|
Boundary Waters Quetico Forum Listening Point - General Discussion Problem bear by Back Bay (Basswood) |
Author
Text
06/28/2020 02:28AM
This message has had HTML content edited out of it.
We heard of a very aggressive bear on the portage area near Back Bay.
Customer came in a day late because they couldn't go through the portage, the Forest Service (& maybe the DNR) closed it until they can "manage" the bear.
They told us that a young boy was on one side of the portage when the bear came very close to him. The boy went (or was) standing in the lake and tried to move down the shore and the bear also moved, sort of blocking his exit.
A canoe came by and picked up the boy. I don't know if it was part of his group, or a person doing a good deed.
All that seems quite clear is that this bear is way too aggressive and is not afraid of people at all and needs to be removed.
We heard of a very aggressive bear on the portage area near Back Bay.
Customer came in a day late because they couldn't go through the portage, the Forest Service (& maybe the DNR) closed it until they can "manage" the bear.
They told us that a young boy was on one side of the portage when the bear came very close to him. The boy went (or was) standing in the lake and tried to move down the shore and the bear also moved, sort of blocking his exit.
A canoe came by and picked up the boy. I don't know if it was part of his group, or a person doing a good deed.
All that seems quite clear is that this bear is way too aggressive and is not afraid of people at all and needs to be removed.
06/28/2020 09:24AM
I have always been told that, no matter the weather conditions, bears will adapt to eat whatever natural items are available. In dry years, when many folks blame increased campsite raids/human interactions on the lack of berries, etc, bears will actually switch over to opening logs and eating ants and other bugs, etc.
This year, many have noted the large increase in folks snapping up permits in an effort to get away and distance in the woods. Perhaps a lot of the increased reporting can be attributed to increased visitors. Perhaps it's partly due to inexperienced/careless campers out there in higher percentages right now.
And it pains me to see this happening on Agnes. Again.
Agnes, Alpine, Back Bay on Basswood... could the bears be going through the lakes in alphabetical order?? :-)
This year, many have noted the large increase in folks snapping up permits in an effort to get away and distance in the woods. Perhaps a lot of the increased reporting can be attributed to increased visitors. Perhaps it's partly due to inexperienced/careless campers out there in higher percentages right now.
And it pains me to see this happening on Agnes. Again.
Agnes, Alpine, Back Bay on Basswood... could the bears be going through the lakes in alphabetical order?? :-)
"You can observe a lot just by watching." -- Yogi Berra
06/28/2020 03:38PM
Not sure where the problem is...
Or maby some bears didnt get the memo they need to run away when encountering at human. ( yes I know most bears will run away )
The way I see it, Im in their back yard not mine.
Even habituated bears are just looking for a snack. ( again in their backyard)
Rogue and sick bears are something different that warrant attention.
I've have several encounters with bears, most ran away a couple didnt...I never consided them a problem.
Just my 2 cents.
Or maby some bears didnt get the memo they need to run away when encountering at human. ( yes I know most bears will run away )
The way I see it, Im in their back yard not mine.
Even habituated bears are just looking for a snack. ( again in their backyard)
Rogue and sick bears are something different that warrant attention.
I've have several encounters with bears, most ran away a couple didnt...I never consided them a problem.
Just my 2 cents.
06/28/2020 05:19PM
Interesting twist about bear potentially targeting a child. I've brought many a kid into the BWCA and not always right with me on a portage... something to consider. Glad another paddler was able to scoop him up!
Wherever there is a channel for water, there is a road for the canoe. -Thoreau
06/29/2020 12:19PM
BWPaddler: "Interesting twist about bear potentially targeting a child. I've brought many a kid into the BWCA and not always right with me on a portage... something to consider. Glad another paddler was able to scoop him up!"
Predatory bears commonly target smaller humans
06/29/2020 02:00PM
missmolly: "I like your screen name, Dan. What does it mean?"
I will surmise that Mr. D.B. Cooper is into I.C.P. and jumping out of planes with a suitcase full of cash.
Fate whispers to the warrior "You cannot withstand the storm" and the warrior whispers back "I am the storm". Unknown.
06/29/2020 02:05PM
I would caution everyone against speculating that there is an abnormal amount of problem bear activity this year and/or speculating about why we seem to be hearing more about it this year. It is a very good thing that people are regularly communicating with each other about their bear activity concerns, and it is especially great that they are sharing this information with the right people so often (outfitters, USFS). I know it is tempting to speculate, but just be happy and pump your fist in celebration at all the wonderful information sharing that is occurring. Leave it to the outfitters, USFS, and ecologists who have way more information than any of us have to speculate about what trends may or may not be real.
06/29/2020 03:13PM
mschi772: "I would caution everyone against speculating that there is an abnormal amount of problem bear activity this year and/or speculating about why we seem to be hearing more about it this year. It is a very good thing that people are regularly communicating with each other about their bear activity concerns, and it is especially great that they are sharing this information with the right people so often (outfitters, USFS). I know it is tempting to speculate, but just be happy and pump your fist in celebration at all the wonderful information sharing that is occurring. Leave it to the outfitters, USFS, and ecologists who have way more information than any of us have to speculate about what trends may or may not be real."
A lot of new people in the woods and on the lakes. I wonder if there are more reports about "problem" bears because it is so new/shocking to newcomers. I'd imagine a lot of reports might be like this for the same encounter:
BWCA veteran/board regular: "We saw a bear, here's what happened and what we did. Pretty cool."
New person on first trip: "We were almost killed by a blood-thirsty monster bear."
06/29/2020 06:20PM
I don't think there are more reports, just reports. The berries are just coming out in some abundance & when blueberries come out, that will help too.
We just try to let people know when a bear has been a bit pesky. If we can warn paddlers, maybe they don't stay in an area and the bear may learn it isn't such easy "pickings" after all. I'd rather have a bear learn than get shot as a nuisance bear.
This aggressive bear, especially one that decided to keep the kid from getting out of the water, is an especially dangerous situation for people. Maybe keeping the portage closed will do it but not likely if the Forest Service considers it aggressive enough to close the trail.
We just try to let people know when a bear has been a bit pesky. If we can warn paddlers, maybe they don't stay in an area and the bear may learn it isn't such easy "pickings" after all. I'd rather have a bear learn than get shot as a nuisance bear.
This aggressive bear, especially one that decided to keep the kid from getting out of the water, is an especially dangerous situation for people. Maybe keeping the portage closed will do it but not likely if the Forest Service considers it aggressive enough to close the trail.
07/07/2020 12:55PM
I went to Basswood in early June, camped west of Washington island. We had bear issues morning noon and night. It was a very large mom and a second or third year cub. They keep raiding the campsite next to us which had 9 guys in it. They did everything possible and they keep coming, yelling screaming throwing rocks even warning shots would not stop them. They just kept coming. Finally after leaving talked to the woman at prairie portage and she said there were multiple groups on basswood raiding camps with no regard to humans. Talked to the ranger and the DNR at Tower hoping someone would go out and take care of this issue.
07/09/2020 10:17AM
mackjakey: "They did everything possible and they keep coming, yelling screaming throwing rocks even warning shots would not stop them. They just kept coming. "
mackjakey when you say warning shots, you mean with a gun? And the bears had no reaction?
07/09/2020 11:13AM
Atom: "mackjakey: "They did everything possible and they keep coming, yelling screaming throwing rocks even warning shots would not stop them. They just kept coming. "
mackjakey when you say warning shots, you mean with a gun? And the bears had no reaction? "
Not uncommon for some bears to have no reactions to gun shots.
07/10/2020 12:56PM
VoyageurNorth: "We heard of a very aggressive bear on the portage area near Back Bay.
Customer came in a day late because they couldn't go through the portage, the Forest Service (& maybe the DNR) closed it until they can "manage" the bear.
I spoke with the Forest Service and they said there currently aren't any closed portages in the BWCAW right now.
07/10/2020 07:05PM
Hmm, I'm not sure about that. Unless they dealt with the bear but didn't mention it to me which is possible. Here is what they said in regards to the Back Bay portage.
"There are no closed portages in the BWCAW at this time, including the portage from Pipestone to Back Bay. The area you are referencing did have some recent bear activity with the latest bear report from that area occurring a little over a week ago. The Forest has seen plenty of bear activity so far this season, with most occurrences happening on the eastern side of the Wilderness."
Please keep us posted if you do hear anything from the Ely FS.
"There are no closed portages in the BWCAW at this time, including the portage from Pipestone to Back Bay. The area you are referencing did have some recent bear activity with the latest bear report from that area occurring a little over a week ago. The Forest has seen plenty of bear activity so far this season, with most occurrences happening on the eastern side of the Wilderness."
Please keep us posted if you do hear anything from the Ely FS.
07/10/2020 07:12PM
Will do. Don't know how they would have gotten it to "move" away or if it just moved away on its own. There is still a berry/food shortage for the bears and this bear seemed to be just hanging out in that area for quite some time.
07/12/2020 12:13AM
Darnit! We’d love to see a bear but not in camp or on a portage. This deal with the kid is scary! Someone else said in a different post I read if you leave camp to fish bring the food/smellables in the canoe with you. This year that makes a lot of sense. Northern Tier had posted about the Serviceberries being in season July 1st. Hopefully that helps feed the bears and keep them out of campsites.
Makes me debate on carrying on my trip coming up! Yes I have a CCP in Minnesota. Here is the deal though! I really would rather not. Last thing I’d want to do is harm a bear or honestly even fire a firearm to scare a bear in the BWCA. I’ve cleaned plenty of walleye on Lake of the woods during a long trip this year but I’m even debating If I want To harm a fish in the BWCA. Somehow it’s different for me.
Yup I know about keeping a clean camp. We couldn’t drop a speck of food last year. Whoever scraped the pot and ate it also added water to clean it and then drank that. My son didn’t realize the process and volunteered for a baked good pan. He dumped half a Nalgene in and had to chug it with the cake residue. I was pretty proud of him when he kept it down.
Happy everyone is communicating though and keeping everyone aware!
Ryan
Makes me debate on carrying on my trip coming up! Yes I have a CCP in Minnesota. Here is the deal though! I really would rather not. Last thing I’d want to do is harm a bear or honestly even fire a firearm to scare a bear in the BWCA. I’ve cleaned plenty of walleye on Lake of the woods during a long trip this year but I’m even debating If I want To harm a fish in the BWCA. Somehow it’s different for me.
Yup I know about keeping a clean camp. We couldn’t drop a speck of food last year. Whoever scraped the pot and ate it also added water to clean it and then drank that. My son didn’t realize the process and volunteered for a baked good pan. He dumped half a Nalgene in and had to chug it with the cake residue. I was pretty proud of him when he kept it down.
Happy everyone is communicating though and keeping everyone aware!
Ryan
07/12/2020 11:20AM
Just got out from this area on Friday. Went in with two boy scout troops. One group stayed next to Washington Island one night and the other was somewhere in that area the next night. Both groups ended up going through the portage in question over the next couple of days. I am happy to report that neither group encountered any bear activity.
"It is more important to live for the possibilities that lie ahead than to die in despair over what has been lost." -Barry Lopez
07/12/2020 11:50AM
There is a problem Bear here in the campground in Colorado too. It’s a big cinnamon Colored Black Bear. It scared a family out of their campsite and then ate their Birthday cake. Then it tipped over three dumpsters. The Pitkin County Sheriff came out and shot it with a bean bag. It was back in an hour. If you let a bear eat cake it’s hard to deter. DON’T let them eat cake!
07/12/2020 10:11PM
Zulu: " There is a problem Bear here in the campground in Colorado too. It’s a big cinnamon Colored Black Bear. It scared a family out of their campsite and then ate their Birthday cake. Then it tipped over three dumpsters. The Pitkin County Sheriff came out and shot it with a bean bag. It was back in an hour. If you let a bear eat cake it’s hard to deter. DON’T let them eat cake!"
Thanks for this warning! We will pack pies only on our next trip.
"God never made an ugly landscape. All that sun shines on is beautiful, so long as it is wild." - Muir
07/13/2020 05:50AM
Zulu: " There is a problem Bear here in the campground in Colorado too. It’s a big cinnamon Colored Black Bear. It scared a family out of their campsite and then ate their Birthday cake. Then it tipped over three dumpsters. The Pitkin County Sheriff came out and shot it with a bean bag. It was back in an hour. If you let a bear eat cake it’s hard to deter. DON’T let them eat cake!"
Non-lethal rounds as seen here are only temporary solution.
07/13/2020 07:34AM
acanoer: "Zulu: " There is a problem Bear here in the campground in Colorado too. It’s a big cinnamon Colored Black Bear. It scared a family out of their campsite and then ate their Birthday cake. Then it tipped over three dumpsters. The Pitkin County Sheriff came out and shot it with a bean bag. It was back in an hour. If you let a bear eat cake it’s hard to deter. DON’T let them eat cake!"
Non-lethal rounds as seen here are only temporary solution. "
Kind of like training a dog. I'd imagine bean bag rounds only work if it's consistent, and since they aren't going to get shot with one every time they try to raid a campsite, I doubt the bear will make the association.
Subscribe to Thread
Become a member of the bwca.com community to subscribe to thread and get email updates when new posts are added. Sign up Here