Click to View the Full Thread

Boundary Waters Quetico Forum :: Gear Forum :: GSI Carbon Steel Skillets
 
Author Message Text
Finnboy
04/15/2025 08:53PM
 
I have one. I’ve only used it on one 5 day trip. Worked great.
 
Moonpath
04/17/2025 08:18AM
 
These appear to be really nice skillets, I will have to look into one,
 
OCDave
04/17/2025 01:34PM
 
bombinbrian: "Anyone know why this says it can't be used over a campfire?


https://gsioutdoors.com/products/carbon-steel-frypan"



With so many alternative available, including other GSI skillets, that are suitable for use over a campfire, why would one buy a camping skillet specifically advertised as not suitable for use over a campfire?


Guidecast Frying Pan


Steel Fry Pan


If you have a round hole, avoid shopping in the square pegs aisle.




 
LoonJuice
04/18/2025 11:03AM
 
Avoid Non-stick coatings… Forged RAW aluminum is where it’s at ;)
 
fadersup
04/18/2025 09:11PM
 
OCDave: "bombinbrian: "Anyone know why this says it can't be used over a campfire?



https://gsioutdoors.com/products/carbon-steel-frypan"




With so many alternative available, including other GSI skillets, that are suitable for use over a campfire, why would one buy a camping skillet specifically advertised as not suitable for use over a campfire?



Guidecast Frying Pan



Steel Fry Pan



If you have a round hole, avoid shopping in the square pegs aisle.




"



That GSI cast iron looks pretty good, I think a no-handle design (using a pot gripper) would be ideal - handles are clumsy to pack.


Agree that the nonstick option is a pass for cooking on fires.
 
sns
04/15/2025 06:01PM
 
Our 16" Carbon Steel pan should have topographic lines drawn on it....still works fine. Leather fire gloves solve the other problem.
 
bombinbrian
04/15/2025 08:06AM
 
Anyone know why this says it can't be used over a campfire?

https://gsioutdoors.com/products/carbon-steel-frypan
 
Tryin
04/15/2025 01:24PM
 
Guessing, but warping and hot handle burns are probably the concerns.
 
bombinbrian
04/15/2025 03:56PM
 
I just called GSI and that's the exact reason they gave.