|
Boundary Waters Quetico Forum Trip Planning Forum Portage into Knife from Birch. |
Author
Text
07/17/2020 12:21PM
Ausable: "Can you provide a source for that information?
Portage 76 is on the US side, according to this site's map. Did you mean Portage 698?"
I was told by the outfitter.
And, yes, I agree...the map indicates that the portage is on the US side. I don't know how to reconcile that.
So, it begs the question. What if a smarmy canadian bureaucrat is staked out waiting to make a point?
After looking at Google Earth, it is clear that the Canadian portage (698) is the one being used. Has anyone bushwhacked the lower one? I have done the upper portage maybe a dozen times...never needed to concern myself about which side of the border I was on.
07/17/2020 02:37PM
It’s portage 912 the last portage going into Knife lake that is on the Canadian side. I had a discussion previously about this since my outfitter told me the same thing that it’s supposed to be closed.
In the other message it was discussed that people are still going through that portage. Basically that it doesn’t remove the treaty that allows citizens of both countries access. Through this shared portages which exist on both sides of the border but are in the borders.
Here is the link to the other thread.
https://bwca.com/index.cfm?fuseaction=forum.thread&threadId=1204490&forumID=16&confID=1
Title is Knife Lake Portage. I’ll give it a bump reply to get it back to top page.
In the other message it was discussed that people are still going through that portage. Basically that it doesn’t remove the treaty that allows citizens of both countries access. Through this shared portages which exist on both sides of the border but are in the borders.
Here is the link to the other thread.
https://bwca.com/index.cfm?fuseaction=forum.thread&threadId=1204490&forumID=16&confID=1
Title is Knife Lake Portage. I’ll give it a bump reply to get it back to top page.
07/17/2020 02:58PM
I took these portages in the first week of June and saw no evidence of closures. From everything I read, the formal border closure does not affect travel along border routes in the BWCA allowed by the treaty that Gaidin53 mentioned. I would press outfitters for more information. I think they are mistaken.
07/17/2020 03:02PM
I just spoke with another source sending crews into the BWCA that they are sending them through Big knife portage based on the treaty and the shared portion of the border.
Only other way to get to Knife would be Ensign to Vera to Knife and those are much longer portages to start a trip out with.
Ryan
Only other way to get to Knife would be Ensign to Vera to Knife and those are much longer portages to start a trip out with.
Ryan
07/17/2020 06:33PM
Gaidin53: "I just spoke with another source sending crews into the BWCA that they are sending them through Big knife portage based on the treaty and the shared portion of the border.
Only other way to get to Knife would be Ensign to Vera to Knife and those are much longer portages to start a trip out with.
Ryan"
Thanks all. I will print a copy of the treaty and take it with me.
This COVID stuff is trying my patience...flying in through MSP...yet another possible adventure!!
07/17/2020 07:38PM
Hundreds and hundreds of paddlers have gone through that portage so far this year, including me twice. Absolutely no sign of Canadians trying to keep US citizens from using it. It would be utterly and completely ridiculous for them to try as it would achieve nothing. They are trying to reduce the infection rates lower I their country, not trying to be vindictive or petty.
Please ask your outfitter if they would kindly supply their source of information. If they know something no one else seems to know, I’d be glad to know.
Please ask your outfitter if they would kindly supply their source of information. If they know something no one else seems to know, I’d be glad to know.
07/17/2020 08:14PM
Jaywalker: "Hundreds and hundreds of paddlers have gone through that portage so far this year, including me twice. Absolutely no sign of Canadians trying to keep US citizens from using it. It would be utterly and completely ridiculous for them to try as it would achieve nothing. They are trying to reduce the infection rates lower I their country, not trying to be vindictive or petty.
Please ask your outfitter if they would kindly supply their source of information. If they know something no one else seems to know, I’d be glad to know.
"
Agreed. The outfitter is one of the very very well known ones. Prolly just doing his job...like, you know, watching the BWCA video. No harm done.
Subscribe to Thread
Become a member of the bwca.com community to subscribe to thread and get email updates when new posts are added. Sign up Here