|
Boundary Waters Quetico Forum Fishing Forum Why no muskies? |
Author
Text
02/27/2008 08:14PM
Interesting question that I don't know the answer to. What's really weird is that about the only lake in the area that has a native pop of muskies that I know of is Shoepack on the Kabetogama Peninsula. They have been successfully introduced to a number of lakes, so it doesn't seem competition is an issue.
02/28/2008 10:58AM
A couple of years back a guy caught a Muskie out of Shagawa. Seems that some time in the past (70's or 80's?) the MNDNR was rearing Muskies at the now defunct rearing ponds on Burntside River. After a heavy rain, the ponds overflowed into the river.
If they're in Shagawa, I would imagine they're in Fall, Newton, Basswood, etc... although in extremely limited numbers.
If they're in Shagawa, I would imagine they're in Fall, Newton, Basswood, etc... although in extremely limited numbers.
Arrgghhh!
02/28/2008 06:30PM
It would be fun to have one lake deep in the interior of Quetico that is stocked with muskies. Maybe PooBah. It's difficult to get to but oh what fun that would be, catching big muskies in the Q.
"Life is not about finding yourself. Life is about creating yourself." --- George Bernard Shaw
03/19/2008 07:18PM
Muskies are not native to any of the BWCAW lakes. Their original distribution in Minnesota were the lakes and rivers of the upper Mississippi River watershed. East Pike Lake once had muskies due to an introduction, but these have since almost disappeared.
“Growth for the sake of growth is the ideology of the cancer cell.” -Edward Abbey
03/20/2008 05:18PM
I remember reading something about pike/muskie competition. In many waters, muskie and pike attempt to occupy the same niche. In those cases, pike have an edge in competition because they hatch out earlier than the muskies and the younger species becomes food for the older one. Pike eventually occupy those waters to the exculsion of muskies.
In some waters, pike and muskies co-exist. That is because they have found separate niches within the same lake.
In some waters, pike and muskies co-exist. That is because they have found separate niches within the same lake.
The business of life is the acquisition of memories. In the end that's all there is. ___Mr Carson (Downton Abby)
03/21/2008 10:46AM
i'm pretty sure i had a musky on in east pike-hardest fighting fish i ever hooked-muskies fight differently than pike-more savagely-i didn't get a good look at him though-he broke me off-i had stayed at a lodge on west fowl years before & the helper/guide told me there were "kahunas" in east pike-i believe him-plus i think the report on lakefinder mention them being stocked at one time-this area is sweet-i love to go there on sept trips
as always,cheers-wk
04/22/2008 01:41PM
I go up to East Pike every year because I'm a musky nut and love the bw and there are in there, just not a lot of them. The dnr stocked them back in 77 before stopping because they weren't a native fish so only a few have survived
Subscribe to Thread
Become a member of the bwca.com community to subscribe to thread and get email updates when new posts are added. Sign up Here