|
Boundary Waters Quetico Forum Group Forum: Solo Tripping only bring sawyer mini filter? |
Author
Text
07/09/2015 09:08AM
Hey, as I get closer to my 2nd solo I'm still working on ways to cut weight.
On my first solo I used our 4L sawyer gravity filter (seemed like overkill solo) and brought the sawyer mini as backup/on the go purposes. I'm thinking of just bringing the mini this time. I'll just boil unfiltered water for my dehydrated meals and coffee. Breakfast and lunch are cold/no cook meals.
Is there something I'm not thinking about that makes this a bad idea? I'll have pills for back up for drinking water.
On my first solo I used our 4L sawyer gravity filter (seemed like overkill solo) and brought the sawyer mini as backup/on the go purposes. I'm thinking of just bringing the mini this time. I'll just boil unfiltered water for my dehydrated meals and coffee. Breakfast and lunch are cold/no cook meals.
Is there something I'm not thinking about that makes this a bad idea? I'll have pills for back up for drinking water.
Ride EZ
07/09/2015 12:00PM
You will also have to bring more fuel for boiling all the water. On my solo trips I still bring the gravity filter.
"It is more important to live for the possibilities that lie ahead than to die in despair over what has been lost." -Barry Lopez
07/09/2015 12:33PM
quote Minnesotian: "
You will also have to bring more fuel for boiling all the water. On my solo trips I still bring the gravity filter. "
I'll boil the same amount of water....I just meant I will boil unfiltered water instead of filtered water (like I usually do from the gravity filter) for my coffee in the morning and dehydrated meals at supper. Then use the mini-filter for drinking water
I will say that I liked the convenience of the gravity filter in camp. It's like having a faucet in camp. When I needed water to boil I got it from the hanging filter in the cooking area instead of needing to walk down to the lake
Ride EZ
07/09/2015 12:41PM
Thanks for the ideas on other filters. They would definitely do the trick. I already have 2 filters so I don't want to buy another one. Just trying to decide if I should still bring them both or if the mini-filter alone will cut it.
Ride EZ
07/09/2015 08:11PM
quote TomT: "A Steripen is a great way to go on a solo. This price here is excellent. The sawyer mini is a good backup to bring.
"
Had one before the filters. Used it 2 seasons and When I tested it before a trip the 3rd season it didn't work anymore.
Ride EZ
07/10/2015 03:14AM
I have used the Sawyer Squeeze exclusively for all my solo trips this year. Works just fine but more labor intensive than the 2L Sawyer gravity system I have as you have to sit and squeeze vs. letting it run on its own. You also need to refill it more often.
I use the Sawyer Squeeze to fill a Nalgene 96 oz canteen in camp. I have a collapsible bucket that I fill with dirty water and fill the squeeze with that and filter into the Nalgene.
If I wanted to go lighter I could ditch the Nalgene and bucket and just squeeze into my cooking pot but I like the convenience of having the full Nalgene in camp.
I use the Sawyer Squeeze to fill a Nalgene 96 oz canteen in camp. I have a collapsible bucket that I fill with dirty water and fill the squeeze with that and filter into the Nalgene.
If I wanted to go lighter I could ditch the Nalgene and bucket and just squeeze into my cooking pot but I like the convenience of having the full Nalgene in camp.
07/10/2015 06:10AM
I got a Sawyer Squeeze a couple of years ago and also found it a good bit more time and labor intensive. Maybe I'm just lazy, but I like the ease and convenience of the gravity system. Sometime I may try one of the YouTube Sawyer conversions to a gravity system. I wouldn't care so much that it was slower if I didn't have to sit there and squeeze.
07/10/2015 08:25AM
Last year I replaced my Platypus 4L filter with a Sawyer mini because the Platypus filter seemed to be getting clogged frequently even after backflushing. The mini has been working fine for several trips now. I bring two empty 1 gal plastic vinegar jugs (they are thicker than milk jugs and last for years in canoe country) that I tie inside the bow and stern when traveling. One is used as the "clean" jug and the other I use to get "dirty" water from the middle of the lake prior to landing at the campsite.
The only "problem" I've had is at camp. The first gallon of water that goes through the filter results in air bubbles getting trapped in the line between the filter and the clean jug. So, I need to spend a few minutes squeezing the air bubbles out of the line so it flows faster. Once them line is free of bubbles, the jug fills up in 5-10 minutes. This problem occurs whenever the dirty bag becomes empty which allows air to enter the filter.
The solution of course, is too keep a liter or two of water in the dirty bag and shut off the flow before the dirty bag empties. Then when I add more water, it flows without the air bubbles forming in the line. Took me a trip or two to get this system down, but it makes purifying water simple and quick.
Lastly, on travel days, I use a Steripen for purifying my water.
The only "problem" I've had is at camp. The first gallon of water that goes through the filter results in air bubbles getting trapped in the line between the filter and the clean jug. So, I need to spend a few minutes squeezing the air bubbles out of the line so it flows faster. Once them line is free of bubbles, the jug fills up in 5-10 minutes. This problem occurs whenever the dirty bag becomes empty which allows air to enter the filter.
The solution of course, is too keep a liter or two of water in the dirty bag and shut off the flow before the dirty bag empties. Then when I add more water, it flows without the air bubbles forming in the line. Took me a trip or two to get this system down, but it makes purifying water simple and quick.
Lastly, on travel days, I use a Steripen for purifying my water.
Do what you can, with what you have, where you are -- Teddy Roosevelt
07/11/2015 12:14AM
quote cycle003: "When I use the squeeze, I do so in a gravity setup with no clean bag. I just use it like a tap and run water through it on demand. "
cycle- how long does it take to filter a half liter that way?
luft - How long does it take you with the Squeeze to fill the Nalgene canteen. When I tried the Squeeze it seemed to take an inordinate amount of effort and time. I must have been doing something not quite right. . .?
07/14/2015 12:02AM
Hmmmm. I didn't time it but it definitely takes me at least 1-1.5 minutes to empty my squeeze but I baby it because I have heard of the bags blowing out from too much force. I think it took 4-5 full "squeezes" to fill the nalgene.
I just got back from a trip and need to clean my filter out. I will do a timed test and let you know how long it takes to fill with city water.
I just got back from a trip and need to clean my filter out. I will do a timed test and let you know how long it takes to fill with city water.
07/14/2015 08:55AM
I have used the Sawyer Squeeze system on my solo trips for the last 2 years. It works really well, is light and compact. I have never run short of filtered water for food and drinking. If is slows down you just back flush it with filtered water. Never need to buy filter cartridges either. It is now my preferred filter method.
Want to make God laugh? Tell him your plans...
07/14/2015 09:36AM
I took liquid iodine on my solo, so much easier than dealing with a filter. I also started doing this when it's just me and my fiancee. The taste is negligible, no tinkering with filters. Only inconvenience is waiting 20 minutes once you fill up.
07/19/2015 05:39AM
I have the Sawyer minifilter with the squeeze system. When I go with Sherpa 1 and 2 I attach it to a 5 gallon bucket and hang it in a tree, a little slow it seems but we simply let it run into our Nagelene bottles when were in camp making supper or what ever, when I solo I have a 2liter Platypus bag the sawyer hooks up to, I carry the squeeze bag in case I have to get water from a stream. FRED
Grant me the senility to forget the people I never liked, the good fourtune to remember the ones do, and the eyesight to tell the differance.
08/15/2015 08:47AM
I decided to bring both the mini (needed it on the go on 2 hot travel days when I was drinking lots of water and went through all my water in my nalgene) and the 4 liter Sawyer gravity for in camp. I'm really glad I decided to bring both.
Ride EZ
08/15/2015 08:37PM
Last year I bought one of the Sawyer water bottles with the mini filter inside that you suck water through. I really liked that for drinking on the go rather than carrying a couple of liters or stopping to filter. It's easy for me to get dehydrated in the BW.
We also used my gravity system in camp; they are just so convenient.
We also used my gravity system in camp; they are just so convenient.
08/16/2015 06:32PM
I have been going back and forth on bringing 1 or 2 filters on my solos. I always bring the Sawyer Mini as it is just too small and light not to bring it along. I have found that I like the convenience of my Sawyer 2L gravity filter so I often bring the dirty bag, hose, and filter along and just filter right into a Nalgene collapsible canteen. I leave the clean bag and dispensing hose at home as it is just extra weight and bulk.
08/16/2015 08:24PM
quote boonie: "Last year I bought one of the Sawyer water bottles with the mini filter inside that you suck water through. I really liked that for drinking on the go rather than carrying a couple of liters or stopping to filter. It's easy for me to get dehydrated in the BW.
We also used my gravity system in camp; they are just so convenient."
I'm like you I use my mini when out on the go and the gravity filter when in camp. It's nice just to be able to fill it on the go while canoeing.
"Rivers know this: there is no hurry. We shall get there someday.” ~A.A. Milne
08/21/2015 05:55AM
I recently purchased a camelback uv water bottle. Hit the button and it's "safe" to drink in sixty seconds. Any bad reviews? Seems too good to be true but I didn't get sick...
If heaven ain't a lot like fishing, I dont wanna go
09/03/2015 06:52PM
I brought a sawyer mini and a full-sized sawyer filter with me. I used the mini almost exclusively the first few days. Then the mini really seemed to slow. I switched to the full size for cooking, and kept the mini for the 'in the boat' drinks.
09/03/2015 09:48PM
quote sueb2b: "I brought a sawyer mini and a full-sized sawyer filter with me. I used the mini almost exclusively the first few days. Then the mini really seemed to slow. I switched to the full size for cooking, and kept the mini for the 'in the boat' drinks. "
Did you try to back flush the mini when it slowed?
Subscribe to Thread
Become a member of the bwca.com community to subscribe to thread and get email updates when new posts are added. Sign up Here