|
Boundary Waters Quetico Forum Gear Forum Sorry - but wet foot portage boots again |
Author
Text
06/25/2024 02:38PM
My 20 year Chota Caney Forks are failing and no longer available. And recommendations in previous threads are not always still available.
My best find so far seem to be the Astral Rassler. Available and in wide.
Wondered about Keen Voyageur Mid but not sure they drain and no wides.
The favored NRS seems to keep feet dry and I like wet. My feet never feel so good as after a week of being wet all day.
Merrel is not clear.
Wet foot boots may be a dinosaur product.
My best find so far seem to be the Astral Rassler. Available and in wide.
Wondered about Keen Voyageur Mid but not sure they drain and no wides.
The favored NRS seems to keep feet dry and I like wet. My feet never feel so good as after a week of being wet all day.
Merrel is not clear.
Wet foot boots may be a dinosaur product.
06/25/2024 03:12PM
Bill,
The Rassler is a poor choice for its rather slick tread and thin footbed (8-9mm). I've used them in the past and while they work, I was not pleased with them and there's better out there. Magic Paddler wears the Keen Voyagers, likes them, drain pretty good for not being designed as a portage boot. If you can wait or will wait until August, Astral is re-releasing the TR1 Merge with some updates. I did a review with pics here in the Gear Forum just after 'Copia where their reps showed me the latest version, said it would be available in August. I see a lot of Merrill treads on the trails and have heard decent things about them. Not sure which model. Good luck with your search.
BTW, I do have an older but brand-new pair of Rassler's in black, size 11.5 that I'd happily part with if you're stuck on those, they're your size and/or you're looking for an interim solution. (or to anyone else out there looking at the Rassler....)
pd
The Rassler is a poor choice for its rather slick tread and thin footbed (8-9mm). I've used them in the past and while they work, I was not pleased with them and there's better out there. Magic Paddler wears the Keen Voyagers, likes them, drain pretty good for not being designed as a portage boot. If you can wait or will wait until August, Astral is re-releasing the TR1 Merge with some updates. I did a review with pics here in the Gear Forum just after 'Copia where their reps showed me the latest version, said it would be available in August. I see a lot of Merrill treads on the trails and have heard decent things about them. Not sure which model. Good luck with your search.
BTW, I do have an older but brand-new pair of Rassler's in black, size 11.5 that I'd happily part with if you're stuck on those, they're your size and/or you're looking for an interim solution. (or to anyone else out there looking at the Rassler....)
pd
portage dog
06/25/2024 03:53PM
I heard complains about Rassler 2.0 being not too hardy and having thin footbed, but it's not my experience. So far I put about 40 days on these shoes and they are still as good as new and my feet are well protected. For a reference my portaging weight averages at 300 lbs and I travel mostly rocky terrain.
"A man's got to know his limitations."
06/25/2024 04:36PM
Portage dog - sent an email.
Worry about the thin soul but like the higher boot. Loved my caney forks.
Size wise - candy forks are 11 and my oboz hiking shoes - which I love - are 13 W. Don't know where Astra sizes are.
Also through a bunch more glue on my Caney Forks. A short trip in 10 days - canoe trail work weekend.
Thank you all for posts!
Worry about the thin soul but like the higher boot. Loved my caney forks.
Size wise - candy forks are 11 and my oboz hiking shoes - which I love - are 13 W. Don't know where Astra sizes are.
Also through a bunch more glue on my Caney Forks. A short trip in 10 days - canoe trail work weekend.
Thank you all for posts!
06/25/2024 09:27PM
If you are looking for water boots they are definitely getting tougher to find.
If you want ankle support what about using an ankle brace with a water shoe? Better support than a high top shoe/boot. The current ankle braces are pretty easy to adjust and put on. I’d suggest a Trilok brace.
That would also give ya options on water shoes, I’d try to find one that is the most comfortable and has the best wet traction. Usually you can tell by the softness of the rubber. High volume road shoes have a more dense/harder rubber and water shoes will be softer, but if you use them for road work they wear quickly. Sort if liek if ya used winter/snow tires year round.
The other option is just use hiking shoes/boots. Won’t drain as well, but has everything else ya want.
T
If you want ankle support what about using an ankle brace with a water shoe? Better support than a high top shoe/boot. The current ankle braces are pretty easy to adjust and put on. I’d suggest a Trilok brace.
That would also give ya options on water shoes, I’d try to find one that is the most comfortable and has the best wet traction. Usually you can tell by the softness of the rubber. High volume road shoes have a more dense/harder rubber and water shoes will be softer, but if you use them for road work they wear quickly. Sort if liek if ya used winter/snow tires year round.
The other option is just use hiking shoes/boots. Won’t drain as well, but has everything else ya want.
T
“Many go fishing all their lives without knowing that it is not fish they are after.” Henry David Thoreau
06/28/2024 09:43AM
My initial impression of the Astral Rasslers is positive, though I would say they run just a hair small. With very thin socks they are still slightly snug in my normal size (10.5). I would likely be happier in an 11. My Astral brewers are 10.5s and those fit much better.
Just FYI.
Just FYI.
"I don't care what you believe. I care what you can prove." -Philosopher & Mathematician JJJ
06/28/2024 09:18PM
Hey Bill,
Check out the Orvis Ultralight Wading boots. I posted a note about them about 3 weeks ago. I have used about every footgear option available and I think I finally found an excellent solution with the Orvis boots. I wear Sealskinz socks with them and it is a great combination.
The boots are sturdy as heck, have great grip, and drain well. They provide great ankle support as well.
I will still probably go with something like Muck boots late in the season because of the warmth they provide, but the Orvis boots are hard to beat otherwise.
Mike
Check out the Orvis Ultralight Wading boots. I posted a note about them about 3 weeks ago. I have used about every footgear option available and I think I finally found an excellent solution with the Orvis boots. I wear Sealskinz socks with them and it is a great combination.
The boots are sturdy as heck, have great grip, and drain well. They provide great ankle support as well.
I will still probably go with something like Muck boots late in the season because of the warmth they provide, but the Orvis boots are hard to beat otherwise.
Mike
06/29/2024 04:47AM
northerncanoe: "Hey Bill,
Check out the Orvis Ultralight Wading boots. I posted a note about them about 3 weeks ago. I have used about every footgear option available and I think I finally found an excellent solution with the Orvis boots. I wear Sealskinz socks with them and it is a great combination.
The boots are sturdy as heck, have great grip, and drain well. They provide great ankle support as well.
I will still probably go with something like Muck boots late in the season because of the warmth they provide, but the Orvis boots are hard to beat otherwise.
Mike"
They drain well? I have just worn smart wool type socks under my Caney Forks - April through October.
06/29/2024 06:01PM
straighthairedcurly: "Not sure what you mean by "Merrill is not clear" but these Merrell boots have been my go to for wet footing for years now. I tried Keens but they fell apart too fast.
Merrell Moab 3 Mid "
Sorry. It was not clear to me they drained well. A lot of Moab models were advertised as waterproof.
06/29/2024 10:17PM
DanMN: "I found these work great good traction and drains well. Solomon jungle boots "I use these and they work extremely well. If I’m too early in spring I’ll add a Sealskinz, but if true wet-footin they can’t be beat IMHO
Rick B
06/30/2024 08:37PM
billconner: "straighthairedcurly: "Not sure what you mean by "Merrill is not clear" but these Merrell boots have been my go to for wet footing for years now. I tried Keens but they fell apart too fast.
Merrell Moab 3 Mid "
Sorry. It was not clear to me they drained well. A lot of Moab models were advertised as waterproof."
Moab are what the YMCA camp recommends for kids who will be getting their feet wet. When we went to REI they were one of the only boots they recommended for draining well.
Subscribe to Thread
Become a member of the bwca.com community to subscribe to thread and get email updates when new posts are added. Sign up Here