BWCA Top 10 Smallie Lures Boundary Waters Fishing Forum
Chat Rooms (0 Chatting)  |  Search  |   Login/Join
* BWCA is supported by its audience. When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.
Boundary Waters Quetico Forum
   Fishing Forum
      Top 10 Smallie Lures     
 Forum Sponsor

Author

Text

QueticoMike
distinguished member(5280)distinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished memberpower member
  
02/22/2012 10:40AM  
Here is my list for favorite smallmouth lures. All of these don't pertain to strictly the Boundary Waters\Quetico. Some work better on my river in Ohio. I do use a lot of them at both locations. I do not have the standard jig or twisty tail on my list. The only reason is because I don't care for jigging or being snagged all of the time. I do use tube baits though. So with all of that said here are my favorite top 10 in no particular order.

Zulu - blue glimmer\pearl
Lucky 13 - bullfrog
Double willow spinner bait - chartreuse
Berkley Power tube - bleeding watermelon
Pop-R - blue\shad
Mepps spinner - size 3 or larger - silver blade\white bucktail
Floating Rapala - size 11 - black and silver
Buzzbait - black
Rebel Craw - 2 1/2 inch version - chartreuse
Tiny Torpedo - bullfrog

Can't go wrong here......... fish on!
 
      Print Top Bottom Previous Next
Arlo Pankook
distinguished member(2534)distinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished member
  
02/22/2012 12:06PM  
Pop-R
Jerk Shad or Zulu
Husky Jerk
1/4 oz jig and Power Grub (Chart/pumpkin)

let me think about this some more...
 
keithcatfish
distinguished member (232)distinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished member
  
02/22/2012 01:05PM  
senko
senko
senko
senko
senko
senko
zara puppy
shad rap
green/brown grub
buzzbait

In that order.
 
Mad_Angler
distinguished member(1720)distinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished member
  
02/22/2012 01:26PM  
Jig, slip bobber, leech (by far my most productive)
Zulu (see BWJ article)
Any topwater popper
Taildancer (Catching smallies while trolling for other things)
 
QueticoMike
distinguished member(5280)distinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished memberpower member
  
02/22/2012 01:39PM  
quote keithcatfish: "senko
senko
senko
senko
senko
senko
zara puppy
shad rap
green/brown grub
buzzbait


In that order."


How are you rigging your senko? Never used one, but I am interested. Best color?
 
CrookedPaddler1
distinguished member(1363)distinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished member
  
02/22/2012 01:50PM  
foam popper
clauser minnow
wolly bugger
might mite (hellgramite)
deer hair popper
 
Savage Voyageur
distinguished member(14416)distinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished membermaster membermaster member
  
02/22/2012 02:32PM  
quote CrookedPaddler1: "foam popper
clauser minnow
wolly bugger
might mite (hellgramite)
deer hair popper
"




I will be using all but one for my next trip. Thanks for the confirmation of my lure choices.
 
jphares44
senior member (54)senior membersenior member
  
02/22/2012 02:43PM  
Zoom SuperFluke (watermelon red)
Chompers Twister-tail grub
Yum Wooly Bug (watermelon or green pumpkin)
Strike King Mop Jig w/ trailer (PBJ)
Senko w/ drop-shot rig (heck, any color)
4" Ring Fry on Texas rig (again, love the watermelon / pumpkin)


Well, listed 6 of 10 I guess. I'll second just about every lure someone else has mentioned already. We all know there are so many determining factors that can change rapidly when selecting lures, but I've had really good luck catching quality bass all year long with the lures mentioned above.
 
Moonman
distinguished member(929)distinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished member
  
02/22/2012 02:52PM  
spinning:

#11 rapala perch
#11 rapala natural
perch shad rap
black curly tail jig
black bucktail jig
smoke/watermelon tube jig
spinnerbait. orange willow leaf blades, black skirt
black tiny torpedo
black jitterbug
plastic natural jerk bait minnow - like the fin-s-fish, fished weightless


fly

angel hair streamer, blue over white
deceiver, olive over white
clouser, chart over white
clouser, black
Morish mouse popper, black
Morish mouse popper, natural
dahlberg diver black
black/purple rabbit strip leech
DDH leech
wiggle damsel fly nymph

Moonman.

 
02/22/2012 03:13PM  
mepps spinner #3 dressed copper

wordens rooster tail in plain red.silver spoon

senko wacky rigged

rebel deep craw

case plastics helgramite

those are the lures, if I have live helgramites,craws,crawlers or grasshoppers......even better for me than lures
 
toddhunter
distinguished member(543)distinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished member
  
02/22/2012 03:36PM  
Senko (black/blue, watermelon) (or Dinger, Flick Shake, etc)
jerkbait (td minnow, pointer, x rap)
jig/grub (not jigged, just straight retrieve)(brown/pepper)
topwaters (pop r, chug bug, etc)
spinnerbaits (3/16 oz)
spinners (mepps style)
tubes (#1 outside of BW, but too snaggy for me in BW)
If i had enough room, I'd experiment with more colors on the above lures. Ordinary diving baits haven't done so well for me. I'll be trying a few lipless crankbaits this year based on recommondations.
The above lures also catch pike and should catch walleye (if I ever locate them).
For smallies, just cast to likely spots, such as rocky shores, emergent stumps, weed beds, and reefs if you're lucky enough to find them. Get close enough, and the fish, if there, will find your lure.
 
Basspro69
distinguished member(14135)distinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished membermaster membermaster member
  
02/22/2012 04:07PM  
1. 4 inch Berkley Powerworm Black On 1/8 ounce Charlie Brewer Spider slider head, My number one by far for numbers of fish and big fish, responsible for 30 to 35 smallies over 5 pounds. Use it in clear water mostly.
2. Spinnerbait Black with gold blades.
3. Floating Rapala
4. Road Runner 1/16 ounce yellow white or chartreuse.
5. Tube Jig
6. Mepps 2 or 3 Dressed with Silver gold or firetiger blades.
7. Rattlin Rapala Blue and Silver or Crayfish colored.
8. Jerkbait.
9. Black Jitterbug possibly my favorite lure of all time fun fun fun.
10. Little Cleo
I have to mention that when all these fail, which is almost never, or I just want some down time from casting, a hook bobber and leech will get it done for you also.
 
GeoFisher
distinguished member(1459)distinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished member
  
02/22/2012 07:55PM  
quote QueticoMike: "
Here is my list for favorite smallmouth lures. All of these don't pertain to strictly the Boundary Waters\Quetico. Some work better on my river in Ohio. I do use a lot of them at both locations. I do not have the standard jig or twisty tail on my list. The only reason is because I don't care for jigging or being snagged all of the time. I do use tube baits though. So with all of that said here are my favorite top 10 in no particular order.

Zulu - blue glimmer\pearl
Lucky 13 - bullfrog
Double willow spinner bait - chartreuse
Berkley Power tube - bleeding watermelon
Pop-R - blue\shad
Mepps spinner - size 3 or larger - silver blade\white bucktail
Floating Rapala - size 11 - black and silver
Buzzbait - black
Rebel Craw - 2 1/2 inch version - chartreuse
Tiny Torpedo - bullfrog

Can't wrong here......... fish on!
"


:):) I've never used any of those...I do use a tube close to the bleeding watermelon, and I have also used a texas RED wee craws, but all the others.......NOPE.

I find it amazing what people end up catching fish with. Most of my stuff is soft plastic, or jigs.

Later,

Geo
 
lundojam
distinguished member(2730)distinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished member
  
02/22/2012 08:37PM  
Senko
senko under a slip bobber
leech
original floater
skitter pop
BP offers a real sleeper, the cleo. I've caught tons of smallies on a little cleo.
twister tail
jig and a minnow
husky jerk
shad rap
 
Bdubguy
distinguished member(611)distinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished member
  
02/22/2012 08:44PM  
This is fun to think about....
- 4 in powerbait jig worm, green pumkin, 1/8 oz black mushroom jig head (#1 for me, we're on the same page Basspro69)
- 3 in power bait twister tail, pumpkin seed, 1/8 oz gold jig (#2)
- husky jerk
- x-Rap
- #9 floating rap, perch (topwater)
- Pop-R
- Swimbait, yum money minnow, 1/2oz jig head
- swimbait, Sebile magic swimmer, up til now my secret bait, expensive, but deadly on smallies and pike
- spinnerbait, 3/8 oz white, dbl willow

This doesn't include trolling or live bait. I'll be adding mepps, zulus and senkos to my list.

 
Arlo Pankook
distinguished member(2534)distinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished member
  
02/23/2012 08:04AM  
Oooo, Money Minnows yeah, yeah!

And a 1oz. Crippled Herring in the fall.
 
PaddleAway
distinguished member(980)distinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished member
  
02/23/2012 08:43AM  
Only thing I haven't seen mentioned is a Junebug sinking Gulp! My go-to for any type of bass anywhere.
 
Mad_Angler
distinguished member(1720)distinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished member
  
02/23/2012 08:52AM  
quote PaddleAway: "Only thing I haven't seen mentioned is a Junebug sinking Gulp! My go-to for any type of bass anywhere. "


I've seen a few mentions to "Junebug". I looked through the gulp site and can't find it. What is it? How do you use it?
 
Gravy33
distinguished member (169)distinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished member
  
02/23/2012 09:06AM  
quote Basspro69: "1. 4 inch Berkley Powerworm Black On 1/8 ounce Charlie Brewer Spider slider head, My number one by far for numbers of fish and big fish, responsible for 30 to 35 smallies over 5 pounds. Use it in clear water mostly.
2. Spinnerbait Black with gold blades.
3. Floating Rapala
4. Road Runner 1/16 ounce yellow white or chartreuse.
5. Tube Jig
6. Mepps 2 or 3 Dressed with Silver gold or firetiger blades.
7. Rattlin Rapala Blue and Silver or Crayfish colored.
8. Jerkbait.
9. Black Jitterbug possibly my favorite lure of all time fun fun fun.
10. Little Cleo
I have to mention that when all these fail, which is almost never, or I just want some down time from casting, a hook bobber and leech will get it done for you also. "


I'm right with ya Basspro69 I do like the black 4" berkley power worm with the chartreuse tail and camo worms too. A single hook rig is so much easier to unhook also and release so you can catch the next one !

BUT a jitterbug is by far the the most fun and those big boys really like them !
 
toddhunter
distinguished member(543)distinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished member
  
02/23/2012 09:19AM  
Oh no! Does this mean I have to bring my Jitterbug now?
 
keithcatfish
distinguished member (232)distinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished member
  
02/23/2012 09:29AM  
Quetico Mike,

I almost always rig senkos weightless, texas style if the fish are in fallen trees or thick weeds, wacky if cover is light. A 2/0 wide gap worm hook works fine. I like the 4" baits in any shade of green, green/brown, purple or black.
 
toddhunter
distinguished member(543)distinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished member
  
02/23/2012 11:09AM  
quote Mad_Angler: "
quote PaddleAway: "Only thing I haven't seen mentioned is a Junebug sinking Gulp! My go-to for any type of bass anywhere. "



I've seen a few mentions to "Junebug". I looked through the gulp site and can't find it. What is it? How do you use it?"

I'm not sure what a sinking Gulp is, but Junebug refers to a popular color, kind of blue/purple.
 
chesapeakes
distinguished member (440)distinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished member
  
02/23/2012 02:07PM  
One lure for me.
Senko in root beer.
 
jb in the wild
distinguished member(2651)distinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished member
  
02/23/2012 06:37PM  
Ordered these from BPS and I am looking forward to trying them wacky and drop-shot.

BPS

Have you seen the new hooks from VMC made to drop-shot will make things a lot easier.

VMC

Floating Raps, Tubes and Jerk Baits.


JB
 
QueticoMike
distinguished member(5280)distinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished memberpower member
  
02/24/2012 09:00AM  
quote GeoFisher: "
quote QueticoMike: "
Here is my list for favorite smallmouth lures. All of these don't pertain to strictly the Boundary Waters\Quetico. Some work better on my river in Ohio. I do use a lot of them at both locations. I do not have the standard jig or twisty tail on my list. The only reason is because I don't care for jigging or being snagged all of the time. I do use tube baits though. So with all of that said here are my favorite top 10 in no particular order.


Zulu - blue glimmer\pearl
Lucky 13 - bullfrog
Double willow spinner bait - chartreuse
Berkley Power tube - bleeding watermelon
Pop-R - blue\shad
Mepps spinner - size 3 or larger - silver blade\white bucktail
Floating Rapala - size 11 - black and silver
Buzzbait - black
Rebel Craw - 2 1/2 inch version - chartreuse
Tiny Torpedo - bullfrog


Can't wrong here......... fish on!
"



:):) I've never used any of those...I do use a tube close to the bleeding watermelon, and I have also used a texas RED wee craws, but all the others.......NOPE.


I find it amazing what people end up catching fish with. Most of my stuff is soft plastic, or jigs.


Later,


Geo"


I must not be using anything you use then either....... strange....somehow we still manage to catch a few fish :)
 
QueticoMike
distinguished member(5280)distinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished memberpower member
  
02/24/2012 09:02AM  
quote jb in the wild: "Ordered these from BPS and I am looking forward to trying them wacky and drop-shot.


BPS


Have you seen the new hooks from VMC made to drop-shot will make things a lot easier.


VMC


Floating Raps, Tubes and Jerk Baits.



JB"


Hey JB,

Have been watching the Linders again on the weekend? :)
Saw those VMC hooks too, really like the way they look and work, thinking about giving them a try as well.
 
02/24/2012 09:04AM  
Loads of senko lovers here.
Anyone loving the hair?! Kicks tail, especially in current. Check out:
http://www.jimmydsriverbugs.com/

Can't even count or tell you how many sows have fell for his riverbugs!!
 
Arlo Pankook
distinguished member(2534)distinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished member
  
02/24/2012 11:08AM  
quote QueticoMike: "
quote keithcatfish: "senko
senko
senko
senko
senko
senko
zara puppy
shad rap
green/brown grub
buzzbait



In that order."



How are you rigging your senko? Never used one, but I am interested. Best color?"

Some good tips here...could be t.m.i. Wacky Senco Video
 
northallen
distinguished member(666)distinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished member
  
02/24/2012 11:25AM  
Lots of great ideas here. I'll add 2 more:
- Texas rigged Powerbait Skirtgrub or lizard (lose lots of tails on the lizards)
- prefer Panther Martins over Mepps; especially in current
 
02/24/2012 02:34PM  
Out here (CA), I prefer a brown Wordens Rooster Tail, #3 Mepps w/ copper blade, Senko rigged wacky or a small popper (fly rod).

I seem to have abandoned my favorites when I go to the BW. There, I have used Heddon's surface plugs (Spook, Tiny Torpedo) the Original Rapala and leeches.

I think the switch occurred because I was influenced by other people's BW favorites in old threads on this site, on the theory that you should listen to the locals. I never really thought about that until this thread. Reflecting, I realized that I have never taken a Rooster Tail, Senko or small popper (maybe because I haven't taken a fly rod) to the BW.

Leeches do double duty (both smallies and walleye). My most success has occurred with leeches and perhaps that is why I haven't thought about my oversight much.
 
tom m
distinguished member(535)distinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished member
  
02/24/2012 02:35PM  
Drop shot any plastic worm and I like the blue fox inline spinners over the mepps myself.
 
Basspro69
distinguished member(14135)distinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished membermaster membermaster member
  
02/24/2012 03:38PM  
quote Sobi: "Loads of senko lovers here.
Anyone loving the hair?! Kicks tail, especially in current. Check out:
http://www.jimmydsriverbugs.com/


Can't even count or tell you how many sows have fell for his riverbugs!! "
Nice smallie !
 
Arlo Pankook
distinguished member(2534)distinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished member
  
02/24/2012 04:37PM  
quote Sobi: "Loads of senko lovers here.
Anyone loving the hair?! Kicks tail, especially in current. Check out:
http://www.jimmydsriverbugs.com/


Can't even count or tell you how many sows have fell for his riverbugs!! "

Those are great looking jigs too. I'll be putting in an order for sure.

The link again-Jigs
 
02/25/2012 07:08AM  
I checked out the site. Looks good! I'll be fishing Gabro & Blad Eagle lakes Boundary Waters, first week of July. Interested to know which ones you had the most fortune with catching Walleye and Small Mouth. Sizes, colors, etc.Good looking Small Mouth!!!
 
mc2mens
distinguished member(3311)distinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished member
  
02/25/2012 10:22AM  
1.Bobber, hook, slip shot and a leech
2.Bobber, hook and a leech
3.Slip bobber, slip shot, hook and a leech
4.Slip shot, hook and a leech
5.Jig and a leech
6.Lindy rig tipped with a leech (fishing for walleye, but catching a smallie)
7.Bottom bounce setup, tipped with a leech (fishing for walleye, but catching a smallie)
8.Husky Jerk (if for some reason, the leeches aren’t working)
9.Shad Rap (if for some reason, the leeches aren’t working)
10.Skitter Pop (if for some reason, the leeches aren’t working)

I catch 10 times more smallies with live bait than I do with a lure. The lures come out only, and I mean only, if the leeches aren't working.
 
mr.barley
distinguished member(7230)distinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished memberpower member
  
02/25/2012 11:02AM  
I'm looking for something that DOESN'T catch SMB. Please help me.
 
Bdubguy
distinguished member(611)distinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished member
  
02/25/2012 04:43PM  
Arlo - good video on wacky rigging. Maybe TMI, but some good tips. Senko's definitely on my list for this year... I would add rattlin-rap to my previous list, chrome blue and crawdad red. Good pike bait as well.
 
bassnut
distinguished member(1340)distinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished member
  
02/25/2012 08:02PM  
To QueticiMike: I am from the south, and you are from de norte...I understand the regional...differnces. With that in mind: I offer.
Topwater: SMB: buzzbait:dark...lowlight...BIGfish time...Spook(3/4oz.)lower light...work erratic, work slow...work like you are struggling to get somewhere, anywhere
Bottom: 3 to 4in. grub(tube, curlytail straight) just be helpless
Horizontal: 3-5in. curly tail grub(1/16 to 3/8oz. round head jig), brand (whatever), below 48degress think marabou/feathers....Spinnerbait, Crankbait(be careful, work erratic)
DON'T be a slave to a brand...best action/ lure is one that YOU impart the action.
"Budwiesher" lure will catch fish IF worked properly, knot great, hooks sharp.
Do you trust YOUR sharp hooks?
Do you trust your KNOT?
From the package "they sat our hooks are sharp".
Sharp hooks(YOU sharpen the hooks), great action(YOU impart the action).
Top Ten lures? My imagintion...MY IMAGINATION..a Senko...a Sluggo...a CRANK!!...
Imagination catches fish...a Thoreau moment catches fish.
After a half a lifetime fishing for money(sponsors...life on the line) it is THE ACTION YOU IMPART THAT IS THE DIFERENCE...not Rap,Strike King...not Lurh Jensen.
Fish in das boot is sharp hooks, great knots, fresh line. Think of all the BIG fish WE have all lost at the boat...
Please, all of us, DO NOT BECOME BRAND WHORES...lot's of lures catch fish...impart action, sharpen hooks, use fresh line. WE will all lose good fish...fault ours, fault not ours...please strive to eliminate our faults
 
Bdubguy
distinguished member(611)distinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished member
  
02/26/2012 07:20PM  
Interesting points Bassnut. I had made a post a bit ago regarding non-rapalas, concerned I might be missing some effective options being the rapala whore that I am (never considered myself a whore before:)). To me it's about confidence. I'm sure you can catch fish on bargain bin stuff, but I am more confident with baits I have had success with in the past. To me that's worth something....

Mr Barley asks a simple question, what doesn't catch SMB's. Seems to be referencing all the different ideas posted. There is no one answer. There's lots of different thoughts, ideas, experiences and opinions. That's what makes it fun and why I enjoy this site.
 
QueticoMike
distinguished member(5280)distinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished memberpower member
  
02/27/2012 07:04AM  
quote mc2mens: "1.Bobber, hook, slip shot and a leech
2.Bobber, hook and a leech
3.Slip bobber, slip shot, hook and a leech
4.Slip shot, hook and a leech
5.Jig and a leech
6.Lindy rig tipped with a leech (fishing for walleye, but catching a smallie)
7.Bottom bounce setup, tipped with a leech (fishing for walleye, but catching a smallie)
8.Husky Jerk (if for some reason, the leeches aren’t working)
9.Shad Rap (if for some reason, the leeches aren’t working)
10.Skitter Pop (if for some reason, the leeches aren’t working)


I catch 10 times more smallies with live bait than I do with a lure. The lures come out only, and I mean only, if the leeches aren't working."


Yep....that is why the thread list is for the top smallmouth lures and not the top live bait. This is just to help people who can not use live bait in Quetico or are looking for an alternative to live bait. Sometimes live bait can't be beat and other times I will kill with lures when nothing is hitting live bait.

Top live baits for smallmouth in no particular order:

Crawdad ( mud puppy, crawfish, crawdaddy, crayfish, mini lobster )
Leech ( notice that there is no A in Leech (LeAch)....bugs me when people can't spell LEECH )
Cisco
Creek Chub
Night Crawler
Grass hopper
Cricket
Frog
Minnow
Shiner
 
Basspro69
distinguished member(14135)distinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished membermaster membermaster member
  
02/27/2012 07:22AM  
quote mc2mens: "1.Bobber, hook, slip shot and a leech
2.Bobber, hook and a leech
3.Slip bobber, slip shot, hook and a leech
4.Slip shot, hook and a leech
5.Jig and a leech
6.Lindy rig tipped with a leech (fishing for walleye, but catching a smallie)
7.Bottom bounce setup, tipped with a leech (fishing for walleye, but catching a smallie)
8.Husky Jerk (if for some reason, the leeches aren’t working)
9.Shad Rap (if for some reason, the leeches aren’t working)
10.Skitter Pop (if for some reason, the leeches aren’t working)


I catch 10 times more smallies with live bait than I do with a lure. The lures come out only, and I mean only, if the leeches aren't working."
Ive had to use leeches maybe 3 times in 30 years to catch smallies, you just dont need em for smallmouth, now walleyes are a different story . p.s. However it is fun occasionally to toss a bobber and leech just to watch the bobber go down for smallies .
 
Arlo Pankook
distinguished member(2534)distinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished member
  
02/27/2012 07:42AM  
quote mr.barley: "I'm looking for something that DOESN'T catch SMB. Please help me."
Fair comment.
 
QueticoMike
distinguished member(5280)distinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished memberpower member
  
02/27/2012 07:43AM  
quote Basspro69: "
quote mc2mens: "1.Bobber, hook, slip shot and a leech
2.Bobber, hook and a leech
3.Slip bobber, slip shot, hook and a leech
4.Slip shot, hook and a leech
5.Jig and a leech
6.Lindy rig tipped with a leech (fishing for walleye, but catching a smallie)
7.Bottom bounce setup, tipped with a leech (fishing for walleye, but catching a smallie)
8.Husky Jerk (if for some reason, the leeches aren’t working)
9.Shad Rap (if for some reason, the leeches aren’t working)
10.Skitter Pop (if for some reason, the leeches aren’t working)



I catch 10 times more smallies with live bait than I do with a lure. The lures come out only, and I mean only, if the leeches aren't working."
Ive had to use leeches maybe 3 times in 30 years to catch smallies, you just dont need em for smallmouth, now walleyes are a different story . p.s. However it is fun occasionally to toss a bobber and leech just to watch the bobber go down for smallies ."


They aren't called "bobbers" anymore, I was watching Roland Martin one day and he called them "strike indicators". Big, round, red and white strike indicators with a big ol' shiner on the hook. Thought that was funny, so now when people say did you use a float or bobber, I just tell them I used a strike indicator. I used an actual strike indicator on fly line before while fly fishing and that was the only time I had heard of them until Roland started calling bobbers strike indicators. Still find that funny.
 
QueticoMike
distinguished member(5280)distinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished memberpower member
  
02/27/2012 08:10AM  
quote Arlo Pankook: "
quote mr.barley: "I'm looking for something that DOESN'T catch SMB. Please help me."
Fair comment."


Sounds like Mr. Barley needs to start his own thread...LOL :)

He could try throwing one of those huge musky, double bladded, bucktail lures. I never caught a smallmouth with one of those. He might get a pike though :)
 
mc2mens
distinguished member(3311)distinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished member
  
02/27/2012 08:33AM  
quote QueticoMike: "
quote mc2mens: "1.Bobber, hook, slip shot and a leech
2.Bobber, hook and a leech
3.Slip bobber, slip shot, hook and a leech
4.Slip shot, hook and a leech
5.Jig and a leech
6.Lindy rig tipped with a leech (fishing for walleye, but catching a smallie)
7.Bottom bounce setup, tipped with a leech (fishing for walleye, but catching a smallie)
8.Husky Jerk (if for some reason, the leeches aren’t working)
9.Shad Rap (if for some reason, the leeches aren’t working)
10.Skitter Pop (if for some reason, the leeches aren’t working)



I catch 10 times more smallies with live bait than I do with a lure. The lures come out only, and I mean only, if the leeches aren't working."



Yep....that is why the thread list is for the top smallmouth lures and not the top live bait. This is just to help people who can not use live bait in Quetico or are looking for an alternative to live bait. Sometimes live bait can't be beat and other times I will kill with lures when nothing is hitting live bait.


Top live baits for smallmouth in no particular order:


Crawdad ( mud puppy, crawfish, crawdaddy, crayfish, mini lobster )
Leech ( notice that there is no A in Leech (LeAch)....bugs me when people can't spell LEECH )
Cisco
Creek Chub
Night Crawler
Grass hopper
Cricket
Frog
Minnow
Shiner"


I know that. I was just being a smartass.
 
toddhunter
distinguished member(543)distinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished member
  
02/27/2012 09:55AM  
quote QueticoMike: "
quote Arlo Pankook: "
quote mr.barley: "I'm looking for something that DOESN'T catch SMB. Please help me."
Fair comment."



Sounds like Mr. Barley needs to start his own thread...LOL :)


He could try throwing one of those huge musky, double bladded, bucktail lures. I never caught a smallmouth with one of those. He might get a pike though :)"

My best sm bass last year in the BW was on a large Mepps bucktail. Not quite a musky bait, but a surprise nonetheless. It would be hard to find a bait they wouldn't at least try to hit (sometimes). Then there are times they won't hit anything.
 
02/27/2012 10:54AM  
Im just going to do a few:

Culprit 4" ribbon tailed worm. Red belly, black back. Wonderful action on these and can be worked an endless number of ways.

Berkeley powerbait, 4" curly tailed grub. Brown, black, white or chartreuse. Tried a lot of different brands/styles of this style bait, these have worked the best.

Original floating black/silver rapala. Tried and true multipurpose lure. Have had insane fishing with these lures.

Storm popper, any color, skirted rear treble hook, rattles. Great topwater bait, like this one particularly because the rear of the bait drops under the surface which seems to cause more strikes and better hooking percentage.
 
03/01/2012 07:54AM  
Sorry for the delay... been fishing in the BW!! The River Bugs I use are typically the 1/8oz variety in olive, gray, cream, bumblebee or black. I like the duller colors best for the bronze backs. For the eyes the white to cream to yellow combo's are normally better. Jim also makes the walleye weenies that are similar to the river bug but lack the dual feather tail. I use them plain but you could tip with a minnow too. He is really accommodating so if you have a color combo in mind that you don't see on the site just describe to him what you want. So back to the BW and Parent Lake. 2 flags in 2 days, not the greatest action but the one made for a great dinner and the remains will be pickled.
 
03/01/2012 09:07AM  
Here's a nice river eye from last spring that ate one of his river bugs. I call this the bumblebee which is a darker version of his typical yellow bug.
 
CrappieDay
member (8)member
  
03/03/2012 10:39AM  
Question for Basspro69:
I'm curious about your "1. 4 inch Berkley Powerworm Black On 1/8 ounce Charlie Brewer Spider slider head, My number one by far for numbers of fish and big fish, responsible for 30 to 35 smallies over 5 pounds. Use it in clear water mostly."

How do you work that. I'm assuming on the bottom. Do you work it slow and just pull along and keep a tight line to feel the lure, or do you try to keep in in one place and shake it? I haven't tried this method, but I could see it being productive. Thanks for any advice you can give.
 
Basspro69
distinguished member(14135)distinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished membermaster membermaster member
  
03/03/2012 05:27PM  
quote CrappieDay: "Question for Basspro69:
I'm curious about your "1. 4 inch Berkley Powerworm Black On 1/8 ounce Charlie Brewer Spider slider head, My number one by far for numbers of fish and big fish, responsible for 30 to 35 smallies over 5 pounds. Use it in clear water mostly."


How do you work that. I'm assuming on the bottom. Do you work it slow and just pull along and keep a tight line to feel the lure, or do you try to keep in in one place and shake it? I haven't tried this method, but I could see it being productive. Thanks for any advice you can give.
"
Cast out let it hit bottom and bounce hop bounce for about 10 feet or so, if not hit by then I just swim it back. If they are really active I swim it with twitches, very effective smallie lure . p.s. If theres been a major cold front I let it sit for up to a minute before I move it, and then very small subtle movements afer that.
 
CrappieDay
member (8)member
  
03/03/2012 07:48PM  
Thanks BP, great info. Now I have to pick some of those up tomorrow, lol. Thanks again
 
Basspro69
distinguished member(14135)distinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished membermaster membermaster member
  
03/03/2012 10:57PM  
Your welcome crappie, good luck with it, the powerworm really is an excellent lure. p.s. Walleye and Northerns occasionally chow on them also.
 
bwcasolo
distinguished member(1919)distinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished member
  
03/04/2012 06:57AM  
i have used cbrewer heads and black 4 inch power worms for 20 plus years, throw in a 3.5 inch spook as well.
 
03/04/2012 07:49AM  
I didn't notice anyone mention the Five of Diamonds!
 
QueticoMike
distinguished member(5280)distinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished memberpower member
  
03/05/2012 11:27AM  
quote Ray59: "I didn't notice anyone mention the Five of Diamonds! "


I don't think many people use a big spoon for smallmouth up there. Those darn pike always get in the way :-)
 
QueticoMike
distinguished member(5280)distinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished memberpower member
  
03/05/2012 11:28AM  
quote Basspro69: "
quote CrappieDay: "Question for Basspro69:
"
Cast out let it hit bottom and bounce hop bounce for about 10 feet or so, if not hit by then I just swim it back. If they are really active I swim it with twitches, very effective smallie lure . p.s. If theres been a major cold front I let it sit for up to a minute before I move it, and then very small subtle movements afer that. "


Hey BP69,

Thinking about drop shotting a 4" black Powerworm up there, have you ever done that?

QM
 
Basspro69
distinguished member(14135)distinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished membermaster membermaster member
  
03/05/2012 03:36PM  
quote QueticoMike: "
quote Basspro69: "
quote CrappieDay: "Question for Basspro69:
"
Cast out let it hit bottom and bounce hop bounce for about 10 feet or so, if not hit by then I just swim it back. If they are really active I swim it with twitches, very effective smallie lure . p.s. If theres been a major cold front I let it sit for up to a minute before I move it, and then very small subtle movements afer that. "



Hey BP69,


Thinking about drop shotting a 4" black Powerworm up there, have you ever done that?


QM"
I havent Mike, the presentation with the slider head has been so effective that I havent really had to deviate from it. Im sure it would work just fine though .
 
toddhunter
distinguished member(543)distinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished member
  
03/06/2012 10:10AM  
quote QueticoMike: "
quote Basspro69: "
quote CrappieDay: "Question for Basspro69:
"
Cast out let it hit bottom and bounce hop bounce for about 10 feet or so, if not hit by then I just swim it back. If they are really active I swim it with twitches, very effective smallie lure . p.s. If theres been a major cold front I let it sit for up to a minute before I move it, and then very small subtle movements afer that. "
Last year I brought drop shot rigs but never used them. A little fussy for canoeing, and snaggy, but I think the fish would annihilate them


Hey BP69,


Thinking about drop shotting a 4" black Powerworm up there, have you ever done that?


QM"
 
toddhunter
distinguished member(543)distinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished member
  
03/06/2012 10:21AM  
This was my part of the above post:
Last year I brought drop shot rigs but never used them. A little fussy for canoeing, and snaggy, but I think the fish would annihilate them.

 
Basspro69
distinguished member(14135)distinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished membermaster membermaster member
  
12/28/2012 10:34AM  
bump
 
QueticoMike
distinguished member(5280)distinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished memberpower member
  
12/28/2012 11:17AM  
I just checked my top ten from last year at the top of this thread and I see no reason to change any of the top ten, they are still my top 10. But I am always looking for the next magical lure. Should be interesting to see some new input.
 
CapitalCity
distinguished member (170)distinguished memberdistinguished memberdistinguished member
  
12/29/2012 02:41PM  
Chug Bug
Hoola Popper
Jig and a leach
Spinner bait with double willows.
Mepps

No need for 10, if they wont take any of these than I dont want to catch them!
 
      Print Top Bottom Previous Next