BWCA GSI Carbon Steel Skillets Boundary Waters Gear Forum

Chat Rooms (0 Chatting) | Search | Login/Join

* BWCA is supported by its audience. When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.

Boundary Waters Quetico Forum

Gear Forum

GSI Carbon Steel Skillets

Forum Sponsor

Author

Text

bombinbrian

04/15/2025 08:06AM

Anyone know why this says it can't be used over a campfire?

https://gsioutdoors.com/products/carbon-steel-frypan

Print Top Bottom Previous Next

Tryin

04/15/2025 01:24PM

Guessing, but warping and hot handle burns are probably the concerns.

Print Top Bottom Previous Next

bombinbrian

04/15/2025 03:56PM

I just called GSI and that's the exact reason they gave.

Print Top Bottom Previous Next

sns

04/15/2025 06:01PM

Our 16" Carbon Steel pan should have topographic lines drawn on it....still works fine. Leather fire gloves solve the other problem.

"I don't care what you believe. I care what you can prove." -Philosopher & Mathematician JJJ

Print Top Bottom Previous Next

Finnboy

04/15/2025 08:53PM

I have one. I’ve only used it on one 5 day trip. Worked great.

Print Top Bottom Previous Next

Moonpath

04/17/2025 08:18AM

These appear to be really nice skillets, I will have to look into one,

Print Top Bottom Previous Next

OCDave

04/17/2025 01:34PM

bombinbrian: "Anyone know why this says it can't be used over a campfire?

https://gsioutdoors.com/products/carbon-steel-frypan"

With so many alternative available, including other GSI skillets, that are suitable for use over a campfire, why would one buy a camping skillet specifically advertised as not suitable for use over a campfire?

Guidecast Frying Pan

Steel Fry Pan

If you have a round hole, avoid shopping in the square pegs aisle.

Print Top Bottom Previous Next

LoonJuice

04/18/2025 11:03AM

Avoid Non-stick coatings… Forged RAW aluminum is where it’s at ;)

Print Top Bottom Previous Next

fadersup

04/18/2025 09:11PM

OCDave: "
bombinbrian: "Anyone know why this says it can't be used over a campfire?

https://gsioutdoors.com/products/carbon-steel-frypan"

With so many alternative available, including other GSI skillets, that are suitable for use over a campfire, why would one buy a camping skillet specifically advertised as not suitable for use over a campfire?

Guidecast Frying Pan

Steel Fry Pan

If you have a round hole, avoid shopping in the square pegs aisle.

"

That GSI cast iron looks pretty good, I think a no-handle design (using a pot gripper) would be ideal - handles are clumsy to pack.

Agree that the nonstick option is a pass for cooking on fires.

Print Top Bottom Previous Next

osteology

05/10/2025 09:25AM

Another carbon steel pan with a removable handle. I've been happy with it so far - seasoned easily, the handle snaps back on easily enough to remove from the fire. Comes in three sizes - 8, 10, 12 in

https://www.oxo.com/oxo-outdoor-10-carbon-steel-pan.html

Print Top Bottom Previous Next