| Author |
Message Text |
|
mgraber
|
Bent shaft all the way for us. Works perfect for the pitch stroke and decent for a true J stroke and adds a bit of speed over a straight. Once you've used one for awhile, all necessary strokes are fairly easy. I would not use one for a fast river or whitewater trip. I resisted for a lot of years, but would never go back now.
|
|
TreeBear
|
One guide summer for me with the standard outfitter aluminum and plastic straight shaft paddle and the wrist tendonitis was unbearable. Part of it was how I was doing my j's, part was the horrible paddle. Moved to a very light wood bent shaft and haven't looked back.
|
|
WaveRunner
|
Greetings, just looking for some opinions on using a straight vs bent shaft in the stern position. I’m thinking the primary reason for a straight shaft is greater stroke control, but doing so may sacrifice some power you get from a bent shaft. I am an experienced Boundary Waters traveler with many trips under my belt. This discussion came up on a recent trip and I am just curious what others are doing. Thanks for your comments!
|
|
Jackfish
|
Bent shaft for me 100% of the time. Same for the bow paddler, too, btw.
|
|
sedges
|
The only situation where loss of control options with a bent-shaft would matter is moving water with obstacles requiring quick maneuvers. Pries, draws, braces high and especially low. Straight shafts are also less likely to break when abused. Using it as a pole for instance.
The benefits of the mechanics of a properly used bent are well excepted. As I age I especially feel the difference in my shoulders. I always carry a spare paddle, so I make it a straight and use it in shallow situations where I am pushing off or using it as a pole.
|
|
bottomtothetap
|
I love my Bending Branches double-bent Viper, bow or stern. It just feels so good and seems to work so well giving me all of the power an maneuverability I want.
|
|
Blatz
|
It's funny how things have changed. Back in the early 90s I used a carbon bent Shaft Barton paddle in the BW. Oh the negative comments I received. "What do you need that for, you're not racing or that thing won't last a week in the BW" Unless you're doing moving water, the bent shaft is a great choice for the BW because of it's straight ahead efficiency.However, you would be surprised how much it can be used for extreme turns in the right hands.
|
|
Capsize
|
The bent shaft paddle is a game changer in the stern from a steering perspective. I can pull the back end of the canoe left or right very easily by reversing the paddle and doing a 45 degree angle approach from the front/side back toward me. This pulls the canoe toward my paddle while still pushing me forward. In strong cross winds this stroke lets me keep the canoe straight with very little ruddering, which has improved my efficiency quite a bit. In tight creeks at slow speeds it allows me to turn the canoe on a dime. By far the most improved piece of gear that I have used over the past 30 years.
|
|
jwartman59
|
Depends on the canoe. In a canoe with rocker I always use a straight shaft. I always prefer a canoe with a small amount of rocker
|
|
Speckled
|
Fun read.
What's best? Bent vs. straight shaft canoe paddles
|
|
timatkn
|
I didn’t know they still made straight shaft paddles :)
T
|
|
Tony
|
I like to use the straight bladed paddle when I paddle stern because it gives me more control but most of the time I paddle solo anyways so then I use a bent shaft.
Either way I take both a straight blade and a bench shaft with me on all my trips. And both of them are carbon fiber it makes a world a difference. When I switch with my partners sometimes grabbing that wood paddle feels like a 2x4.
Tony
|
|
andym
|
I’m in the camp of taking two paddles. One is a carbon fiber bent for long distances and speed. The other is a wood straight for when lots of steering power is needed in quartering winds, very twisty creeks, and rocky portage landings where I might want to push off. Plus sometimes it is nice to switch from the high rate with the small blade of the bent to the larger blade and a slower rate with the straight. Differences are nice. Why choose just one?
|
|
MikeinMpls
|
I used the same classic Sawyer straight shaft paddle for 40 years. I bought it when I was 16. I had a sentimental attachment to it (and still do.) Two years ago I purchased a Bending Branches Black Pearl carbon bent shaft paddle. I still take my straight shaft paddle as a spare. When tandem canoeing with my wife, I paddle in the back. I have found no significant loss of efficiency and turning or maneuvering using the bent shaft. We don't canoe fast rivers or whitewater so that isn't an issue.
It might take me a little bit more energy to execute a draw stroke with the bent shaft paddle. Once in a while if I want to make a very strong draw stroke, I will turn my bent shaft paddle around and push the water toward the stern in that manner. I find that I can push a little bit more water for a quicker turn. (I quick look around before I do this to make sure nobody sees me using my bent shaft paddle backwards. <<< tongue-in-cheek comment.)
Mike
|
|
OCDave
|
Long and straight while solo or stern.
|
|
tumblehome
|
Bent shaft for me.
I break the rules of paddle length and use a longer bent shaft paddle than the 'experts' tell me to use.
I paddle solo almost all the time. I like to get the blade back behind me to rudder.
Tom
|
|
Pinetree
|
a slightly bent in the stern
|
|
justpaddlin
|
I use a straight shaft. I also kneel and paddle tandems with rocker and paddle rivers more often than lakes. If I was a sitting paddler in a zero rocker boat and always on lakes I'd probably stick with a bent shaft like I do in my Advantage.
|
|
keth0601
|
I think it depends on your paddling style. I like to kneel and heel the canoe over a bit when I can which means I wouldn't get much (if any) advantage from a bent shaft so I mostly use a straight paddle. I've used bent shafts as well and have no complaints other than usage in moving water as others have mentioned.
|
|
WaveRunner
|
Fun article! And right on topic. Thanks for sharing the link!
|
|
gravelroad
|
sedges: "The only situation where loss of control options with a bent-shaft would matter is moving water with obstacles requiring quick maneuvers. Pries, draws, braces high and especially low. Straight shafts are also less likely to break when abused. Using it as a pole for instance.
The benefits of the mechanics of a properly used bent are well excepted. As I age I especially feel the difference in my shoulders. I always carry a spare paddle, so I make it a straight and use it in shallow situations where I am pushing off or using it as a pole."
This.
|
|
ISRO
|
I am learning there are other paddles besides a ZRE Bent shaft, how interesting.
:)
|
|
HayRiverDrifter
|
Yep, bent all the way here. Flat water or drifting the river.
|