|
Boundary Waters Quetico Forum Listening Point - General Discussion BWCA paddler recounts near-death experience after capsizing during fishing opener weekend |
Author
Text
05/18/2022 10:22PM
Scary deal. Glad he had the navigation tools/skills to get out safely. Sounds like one key oversight was waterproofing the contents of his pack. Even if you capsize in warmer weather you should have clothes and sleeping gear protected from water. Glad he's ok.
05/19/2022 12:36PM
Got to give him a hand for going on the radio and talking about it. Some may feel embarrassed if it happened to them, but no doubt everyone who heard that piece did some reflection on their own safety kit and protocols. I think too often we see these beautiful photos and read reports of ideal trips. It’s good to be reminded sometimes things go wrong in a hurry and situations you never expected can creep up. Share those experiences too so others can learn. We all get better and safer that way.
05/19/2022 03:15PM
I also appreciate that he delivered his story. It is easy to stay quiet and not open yourself up to criticism, but listening to him helped me think about and examine my own techniques when canoeing solo.
"It is more important to live for the possibilities that lie ahead than to die in despair over what has been lost." -Barry Lopez
05/19/2022 06:43PM
Thanks for posting this. Pretty intense experience. It really gave me pause - we were in that area last summer but approaching the Royal River portage from the other direction. The water was so low that we had a heck-of-a-time finding the portage. And, you could have just about walked from the campsite he stopped at, across a spit of rocks to the other side.
05/19/2022 07:02PM
Went that way myself first portaging trip I did. We never found the portage and walked our canoe over the ‘rapids’. He missed the portage and almost got himself killed. What bugs me is he never mentioned the rescue for the canoe he rented. Left his mess for someone else to clean up. Sad story about someone unprepared and basically clueless. My take anyway.
05/19/2022 08:57PM
scat: "Went that way myself first portaging trip I did. We never found the portage and walked our canoe over the ‘rapids’. He missed the portage and almost got himself killed. What bugs me is he never mentioned the rescue for the canoe he rented. Left his mess for someone else to clean up. Sad story about someone unprepared and basically clueless. My take anyway."
The podcast episode I listened to said he was going back this weekend and hoped to get it all back. Pack and canoe and whatever else.
Plus IF the canoe was submerged and caught in a strainer....it would take more than the legal amount of people to get it dislodged. Wait for a bit lower water and hope you can make it happen.
05/20/2022 08:22AM
scat: "Went that way myself first portaging trip I did. We never found the portage and walked our canoe over the ‘rapids’. He missed the portage and almost got himself killed. What bugs me is he never mentioned the rescue for the canoe he rented. Left his mess for someone else to clean up. Sad story about someone unprepared and basically clueless. My take anyway."
Your compassion and tact are something we all strive for. Thank you for sharing your take. And, fyi, he paid the outfitter for the canoe.
"The future ain't what it used to be" Yogi Berra
05/20/2022 02:09PM
scat: "Went that way myself first portaging trip I did. We never found the portage and walked our canoe over the ‘rapids’. He missed the portage and almost got himself killed. What bugs me is he never mentioned the rescue for the canoe he rented. Left his mess for someone else to clean up. Sad story about someone unprepared and basically clueless. My take anyway."
The hell you'd expect him to do? Go swimming in 40 degree rapids to try to recover his canoe after he was already borderline hypothermic with no dry clothing? He said he's going to go back to try to get it. Jeez.
"God never made an ugly landscape. All that sun shines on is beautiful, so long as it is wild." - Muir
05/20/2022 07:14PM
Minnesotian: "
I also appreciate that he delivered his story. It is easy to stay quiet and not open yourself up to criticism, but listening to him helped me think about and examine my own techniques when canoeing solo. "
Well put! I used to spend quite a bit of time every year reading “Accidents in North American Mountaineering.” I too am a solo tripper with quite a bit of experience. Listening was very useful. It prompted me to go over my own approach and conditions assessment process, my capsize plan, my self rescue plan, and more. I even created a mock SOAP note (WFR, WMA). Thank you so much for this great learning opportunity.
Subscribe to Thread
Become a member of the bwca.com community to subscribe to thread and get email updates when new posts are added. Sign up Here