|
Boundary Waters Quetico Forum Gear Forum TP tablets |
Author
Text
06/28/2022 07:43AM
Though such compressed towels have been around for years, I never used them as TP, Liteload Towels
I do compress TP at home. Save 1/2 rolls or smaller, remove the cardboard core, vacuum seal them.
butthead
I do compress TP at home. Save 1/2 rolls or smaller, remove the cardboard core, vacuum seal them.
butthead
"never underestimate the power of stupid people in large groups" George Carlin
06/28/2022 09:25AM
Ahh, each tablet is 1 wipe. Before watching the video I thought it would be a whole roll, and couldn’t imagine what you’d do with a whole roll of wet tp !
I usually bring both tp and wet baby wipes. This would reduce how much stuff I bring.
While I do vacuum seal a partial roll of tp, I keep that as my emergency back up. Once you cut it open you can’t seal it again, so my daily supply is kept in a ziplock.
I usually bring both tp and wet baby wipes. This would reduce how much stuff I bring.
While I do vacuum seal a partial roll of tp, I keep that as my emergency back up. Once you cut it open you can’t seal it again, so my daily supply is kept in a ziplock.
06/28/2022 06:00PM
deerfoot: "TP tablets remind me of these. With a little care they can be re-used several times. One towel will last for a 3-4 day trip. "
I have used the above as towels. When I last worked I was located in a large county government building and I made friends with Steve a DD guy who worked there as a janitor. When he stopped by my cube to talk I noticed he had a number of the ends of large commercial tp rolls. He would drop them off every once in a while and I would buy him sodas. Even though I have been retired for quite awhile I still have a few left.
06/29/2022 11:07AM
tumblehome: "Holy crap, those are neat. I'm definitely going to buy some since they seem good for other things too besides poo.
I also will start bringing dehydrated H2O tablets for more space saving!
"
I would be very careful of those tablets. They contain concentrated amounts of di-hydrogen monoxide which has been know to cause all sorts of health issues like excessive urination and perspiration.
06/29/2022 05:51PM
My daughter gave me a pack of a dozen Coleman compressed travel towels for Christmas. At the time I was very skeptical and set them aside with the Bear Grylls survival flint/steel I received at the same time. Going through my gear a year later I tossed a couple in my tool kit, first aid kit and personal kit. They have their application and I have really appreciated them on the trail. No bigger than a life-saver candy, they blow up into very sturdy towels. If the TP tablets work as well as the towels they will become a part of my duty bag. Advertised as biodegradable, they might well be a great alternative to TP. Anyone poop in the rain before and clean up with wet paper TP? Perhaps I will write a review.
Also +++ on vacuum packing small rolls of TP. Great idea Butthead, I compress typical three day supply and keep them at the ready in several places in my kit. Why risk getting a whole roll wet? And it is a space saver too.
Also +++ on vacuum packing small rolls of TP. Great idea Butthead, I compress typical three day supply and keep them at the ready in several places in my kit. Why risk getting a whole roll wet? And it is a space saver too.
Never better, attitude is a choice.
06/29/2022 07:05PM
I did buy a 200 count package on Amazon today. These things look kinda neat. They even make big giant towels the size of a bar of soap.
If anything, I’m thinking stocking stuffers for my family. We like to buy each other goofy and practical gifts. But honestly, I’m taking some on my next trip, not to save space but I’m curious.
And yes, di-hydrogen monoxide is also an awful by-product of hydrogen combustion.
Tom
If anything, I’m thinking stocking stuffers for my family. We like to buy each other goofy and practical gifts. But honestly, I’m taking some on my next trip, not to save space but I’m curious.
And yes, di-hydrogen monoxide is also an awful by-product of hydrogen combustion.
Tom
06/30/2022 06:13AM
The ones I looked at are 100% cotton, which is cellulose like toilet paper, so should decompose in several months.
I had no real interest in these until I read comments from users here. Now, I might consider packing some of these.
I had no real interest in these until I read comments from users here. Now, I might consider packing some of these.
06/30/2022 08:29AM
We have never brought rolls of toilet paper since the first year when one of the boys left the roll out in the rain.
We moved to biodegradable wet wipes. No problem with getting wet. I can see these tablets as a replacement or backup. Standard tp just takes up too much space, has to be kept sealed and guys tend to use more of them in a wet wipe type product.
We moved to biodegradable wet wipes. No problem with getting wet. I can see these tablets as a replacement or backup. Standard tp just takes up too much space, has to be kept sealed and guys tend to use more of them in a wet wipe type product.
07/01/2022 12:03AM
Heyfritty: "straighthairedcurly: "I started using these 2 years ago and love them. Can't get anyone else in my family to even try them though. "
I thought this was a joke until straighthairedcurly commented."
I didn’t think it was a joke but it seemed like a good setup. But yeah, way to ruin it by saying they work.
I will ask though, why not just carry a small amount of TP in a ziplock? I’ve never been so short on space that I couldn’t do that. Sort of reminds me of when I saw chopsticks that unscrewed in the middle to make them more compact. Or ostensibly more compact. Could never figure out when that would fit easier in my pack than regular chopsticks.
07/01/2022 12:21AM
billconner: "The ones I looked at are 100% cotton, which is cellulose like toilet paper, so should decompose in several months.
I had no real interest in these until I read comments from users here. Now, I might consider packing some of these."
So, they are 100% cotton just like some clothing. Wood is about 50% cellulose. Cotton clothing and wood do biodegrade but slowly. I am not saying that these wipes don’t decompose quickly. Heck, maybe they decompose faster than tp. I just don’t know. I require more evidence. Tp bombs last long enough. How long will a wipe bomb last? ????
07/02/2022 09:48AM
tumblehome: "Holy crap, those are neat. I'm definitely going to buy some since they seem good for other things too besides poo.
I also will start bringing dehydrated H2O tablets for more space saving!
"
"Holy crap"? I see what you did there, tumblehome!
07/02/2022 09:49AM
Argo: "tumblehome: "Holy crap, those are neat. I'm definitely going to buy some since they seem good for other things too besides poo.
I also will start bringing dehydrated H2O tablets for more space saving!
"
I would be very careful of those tablets. They contain concentrated amounts of di-hydrogen monoxide which has been know to cause all sorts of health issues like excessive urination and perspiration."
That was a fair and important warning, Argo! Even beyond what you've cited, in many cases di-hydrogen monoxide has been proven deadly!
07/02/2022 10:46AM
bobbernumber3: "Argo: "... They contain concentrated amounts of di-hydrogen monoxide..."
What is the source of this info?? Curious."
The instructions in the article linked in the very first post says that dihydrogen monoxide is required to expand the tablet to a wipe.
“ The process is simple. Take out the tablet, sprinkle water on it or dip it in water. Quickly, the tablet expands, so you can use it for whatever you need.”
But perhaps you were asking what type of info is available to suggest that dihydrogen monoxide is dangerous. Every canoeist should know at least one answer to that. It’s why you wear a pfd.
07/02/2022 10:53AM
bobbernumber3: "Argo: "... They contain concentrated amounts of di-hydrogen monoxide..."
What is the source of this info?? Curious."
Speaking for Argo, I believe it is in the product description as necessary for making these tablets functional to their intended purpose.
07/02/2022 11:09AM
bottomtothetap: "bobbernumber3: "Argo: "... They contain concentrated amounts of di-hydrogen monoxide..."
What is the source of this info?? Curious."
Speaking for Argo, I believe it is in the product description as necessary for making these tablets functional to their intended purpose."
I see... so it's not really IN the product. You have to add it. Wonder where you would get some? Sounds like it could be dangerous.
Still wondering about usage of the product.
07/02/2022 12:23PM
bobbernumber3: "bottomtothetap: "bobbernumber3: "Argo: "... They contain concentrated amounts of di-hydrogen monoxide..."
What is the source of this info?? Curious."
Speaking for Argo, I believe it is in the product description as necessary for making these tablets functional to their intended purpose."
I see... so it's not really IN the product. You have to add it. Wonder where you would get some? Sounds like it could be dangerous.
Still wondering about usage of the product."
Even though the use of di-hydrogen monoxide (DHMO) is often regulated, those that are looking for it will likely know where to find it. Should not be a problem for those on a BWCA trip who want to use the TP tablets.
07/02/2022 01:01PM
ockycamper: "I can see it now on our trip this fall. One of the boys comes up and asks for the tp. We give him a couple of "tablets" and send him off. Nothing bad could happen with that!"
Oh my! That boy probably has dihydrogen monoxide in his mouth and stomach. If he decides to eat the tablet, it would expand to a wipe, and those wipes are not flushable. I think it would clog his pipes.
TP tablets, dihydrogen monoxide and wipes, OH My!!!
07/02/2022 04:16PM
straighthairedcurly: "I started using these 2 years ago and love them. Can't get anyone else in my family to even try them though. "
So, I'm picturing wet toity paper....they must be stronger than regular TP. Are they the consistency of paper towel? Baby wipes?
07/03/2022 06:11AM
LarryS48: "ockycamper: "I can see it now on our trip this fall. One of the boys comes up and asks for the tp. We give him a couple of "tablets" and send him off. Nothing bad could happen with that!"
Oh my! That boy probably has dihydrogen monoxide in his mouth and stomach. If he decides to eat the tablet, it would expand to a wipe, and those wipes are not flushable. I think it would clog his pipes.
TP tablets, dihydrogen monoxide and wipes, OH My!!!"
You make fun of me for raising the issue. But don't you realize dihydrogen monoxide can be found in our lakes and rivers...even in baby food!!!
07/03/2022 07:19AM
Argo: "LarryS48: "ockycamper: "I can see it now on our trip this fall. One of the boys comes up and asks for the tp. We give him a couple of "tablets" and send him off. Nothing bad could happen with that!"
Oh my! That boy probably has dihydrogen monoxide in his mouth and stomach. If he decides to eat the tablet, it would expand to a wipe, and those wipes are not flushable. I think it would clog his pipes.
TP tablets, dihydrogen monoxide and wipes, OH My!!!"
You make fun of me for raising the issue. But don't you realize dihydrogen monoxide can be found in our lakes and rivers...even in baby food!!!"
To funny...
"In wilderness is the salvation of mankind." Thoreau.
07/03/2022 11:56AM
Back to reality.
The first pack of 100 arrived here the other day. It took me the better part of five minutes to soak it and pull it out to its maximum size, which is about 15 inches by six inches. This is not something you want to be doing while your nether regions are exposed to the bugs.
I cannot imagine relying on just one for accomplishing a single wipe at a latrine. Plan on needing at least two for that, and four for a couple of wipes, minimum. These will only make sense for latrine duty if you take the time to rehydrate and at least partially dry them in advance of needing them.
I do think they will be very handy for pre-filtering water and for wiping the insides of fish cavities after they've been dressed. Ditto for grouse and hare, but any form of big game would be better done with something larger.
The first pack of 100 arrived here the other day. It took me the better part of five minutes to soak it and pull it out to its maximum size, which is about 15 inches by six inches. This is not something you want to be doing while your nether regions are exposed to the bugs.
I cannot imagine relying on just one for accomplishing a single wipe at a latrine. Plan on needing at least two for that, and four for a couple of wipes, minimum. These will only make sense for latrine duty if you take the time to rehydrate and at least partially dry them in advance of needing them.
I do think they will be very handy for pre-filtering water and for wiping the insides of fish cavities after they've been dressed. Ditto for grouse and hare, but any form of big game would be better done with something larger.
07/04/2022 10:58AM
gravelroad: "Back to reality.
The first pack of 100 arrived here the other day. It took me the better part of five minutes to soak it and pull it out to its maximum size, which is about 15 inches by six inches. This is not something you want to be doing while your nether regions are exposed to the bugs.
I cannot imagine relying on just one for accomplishing a single wipe at a latrine. Plan on needing at least two for that, and four for a couple of wipes, minimum. These will only make sense for latrine duty if you take the time to rehydrate and at least partially dry them in advance of needing them.
I do think they will be very handy for pre-filtering water and for wiping the insides of fish cavities after they've been dressed. Ditto for grouse and hare, but any form of big game would be better done with something larger."
It takes be about 10 seconds to unpack one.
07/04/2022 11:31AM
Argo: "gravelroad: "Back to reality.
The first pack of 100 arrived here the other day. It took me the better part of five minutes to soak it and pull it out to its maximum size, which is about 15 inches by six inches. This is not something you want to be doing while your nether regions are exposed to the bugs.
I cannot imagine relying on just one for accomplishing a single wipe at a latrine. Plan on needing at least two for that, and four for a couple of wipes, minimum. These will only make sense for latrine duty if you take the time to rehydrate and at least partially dry them in advance of needing them.
I do think they will be very handy for pre-filtering water and for wiping the insides of fish cavities after they've been dressed. Ditto for grouse and hare, but any form of big game would be better done with something larger."
It takes be about 10 seconds to unpack one.
"
I have used the towel versions of these for years. I just pour a little water on the tablet, then peel apart. 15 seconds tops. Also, why would you want to dry out the tp tablets prior to use? They would function much better wet, like wet wipes.
07/05/2022 02:33PM
Argo: "gravelroad: "Back to reality.
The first pack of 100 arrived here the other day. It took me the better part of five minutes to soak it and pull it out to its maximum size, which is about 15 inches by six inches. This is not something you want to be doing while your nether regions are exposed to the bugs.
I cannot imagine relying on just one for accomplishing a single wipe at a latrine. Plan on needing at least two for that, and four for a couple of wipes, minimum. These will only make sense for latrine duty if you take the time to rehydrate and at least partially dry them in advance of needing them.
I do think they will be very handy for pre-filtering water and for wiping the insides of fish cavities after they've been dressed. Ditto for grouse and hare, but any form of big game would be better done with something larger."
It takes be about 10 seconds to unpack one.
"
I discovered that I erred by immersing the first one and soaking it. Adding just a bit of water allowed me to unroll a second one easily. These are going to be exceedingly handy.
07/06/2022 09:28PM
Mine arrived today. They are quite fascinating. I’ll admit, I bought them for the ‘cool’ factor. Some people buy butane stoves, others tarps and things. I bought TP tablets.
I am going to put one out back in the woods and observe the decomposition rate. Based on the strength of the wipe compared to regular TP, I can bet it will take much longer to decompose. Still, as long as it does decomposes in short order, I’ll give it two thumbs up. Or one bottom up depending on the use.
Tom
I am going to put one out back in the woods and observe the decomposition rate. Based on the strength of the wipe compared to regular TP, I can bet it will take much longer to decompose. Still, as long as it does decomposes in short order, I’ll give it two thumbs up. Or one bottom up depending on the use.
Tom
07/06/2022 09:55PM
tumblehome: "Mine arrived today. They are quite fascinating. I’ll admit, I bought them for the ‘cool’ factor. Some people buy butane stoves, others tarps and things. I bought TP tablets.
I am going to put one out back in the woods and observe the decomposition rate. Based on the strength of the wipe compared to regular TP, I can bet it will take much longer to decompose. Still, as long as it does decomposes in short order, I’ll give it two thumbs up. Or one bottom up depending on the use.
Tom"
I would be curious to learn the results of putting one out in the woods. If you also put some TP out with it, the comparison would be useful. Please let us know how your experiment comes out.
07/22/2022 06:40PM
Catrina: "The ends of the comercial TP rolls that Deerfoot mentioned are the best. I collect them too. Sorry, I need the real thing."
I sure wish I hadn’t lost my steady source of supply on the commercial tp roll remnants when I retired 16 years ago. I am down to my last two rolls as pictured above in an earlier post.
07/31/2022 02:36PM
gravelroad: "Back to reality.
The first pack of 100 arrived here the other day. It took me the better part of five minutes to soak it and pull it out to its maximum size, which is about 15 inches by six inches. This is not something you want to be doing while your nether regions are exposed to the bugs.
I cannot imagine relying on just one for accomplishing a single wipe at a latrine. Plan on needing at least two for that, and four for a couple of wipes, minimum. These will only make sense for latrine duty if you take the time to rehydrate and at least partially dry them in advance of needing them.
I do think they will be very handy for pre-filtering water and for wiping the insides of fish cavities after they've been dressed. Ditto for grouse and hare, but any form of big game would be better done with something larger."
Wow, what brand did you buy?! Mine take seconds and only a few dribbles of water to easily open up. I prep it while doing my business.
08/07/2022 10:57AM
tumblehome: "Mine arrived today. They are quite fascinating. I’ll admit, I bought them for the ‘cool’ factor. Some people buy butane stoves, others tarps and things. I bought TP tablets.
I am going to put one out back in the woods and observe the decomposition rate. Based on the strength of the wipe compared to regular TP, I can bet it will take much longer to decompose. Still, as long as it does decomposes in short order, I’ll give it two thumbs up. Or one bottom up depending on the use.
Tom"
So, it’s been about a month now. Did you put a TP tablet/wipe and some real TP in the woods? If so, how are they looking?
Subscribe to Thread
Become a member of the bwca.com community to subscribe to thread and get email updates when new posts are added. Sign up Here