greiner with the hopes of going on QVC in about 2 months.
We fished approximately 16.5 hours that day and the day ended with my son throwing a Zara Puppy around a beaver dam only to get it snagged. We eased over to the dam and he , my smart son, decided to get out of the canoe and try to stand on the dam (I know, I know) and both of his legs went straight through to his waist. Apparently, momma and daddy were both home and grabbed onto his legs. He clutches onto the side of the canoe and tries to pull himself out but both beavers are pulling on his legs ................... just like I am pulling yours.


Happy April 1st
 
mgraber
04/01/2025 04:01PM
 
gqualls: "The best single day fishing story for me was when my son and I were in the BWCA on this beautiful late June day that is etched, no, burned would be more like it, in our memories.
The day began with perfect weather, not only in the morning but throughout the day. There we just enough clouds and just enough breeze and I remember thinking "It's a great day to have a great day".
We have 5 trips together under our belts and our goal was simply to catch fish. We had decided the night before to fish the following day as long as there was enough light to see. We would only stop to eat. We targeted reefs, points, and cobble lined banks. Early morning we used topwater baits. Once the sun came up we started going below the surface with 3 and 4 inch plastics on 1/8 oz and 1/4 oz jig heads. Later in the evening we fished topwater exclusively. When we came across coves filled with grass or cabbage weed we threw Frogs and Flukes.
The surprise lure was an in-line spinner that I made and I tied the treble hook not only with a very specific color but also the hair extended beyond the treble hook 3-4 inches. Two of my PB fish came off that spinner bait. We made several videos and took a lot of pictures on our Go Pro.
Rather than dribble on and on about what we used and how we used certain lure I'll just share the final count:
Smallmouth : 347 ( largest was 8.2 lbs and 26.5 inches long ... a true hog)
Pike: 82 (largest was 45 inches estimating weight to be 22-24 lbs)
Lake Trout: 6 (largest was 22 inches; I know they were small but it was June and we had never caught LT before so we were happy)
Walleye: 116 (largest was 33 inches caught on my in line spinner)
Crappie: 6 ( largest was 23 inches and weight was right at 6 lbs. Fish of the trip. This fish was also caught on my inline spinner.)
I have never had a day like this and I attribute most of our fish to the inline spinner and the hair I used on the treble hook. It was actually a combination of 3 colors and I can't disclose anything else as I am in the process of getting some utility patents with Damon John and Laurie Greiner with the hopes of going on QVC in about 2 months.
We fished approximately 16.5 hours that day and the day ended with my son throwing a Zara Puppy around a beaver dam only to get it snagged. We eased over to the dam and he , my smart son, decided to get out of the canoe and try to stand on the dam (I know, I know) and both of his legs went straight through to his waist. Apparently, momma and daddy were both home and grabbed onto his legs. He clutches onto the side of the canoe and tries to pull himself out but both beavers are pulling on his legs ................... just like I am pulling yours.



Happy April 1st"




I honestly thought you were expecting us to believe you for awhile!